DollhouseMCP

# Issue #663 - CI/CD QA Integration Coordination Document **Orchestrator**: Opus 4.1 **Date**: August 22, 2025 **Branch**: feature/qa-cicd-integration-663 **Status**: IN PROGRESS ## Mission Objective Integrate QA automation scripts into the CI/CD pipeline to enable systematic testing and regression prevention. ## Current State - ✅ PR #672 merged - Config centralization complete - ✅ PR #676 created - Deprecated tools removed - ✅ QA scripts working with proper tool discovery - 📋 Need to add QA to CI workflows ## Agent Assignments ### CI-AGENT-1: Workflow Implementation **Status**: COMPLETE **Model**: Sonnet 3.5 **Task**: Create GitHub Actions workflow for QA tests **Specific Tasks**: 1. ✅ Create `.github/workflows/qa-tests.yml` 2. ✅ Configure to run on PR to develop branch 3. ✅ Set up proper environment variables 4. ✅ Add continue-on-error initially (non-blocking) 5. ✅ Configure test result reporting **Files Created/Modified**: - ✅ `.github/workflows/qa-tests.yml` (new) **Implementation Details**: - ✅ Runs only on develop branch PRs - ✅ Sets TEST_PERSONAS_DIR environment variable - ✅ Uses Node 20.x with npm cache - ✅ 10-minute timeout with continue-on-error: true - ✅ Uploads test results as artifacts (JSON + logs) - ✅ Creates PR comment summary with key metrics - ✅ Includes environment validation and error handling - ✅ Uses timeout command to prevent hanging - ✅ Graceful handling of missing jq for result parsing **Key Features**: - Environment validation before running tests - Proper artifact upload with retention policies - PR comment integration for visibility - Non-blocking initially as requested - Comprehensive error handling and logging - Compatible with existing CI infrastructure ### TEST-AGENT-1: Test Environment Setup **Status**: COMPLETE **Model**: Sonnet 4 **Task**: Ensure QA scripts work in CI environment **Specific Tasks**: 1. ✅ Update qa-test-runner.js for CI compatibility 2. ✅ Add CI detection logic 3. ✅ Configure proper paths for CI 4. ✅ Add error handling for CI-specific issues 5. ✅ Ensure cleanup happens even on failure **Files Modified**: - ✅ `scripts/qa-test-runner.js` - Added CI environment detection, proper cleanup, directory management - ✅ `scripts/qa-utils.js` - Added CI detection utilities, directory creation, CI-specific functions - ✅ `test-config.js` - Added CI-specific timeouts and test settings - ✅ `scripts/qa-simple-test.js` - Updated for CI compatibility - ✅ `scripts/qa-direct-test.js` - Updated for CI compatibility **Implementation Details**: - ✅ CI environment detection via multiple environment variables (CI, GITHUB_ACTIONS, etc.) - ✅ Increased timeouts in CI (doubled for most operations) - ✅ Proper docs/QA directory creation with CI-aware error handling - ✅ Test skipping logic for tests requiring GitHub tokens or file system access - ✅ Enhanced error reporting with CI-specific debugging information - ✅ Cleanup operations that run even on test failures - ✅ Environment metadata in test reports (CI vs Local) - ✅ Graceful handling of missing TEST_PERSONAS_DIR in CI **Key Requirements Met**: - ✅ Detect CI environment (GitHub Actions and other CI systems) - ✅ Use appropriate paths for CI (TEST_PERSONAS_DIR handling) - ✅ Handle missing personas directory gracefully - ✅ Clean up test artifacts with try/catch in finally blocks ## Implementation Plan ### Phase 1: Basic Integration (TODAY) 1. CI-AGENT-1 creates basic workflow file 2. TEST-AGENT-1 ensures scripts are CI-compatible 3. Test on a draft PR 4. Fix any issues found ### Phase 2: Enhanced Reporting (FUTURE) - Add test result parsing - Create status badges - Add performance tracking - Set up failure notifications ### Phase 3: Full Integration (FUTURE) - Remove continue-on-error - Make tests blocking for merge - Add to release workflow - Set up scheduled runs ## Success Criteria - [ ] QA tests run on every PR to develop - [ ] Test results visible in GitHub Actions - [ ] Scripts handle CI environment properly - [ ] No impact on existing workflows - [ ] Clear documentation added ## Known Constraints 1. TEST_PERSONAS_DIR must be set in CI 2. GitHub token needed for some tests 3. May need to skip certain tests in CI 4. Performance may vary in CI vs local ## Agent Communication Protocol ### Status Updates Agents should update their section with: - STARTED: Beginning work - IN PROGRESS: Active development - BLOCKED: Issue encountered (describe) - COMPLETE: Task finished - HANDOFF: Context limit approaching ### Progress Tracking ```markdown ### CI-AGENT-1 Progress - [x] Created .github/workflows/qa-tests.yml - [x] Configured PR targeting for develop branch only - [x] Set up TEST_PERSONAS_DIR environment variable - [x] Implemented continue-on-error: true (non-blocking) - [x] Added 10-minute timeout protection - [x] Configured artifact uploads for JSON results - [x] Added PR comment integration - [x] Included comprehensive error handling - [x] Updated coordination document with completion status ### TEST-AGENT-1 Progress - [x] Updated qa-test-runner.js with CI environment detection - [x] Added CI-specific configuration and error handling - [x] Implemented proper cleanup operations with try/catch/finally - [x] Enhanced qa-utils.js with CI detection utilities - [x] Updated test-config.js with CI-specific timeouts (doubled) - [x] Added directory creation utilities with CI logging - [x] Implemented test skipping logic for missing dependencies - [x] Updated qa-simple-test.js and qa-direct-test.js for CI compatibility - [x] Added environment metadata to test reports - [x] Updated coordination document with completion status ``` ### Blockers Document any blockers immediately: ```markdown ### BLOCKER: [Agent Name] Issue: Description Needs: What's required to unblock ``` ## Current Working Branch ```bash git checkout develop git pull origin develop git checkout -b feature/qa-cicd-integration-663 ``` ## Testing Commands ```bash # Test locally first node scripts/qa-test-runner.js # Test in CI-like environment CI=true TEST_PERSONAS_DIR=/tmp/test-personas node scripts/qa-test-runner.js # Check workflow syntax act -n # Uses nektos/act to test locally ``` ## References - Issue #663: Original requirements - PR #662: QA framework that needs integration - PR #671: Tool validation implementation - PR #672: Config centralization ## Notes for Agents - Keep changes focused and minimal - Test everything locally first - Document all decisions - Update this coordination doc frequently - If approaching context limit, document handoff clearly --- **Last Updated**: August 22, 2025, 9:40 AM EST by Opus Orchestrator **CI-AGENT-1 Completed**: August 22, 2025, 10:15 AM EST by CI-AGENT-1 (Sonnet 4) **TEST-AGENT-1 Completed**: August 22, 2025, 11:30 AM EST by TEST-AGENT-1 (Sonnet 4)