DollhouseMCP

# Issue #665 - Test Data Cleanup Coordination Document **Orchestrator**: Opus 4.1 **Date**: August 22, 2025 **Branch**: feature/qa-test-cleanup-665 **Status**: IN PROGRESS ## Mission Objective Implement comprehensive test data cleanup mechanisms to prevent accumulation of test artifacts in both local and CI environments. ## Current State - ✅ QA tests running in CI (PR #677) - ⚠️ Tests create artifacts without cleanup - ⚠️ Every PR run adds more test data - 📋 Need cleanup before data accumulates ## Critical Requirements With QA tests now running on every PR to develop (from PR #677), cleanup is URGENT to prevent: - Test artifacts accumulating in CI - `docs/QA/` directory growing unbounded - Test personas persisting in portfolio - Performance degradation over time ## Agent Assignments ### CLEANUP-AGENT-1: Core Cleanup System **Status**: COMPLETE **Model**: Sonnet 4 **Task**: Create the test data tracking and cleanup framework **Specific Tasks**: - [x] Create `scripts/qa-cleanup-manager.js` with TestDataCleanup class - [x] Implement artifact tracking system - [x] Add cleanup methods for each artifact type - [x] Create test data identification system (prefixes, markers) - [x] Add cleanup verification logic **Progress**: - [x] Created comprehensive TestDataCleanup class - [x] Implemented artifact tracking with safety mechanisms - [x] Added cleanup methods for personas, files, and test results - [x] Included CI/local environment detection - [x] Added dry-run mode and safety validation - [x] Implemented age-based cleanup for test results - [x] Added comprehensive error handling and logging **Key Implementation**: ```javascript class TestDataCleanup { constructor(testRunId) { this.testRunId = testRunId; this.artifacts = []; } trackArtifact(type, identifier, path) { } async cleanupAll() { } async cleanupPersonas() { } async cleanupFiles() { } async cleanupTestResults() { } } ``` **Files Created**: - ✅ `scripts/qa-cleanup-manager.js` - Complete TestDataCleanup implementation **Implementation Details**: - **TestDataCleanup Class**: Core cleanup system with comprehensive artifact tracking - **Safety Mechanisms**: Prefix validation, dry-run mode, age-based cleanup - **Environment Detection**: Automatic CI/local environment adaptation - **Cleanup Scope**: Personas, files, test results, temporary artifacts - **Error Handling**: Robust error handling with detailed logging - **Command Line Interface**: Supports --stats, --force, and DRY_RUN modes **Key Features Implemented**: - Artifact tracking with metadata and timestamps - Intelligent test data identification using QA_TEST_ prefixes - Age-based cleanup (1-hour default for test results) - Portfolio persona cleanup with safety validation - QA directory cleanup with file type detection - Comprehensive logging with CI-specific formatting - Force cleanup mode for emergency situations - Statistics and reporting functionality **Testing Status**: ✅ VERIFIED - Successfully tested artifact tracking - Dry-run mode working correctly - Safety mechanisms validated - Real cleanup functionality confirmed ### INTEGRATION-AGENT-1: Script Integration **Status**: COMPLETE **Model**: Sonnet 4 **Task**: Integrate cleanup into all QA scripts **Specific Tasks**: - [x] Update `qa-test-runner.js` to use cleanup manager - [x] Add cleanup to `qa-github-integration-test.js` - [x] Update `qa-element-test.js` with cleanup - [x] Modify `qa-direct-test.js` and `qa-simple-test.js` - [x] Ensure cleanup runs even on failures (try/finally) **Progress**: - [x] Integrated TestDataCleanup into all 5 QA scripts - [x] Added unique test run IDs for each script type - [x] Implemented try/finally blocks to ensure cleanup always runs - [x] Added artifact tracking for personas, test results, and files - [x] Used consistent QA_TEST_ prefixes for all test data - [x] Added comprehensive error handling for cleanup failures **Integration Pattern Applied**: ```javascript const testCleanup = new TestDataCleanup(`QA_${SCRIPT_TYPE}_${Date.now()}_${Math.random().toString(36).substr(2, 9)}`); try { // Track created artifacts testCleanup.trackArtifact('persona', personaName, null, metadata); testCleanup.trackArtifact('result', filename, filepath, metadata); // Run tests... } finally { await testCleanup.cleanupAll(); // CRITICAL: Always runs } ``` **Files Successfully Modified**: - ✅ `scripts/qa-test-runner.js` - Added cleanup with legacy fallback - ✅ `scripts/qa-github-integration-test.js` - Integrated cleanup with GitHub artifacts - ✅ `scripts/qa-element-test.js` - Added cleanup for element tests and reports - ✅ `scripts/qa-direct-test.js` - Integrated cleanup for direct SDK tests - ✅ `scripts/qa-simple-test.js` - Added cleanup for simple connection tests **Key Implementation Details**: - **Unique Test Run IDs**: Each script generates unique IDs like `QA_TEST_RUNNER_1692693600000_abc123def` - **QA_TEST_ Prefixes**: All test data uses consistent prefixes (personas: `QA_TEST_PERSONA_*`, users: `QA_TEST_USER_*`) - **Try/Finally Blocks**: Every script guarantees cleanup execution even on test failures - **Comprehensive Tracking**: All artifacts tracked including personas, files, and test results - **Error Resilience**: Cleanup failures logged but don't break test execution - **CI-Aware**: Enhanced logging and error reporting for CI environments **Testing Status**: ✅ READY FOR TESTING - All scripts now have cleanup integration - Cleanup runs automatically on every test execution - Compatible with existing test workflows - No breaking changes to test functionality ## Implementation Strategy ### Test Data Identification All test data will use consistent prefixes: ```javascript const TEST_MARKERS = { PERSONA: 'QA_TEST_PERSONA_', ELEMENT: 'QA_TEST_ELEMENT_', FILE: 'qa_test_', RESULT: 'qa-test-result-', RUN_ID: `QA_${Date.now()}_${Math.random().toString(36).substr(2, 9)}` }; ``` ### Cleanup Scope 1. **File System**: - Test results in `docs/QA/` - Temporary test files - Test personas in portfolio 2. **In-Memory**: - Active elements - Cached data - Test configurations 3. **External** (if applicable): - GitHub test repositories - OAuth tokens - API resources ### Safety Mechanisms - **Prefix validation**: Only delete items with QA_TEST_ prefix - **Age check**: Optional - only delete items > 1 hour old - **Dry run mode**: Log what would be deleted without deletion - **Backup before delete**: Optional backup of items - **Verification**: Confirm cleanup success ## Testing Requirements ### Local Testing ```bash # Test cleanup in dry-run mode DRY_RUN=true node scripts/qa-test-runner.js # Test with real cleanup node scripts/qa-test-runner.js # Verify no test artifacts remain ls docs/QA/ | grep QA_TEST ``` ### CI Testing The cleanup will be automatically tested when this PR runs through the new QA workflow from PR #677. ## Success Criteria - [ ] No test artifacts remain after test completion - [ ] Cleanup executes even when tests fail - [ ] Only test data is removed (never real data) - [ ] Cleanup works in both local and CI environments - [ ] Performance overhead < 5% of test runtime - [ ] Clear logging of cleanup operations ## Agent Communication Protocol ### Status Updates Update your section with: - STARTED: Beginning work - IN PROGRESS: Active development - BLOCKED: Issue encountered - COMPLETE: Task finished - HANDOFF: Context limit approaching ### Progress Example ```markdown ### CLEANUP-AGENT-1 Progress - [x] Created qa-cleanup-manager.js - [x] Implemented TestDataCleanup class - [ ] Testing cleanup methods Status: IN PROGRESS ``` ### Blockers Document immediately: ```markdown ### BLOCKER: [Agent Name] Issue: Cannot delete personas - permission denied Needs: File system permissions or alternative approach ``` ## Commands for Agents ### Create branch (if needed) ```bash git checkout develop git pull origin develop git checkout -b feature/qa-test-cleanup-665 ``` ### Test commands ```bash # Run tests with cleanup node scripts/qa-test-runner.js # Check for remaining artifacts find docs/QA -name "*QA_TEST*" -type f find ~/.dollhouse/portfolio -name "*QA_TEST*" -type f ``` ### Commit message template ```bash git commit -m "feat: Implement test data cleanup mechanism - Add TestDataCleanup class for artifact tracking - Integrate cleanup into all QA scripts - Ensure cleanup runs even on test failures - Use consistent QA_TEST_ prefix for identification Fixes #665" ``` ## Priority Notes **THIS IS URGENT**: With PR #677 merged, every PR to develop now runs QA tests. Without cleanup, we'll accumulate test data rapidly in CI. This needs to be implemented and merged ASAP. ## References - Issue #665: Test data cleanup requirement - PR #677: QA tests now run on every PR (makes cleanup critical) - PR #662: Original QA framework --- **Last Updated**: August 22, 2025, 12:45 PM EST by INTEGRATION-AGENT-1 (Sonnet 4) - Integration Complete