DollhouseMCP

# PR #614 Review Coordination - Build Info Endpoints **Date**: August 17, 2025 **PR**: #614 - Build Info Endpoints with Service Architecture **Branch**: `feature/build-info-endpoints` **Status**: Open - Addressing review feedback ## Overview PR #614 adds build information endpoints to the MCP server with a clean service architecture pattern. The implementation passed all tests except 2 skipped automation-related tests and has one medium security issue to address. ## Review Summary ### Claude Review (Comprehensive) **Overall Rating**: Excellent Implementation (9/10) - Clean service pattern implementation - Comprehensive test coverage (58 tests) - Robust error handling - Good performance optimization ### Security Audit **Status**: 1 Medium Issue - **DMCP-SEC-004**: User input processed without Unicode normalization in BuildInfoService.ts - **Confidence**: Medium - **Location**: `/src/services/BuildInfoService.ts` ## Task Assignments ### Agent 1: Security Fix Specialist **Task**: Fix DMCP-SEC-004 Unicode normalization issue **Priority**: HIGH **Files to modify**: - `/src/services/BuildInfoService.ts` **Requirements**: 1. Add Unicode normalization for any user input 2. Review if BuildInfoService actually processes user input (it may be a false positive) 3. If no user input, add suppression comment 4. Follow SECURITY_FIX_DOCUMENTATION_PROCEDURE.md pattern ### Agent 2: Review Recommendations Analyzer **Task**: Analyze Claude's review recommendations **Priority**: MEDIUM **Focus areas**: 1. Path resolution resilience (line 167-169) 2. Container detection improvements (line 216) 3. Build timestamp fallback paths (line 190) **Deliverables**: - List of actionable improvements - Priority ranking - Implementation difficulty assessment ### Agent 3: Test Coverage Validator **Task**: Verify test coverage and identify gaps **Priority**: LOW **Files to review**: - `/test/__tests__/unit/services/BuildInfoService.test.ts` - Check if security fixes need additional tests ## Coordination Notes ### Current State - All functionality implemented and working - 58 tests passing - Build successful - CI checks mostly passing (2 skipped are automation-related) ### Critical Path 1. Fix security issue (blocks merge) 2. Address high-priority review recommendations 3. Document all changes 4. Update PR with summary of fixes ### Success Criteria - [ ] Security audit passes (0 findings) - [ ] All review recommendations addressed or documented - [ ] Tests still passing - [ ] PR comment added summarizing changes ## Agent Communication Protocol Each agent should: 1. Start by reading this coordination document 2. Review relevant files and context 3. Implement fixes with comprehensive documentation 4. Update this document with completion status 5. Report back with summary of changes ## File References ### Implementation Files - `/src/services/BuildInfoService.ts` - Main service (security fix needed) - `/src/tools/BuildInfoTools.ts` - MCP wrapper - `/src/services/ServerSetup.ts` - Integration point ### Test Files - `/test/__tests__/unit/services/BuildInfoService.test.ts` - Service tests - `/test/__tests__/unit/tools/BuildInfoTools.test.ts` - Tool tests ### Documentation - `/docs/development/SECURITY_FIX_DOCUMENTATION_PROCEDURE.md` - Fix pattern - `/docs/development/PR_BEST_PRACTICES.md` - PR guidelines ## Status Updates ### Security Fix - Agent 1 - [ ] Started - [ ] Issue analyzed - [ ] Fix implemented - [ ] Tests updated - [ ] Documentation added ### Recommendations - Agent 2 - [ ] Review analyzed - [ ] Priority list created - [ ] Implementation plan drafted ### Test Validation - Agent 3 - [ ] Coverage analyzed - [ ] Gaps identified - [ ] Additional tests recommended --- *Coordination document for PR #614 review fixes*