DollhouseMCP

# PR #683 High Priority Fixes Coordination **Orchestrator**: Opus 4.1 **Date**: August 22, 2025 **Branch**: feature/qa-test-cleanup-665 **PR**: #683 **Status**: IN PROGRESS ## Review Summary PR #683 received 9/10 score with approval recommendation pending two high priority fixes. ## High Priority Fixes Required ### 1. Fix Race Condition in forceCleanup() **Issue**: The `forceCleanup()` method modifies shared CLEANUP_CONFIG which could affect concurrent cleanup instances. **Location**: `scripts/qa-cleanup-manager.js:641-653` **Current Code**: ```javascript // Temporary modification of shared config CLEANUP_CONFIG.MAX_AGE_MS = 0; ``` **Fix Required**: ```javascript async forceCleanup() { const originalMaxAge = this.maxAge; // Use instance variable try { this.maxAge = 0; // ... cleanup logic } finally { this.maxAge = originalMaxAge; } } ``` ### 2. Add Path Validation **Issue**: No validation that paths are within expected directories before deletion. **Location**: `scripts/qa-cleanup-manager.js:304-318` **Fix Required**: Add a method to validate paths are within safe directories: ```javascript isPathWithinSafeDirectories(filePath) { const safePaths = [ path.resolve(process.cwd(), 'docs/QA'), path.resolve(process.cwd(), 'test'), path.resolve(process.env.TEST_PERSONAS_DIR || path.join(homedir(), '.dollhouse/portfolio/personas')) ]; const resolvedPath = path.resolve(filePath); return safePaths.some(safe => resolvedPath.startsWith(safe)); } ``` Then use this validation before any deletion operations. ## Agent Assignment ### FIX-AGENT-1: Implement High Priority Fixes **Status**: COMPLETED ✅ **Model**: Sonnet 4 **Task**: Fix the race condition and add path validation **Specific Tasks**: 1. ✅ Fix race condition in forceCleanup() - use instance variables 2. ✅ Add isPathWithinSafeDirectories() method 3. ✅ Integrate path validation into cleanup methods 4. ✅ Test the fixes work correctly 5. ✅ Update coordination document when complete **Implementation Details**: - Added `maxAge` instance variable to constructor to avoid modifying shared `CLEANUP_CONFIG` - Created `isPathWithinSafeDirectories()` method to validate paths before deletion - Integrated path validation into all cleanup methods: - `cleanupFileArtifact()` - `cleanupPersonaArtifact()` - `cleanupPersonas()` - `cleanupResultArtifact()` - `cleanupTestResults()` - `cleanupDirectory()` - Updated `forceCleanup()` to use instance variables instead of shared config - All tests pass: syntax check, dry-run functionality, race condition fix, and path validation ## Medium/Low Priority Issues (For Future Issues) ### Medium Priority 1. **Configuration validation** - Validate CLEANUP_CONFIG values 2. **Error handling consistency** - Standardize throw vs log approach 3. **Performance metrics** - Add timing and statistics 4. **Environment variable support** - Make MAX_AGE_MS configurable 5. **Memory management** - Clear artifacts array after cleanup ### Low Priority 1. **Unit tests** - Add dedicated tests for TestDataCleanup 2. **Batch operations** - Batch file deletions for performance 3. **Async operations** - Use promises for better concurrency 4. **Cleanup scheduling** - Add scheduled cleanup capability ## Success Criteria - [x] Race condition fixed using instance variables - [x] Path validation implemented and integrated - [x] All existing tests still pass - [x] Dry-run mode still works correctly - [x] PR review comments addressed ## Testing ```bash # Test dry-run mode DRY_RUN=true node scripts/qa-simple-test.js # Test actual cleanup node scripts/qa-test-runner.js # Test force cleanup node scripts/qa-cleanup-manager.js --force ``` --- **Last Updated**: August 22, 2025, 2:40 PM EST by FIX-AGENT-1 (Sonnet 4) **Status**: HIGH PRIORITY FIXES COMPLETED ✅