Scan for multi-attester disagreement
emem_memory_contradictionsDetect where independent sources disagree on the same cell, band, and time; return each conflict with a severity score and citations so you know when not to trust a single answer.
Instructions
Find where the corpus DISAGREES with itself (algebra: competing evidence). Two or more independent sources can sign different values for the same place, band and time. This tool returns that disagreement with a severity from 0 to 1 and a citation for each disputed fact. It does not pick one value and hide the conflict. It tells you when not to trust a single answer. Read the SCOPE before you quote a zero. By default it counts two kinds: two DIFFERENT attesters that disagree, and one responder that answers from two upstreams. disagreement_scope names the kind.
When to use: Call this before you rely on a number: 'do the sources agree on X', 'audit this claim'. Use cell_prefix for a region and band for one band family. min_severity removes small differences. Severity depends on the band kind: for a scalar, the spread over the band's range. For a vector, 1 minus the mean cosine. For a category, 1 minus the share of the mode. On a single-responder node, add include_same_attester_sources: true. There, the most likely disagreement is one signer that answers from two providers. Each record names its disagreement_scope. The receipt cites every disputed cid. To measure a pair, use emem_diff. To read the disagrees_with edge, use emem_edges_recall.
Example arguments: {"cell_prefix":"damO","band":"indices.ndvi","min_severity":0.2}
Tool call template
This tool declares no required parameters. Add optional parameters from the input schema as needed.
{
"id": 1,
"jsonrpc": "2.0",
"method": "tools/call",
"params": {
"arguments": {},
"name": "emem_memory_contradictions"
}
}Input Schema
| Name | Required | Description | Default |
|---|---|---|---|
| band | No | Band key filter (e.g. `indices.ndvi`). Omit to include all bands. | |
| cell | No | Alias for `cell_prefix`, and the spelling the rest of the surface uses for a cell64. Send a cell64 you already hold and the scan narrows to that place instead of running over the corpus. | |
| limit | No | Max contradictions to return. | |
| cell64 | No | Alias for `cell_prefix`. | |
| cell_prefix | No | A cell64 to scan, or a bytewise prefix of one (e.g. `defi.zb5f9`). Omit to scan the whole corpus up to the scan cap. A full cell64 is a prefix of itself, so passing one narrows the scan to exactly that place. | |
| min_severity | No | Severity floor in [0, 1]. 0 = report every disagreement, 1 = only flagrant. Severity scoring is per band kind: scalar (max-min over band range), vector (1 - mean cosine), categorical (1 - mode share). | |
| resume_after | No | The `resume_after` of a scan that stopped at its time budget. The scan continues from the next key. | |
| window_unix_s | No | [lo, hi] inclusive Unix-seconds filter on attestations' signed_at, all disagreeing attestations must fall in the window. | |
| include_same_attester_sources | No | Default true: also report keys where ONE attester answered from two upstreams (a changed `derivation.fn_key` or `sources[].scheme` set). A re-signed provider is a refresh and stays out. Each record names its `disagreement_scope`. Pass false for distinct attesters only. |