omni_traditional_vs_roth
Compare pre-tax Traditional and post-tax Roth retirement savings across tax brackets to calculate spendable nest eggs and identify the better contribution strategy.
Instructions
Traditional vs Roth 401(k) / IRA Calculator. Compare pre-tax Traditional retirement savings against post-tax Roth contributions based on career income progression and tax brackets. Discipline: FINANCE. Governing mathematical model / formula: Roth Wealth = P · (1 - t_0) · (1 + r)ⁿ vs Traditional Wealth = [P · (1 + r)ⁿ] · (1 - t_n).
USAGE GUIDELINES:
WHEN TO USE: Invoke for deterministic calculation of roth_spendable (Roth Spendable Nest Egg), traditional_spendable (Traditional Spendable Nest Egg), winner_recommendation (Optimal Wealth Vehicle) using annual_contrib (Annual Contribution), current_tax (Current Tax Bracket (%) in %), retirement_tax (Retirement Tax Bracket (%) in %), years_invested (Years of Investing in yrs), annual_return (Annual Return (%) in %). Guarantees exact machine floating-point precision, eliminating LLM arithmetic mistakes and formula hallucinations.
WHEN NOT TO USE: Do not use for qualitative evaluations or unquantified reasoning. All input parameters must be valid numerical values.
DISAMBIGUATION & BOUNDARIES:
Use this dedicated specialist tool for 'Traditional vs Roth 401(k) / IRA Calculator' rather than generic dispatchers like omni_universal_query.
For multi-calculation chained jobs, use 'omni_batch_calculate'.
To inspect schema fields, see 'omni_describe_solver'.
BEHAVIOR & SAFETY:
Pure deterministic computation with machine floating-point precision.
Read-only, idempotent, and stateless. Zero side effects or persistent state mutations.
Input validation: All arguments are validated against physical and domain bounds. Out-of-bounds inputs return a safe diagnostic error status without throwing runtime exceptions.
RETURNS:
Structured JSON object containing:
status (string): "success" on valid execution or "error" if validation fails
calculator (string): "traditional-vs-roth"
category (string): "finance"
name (string): "Traditional vs Roth 401(k) / IRA Calculator"
formula (string): Governing mathematical formula string
inputs (object): Echoed input parameter dictionary with applied defaults
metrics (object): Dictionary of computed outputs:
metrics.roth_spendable (Roth Spendable Nest Egg): Formatted display string (e.g. '$573,950.00')
metrics.traditional_spendable (Traditional Spendable Nest Egg): Formatted display string (e.g. '$589,050.00')
metrics.winner_recommendation (Optimal Wealth Vehicle): Formatted display string (e.g. 'Traditional 401(k) Advantage (+2.6%)')
execution_time_ms (number): Latency in milliseconds.
Tool call template
This tool declares no required parameters. Add optional parameters from the input schema as needed.
{
"id": 1,
"jsonrpc": "2.0",
"method": "tools/call",
"params": {
"arguments": {},
"name": "omni_traditional_vs_roth"
}
}Input Schema
| Name | Required | Description | Default |
|---|---|---|---|
| current_tax | No | Current Tax Bracket (%) (%). Marginal tax bracket today. Default: 24. Min: 10. Max: 45. | |
| annual_return | No | Annual Return (%) (%). Annual compound return. Default: 7. Min: 3. Max: 14. | |
| annual_contrib | No | Annual Contribution. Annual investment amount. Default: 12000. Min: 1000. Max: 69000. | |
| retirement_tax | No | Retirement Tax Bracket (%) (%). Expected bracket when withdrawing. Default: 22. Min: 10. Max: 45. | |
| years_invested | No | Years of Investing (yrs). Timeline until retirement. Default: 25. Min: 5. Max: 45. |