DollhouseMCP

# Next Steps: Post-Security Fix Roadmap **Created**: August 12, 2025 **Context**: Following successful security fix (PR #594) and version persistence fix (PR #593) **Focus**: Security hardening, agent orchestration standardization, and feature development ## Immediate Actions (Next 24-48 Hours) ### 1. Production Monitoring 🔍 **Priority**: CRITICAL **Owner**: DevOps/Engineering Monitor the impact of security changes: - [ ] Watch error logs for false positive validations - [ ] Monitor performance metrics for validation overhead - [ ] Check user reports for any content installation issues - [ ] Verify no legitimate content is being blocked ### 2. Security Notification **Priority**: HIGH **Owner**: Security Team - [ ] Document CVE if applicable - [ ] Prepare security advisory for users - [ ] Update security documentation - [ ] Consider disclosure timeline ## Short-Term Goals (This Week) ### 3. Portfolio Cleanup Utility 🧹 **Priority**: MEDIUM **Complexity**: LOW **Ideal for**: Single agent task Create utility to clean up any malicious content that may have persisted before fix: ```typescript class PortfolioCleanup { // Scan portfolio for invalid/orphaned files async scanForOrphans(): Promise<OrphanedFile[]> // Validate all existing content async validateExisting(): Promise<ValidationReport> // Remove confirmed malicious content async cleanMalicious(): Promise<CleanupResult> // Generate audit report async generateReport(): Promise<SecurityReport> } ``` ### 4. Security Audit Automation 🤖 **Priority**: HIGH **Complexity**: MEDIUM **Ideal for**: Agent orchestration Set up automated security scanning: - [ ] GitHub Action for security audit on every PR - [ ] Daily security scan of main/develop branches - [ ] Weekly dependency vulnerability scan - [ ] Monthly comprehensive security audit ### 5. Expand SecureDownloader Usage 📥 **Priority**: MEDIUM **Complexity**: MEDIUM Migrate all download operations: - [ ] Identify all remaining download/fetch operations - [ ] Update to use SecureDownloader - [ ] Add appropriate validators - [ ] Update tests ## Medium-Term Goals (Next 2 Weeks) ### 6. Agent Orchestration Framework 🎭 **Priority**: HIGH **Complexity**: HIGH **Approach**: Opus orchestrator + multiple Sonnet agents Standardize the successful agent orchestration approach: ```markdown ## Agent Orchestration Template ### Orchestrator (Opus) Responsibilities: 1. Create comprehensive plan 2. Break down into agent tasks 3. Manage task dependencies 4. Review and integrate agent work 5. Maintain overall coherence ### Agent (Sonnet) Task Structure: - Clear, focused objective - Specific files/components to work on - Required patterns to follow - Integration points defined - Success criteria specified ### Example Task Delegation: - Agent 1: Core implementation - Agent 2: Test creation - Agent 3: Documentation - Agent 4: Integration fixes - Agent 5: Performance optimization ``` ### 7. Security Documentation Hub 📚 **Priority**: MEDIUM **Complexity**: LOW Create centralized security documentation: - [ ] `/docs/security/README.md` - Security overview - [ ] `/docs/security/PATTERNS.md` - Secure coding patterns - [ ] `/docs/security/CHECKLIST.md` - PR security checklist - [ ] `/docs/security/THREATS.md` - Known threats and mitigations - [ ] `/docs/security/TOOLS.md` - Security tools and utilities ### 8. Performance Benchmarking Suite 📊 **Priority**: MEDIUM **Complexity**: MEDIUM Benchmark validation performance: - [ ] Create performance test suite - [ ] Measure validation overhead - [ ] Identify optimization opportunities - [ ] Set performance budgets - [ ] Add to CI pipeline ## Long-Term Initiatives (Next Month) ### 9. Advanced Security Features 🔐 **Priority**: HIGH **Complexity**: HIGH **Approach**: Opus orchestrator + specialized agents #### Content Signing & Verification ```typescript interface SignedContent { content: string signature: string publicKey: string algorithm: 'RS256' | 'ES256' timestamp: Date } ``` #### Encrypted Downloads - End-to-end encryption for sensitive content - Key management system - Secure key exchange protocol #### Security Dashboard - Real-time threat monitoring - Validation metrics - Attack attempt tracking - Security event timeline ### 10. Comprehensive Attack Simulation 🎯 **Priority**: MEDIUM **Complexity**: HIGH Build attack simulation framework: - [ ] Automated penetration testing - [ ] Fuzzing framework - [ ] Attack scenario library - [ ] Vulnerability scanning - [ ] Red team exercises ### 11. Element System Security Hardening 🛡️ **Priority**: HIGH **Complexity**: MEDIUM Apply security patterns to all element types: - [ ] Skills: Parameter injection prevention - [ ] Templates: Template injection prevention - [ ] Agents: Goal injection prevention - [ ] Memories: Data leakage prevention - [ ] Ensembles: Privilege escalation prevention ## Agent Orchestration Best Practices Based on the successful PR #594 implementation: ### When to Use Agent Orchestration ✅ **Ideal for**: - Complex multi-component features - Security implementations - Large refactoring efforts - Cross-cutting concerns - Parallel development opportunities ❌ **Not needed for**: - Simple bug fixes - Single-file changes - Documentation updates - Configuration changes ### Orchestration Patterns #### Pattern 1: Parallel Implementation ``` Orchestrator ├── Agent 1: Component A ├── Agent 2: Component B ├── Agent 3: Tests for A & B └── Agent 4: Documentation ``` #### Pattern 2: Sequential Refinement ``` Orchestrator ├── Agent 1: Core implementation ├── Agent 2: Review & enhance Agent 1's work ├── Agent 3: Add tests based on final implementation └── Agent 4: Document final solution ``` #### Pattern 3: Specialized Expertise ``` Orchestrator ├── Agent 1: Security expert - threat analysis ├── Agent 2: Performance expert - optimization ├── Agent 3: UX expert - user interface └── Agent 4: Testing expert - comprehensive tests ``` ## Success Metrics ### Security Metrics - Zero security findings in audit - No malicious content persistence - 100% validation coverage - < 100ms validation overhead ### Development Metrics - 80% of complex features use agent orchestration - 100% of security fixes include tests - All PRs pass security audit - Documentation complete for all features ### Quality Metrics - Test coverage > 95% - Performance benchmarks passing - Security audit clean - Code review approval rate > 90% ## Resource Allocation ### Team Focus Areas 1. **Security Team**: Monitoring, auditing, threat analysis 2. **Core Team**: SecureDownloader adoption, element security 3. **DevOps**: CI/CD security, automation 4. **QA**: Security testing, attack simulation ### Agent Allocation Strategy - **Opus**: Reserved for orchestration of complex tasks - **Sonnet**: Implementation, testing, documentation - **Haiku**: Simple tasks, code formatting, basic fixes ## Risk Management ### Potential Risks 1. **Performance degradation** from validation overhead - Mitigation: Performance benchmarking and optimization 2. **False positive validations** blocking legitimate content - Mitigation: Comprehensive testing, user feedback monitoring 3. **Security bypass** through new attack vectors - Mitigation: Regular security audits, attack simulation 4. **Agent coordination overhead** - Mitigation: Clear templates, documented patterns ## Communication Plan ### Internal Communication - [ ] Team meeting to review security fix - [ ] Document agent orchestration success - [ ] Share lessons learned - [ ] Update development guidelines ### External Communication - [ ] Security advisory for users - [ ] Blog post on security best practices - [ ] Documentation updates - [ ] Community notification ## Training & Knowledge Sharing ### Security Training - Validate-before-write patterns - Atomic file operations - Security testing approaches - Threat modeling ### Agent Orchestration Training - When to use orchestration - How to delegate to agents - Integration patterns - Quality control ## Conclusion The successful security fix and agent orchestration approach from PR #594 provides a strong foundation for future development. By standardizing these patterns and continuing to prioritize security, we can build a robust and secure system while maintaining high development velocity. ### Key Takeaways 1. **Agent orchestration works** - Use it for complex tasks 2. **Security first** - Always validate before write 3. **Comprehensive testing** - Include attack vectors 4. **Clear documentation** - Essential for security 5. **Continuous improvement** - Regular audits and updates --- *Next steps defined. Ready to build on the success of PR #594 and the agent orchestration approach.*