mcp-adr-analysis-server

# 📋 MCP ADR Analysis Server Documentation Improvement Plan **Comprehensive 4-Phase Plan to Achieve 90%+ Documentation Coverage** > **Current Status**: 35% Documentation Score | **Target**: 90%+ | **Timeline**: 4 Phases --- ## 🎯 Executive Summary Based on comprehensive gap analysis, we identified critical documentation deficiencies: - **318 undocumented functions** - **209 undocumented interfaces** - **29 undocumented classes** - **0% How-To coverage** - **Version mismatch** (docs show v2.0.7, codebase is v2.1.0) ## 📊 Current State Analysis ### ✅ Strengths - Well-organized Diataxis structure (tutorials, reference, explanation) - Comprehensive ADR documentation (9 ADRs) - Extensive test coverage (70+ test files) - Professional README and contributing guides ### ❌ Critical Gaps - **API Documentation**: 60% reference coverage - **How-To Guides**: 0% coverage - **JSDoc Comments**: Missing across codebase - **Version Sync**: Documentation outdated - **Prompting Guide**: Missing (now created ✅) --- ## 🚀 Phase 1: Critical Documentation Fixes (High Priority) ### 🎯 Objectives - Fix version mismatches - Create missing how-to guides - Document testing procedures - Update tool counts and references ### 📋 Tasks #### 1.1 Version Synchronization - [x] **API Reference**: Updated v2.0.7 → v2.1.0 ✅ - [ ] **Website Deployment**: Update GitHub Pages - [ ] **All Documentation**: Search and replace version references - [ ] **Tool Count**: Update from 37 to 18 core tools #### 1.2 How-To Guide Creation - [x] **Prompting Guide**: Comprehensive prompting strategies ✅ - [ ] **Installation Guide**: Step-by-step setup - [ ] **Testing Guide**: Document 70+ test files - [ ] **Deployment Guide**: Production deployment - [ ] **Troubleshooting Guide**: Common issues and solutions - [ ] **Configuration Guide**: Environment setup #### 1.3 Testing Documentation **Priority**: High (70+ test files undocumented) - [ ] **Test Setup Guide**: Jest configuration and setup - [ ] **Test Categories**: Unit, integration, performance tests - [ ] **CI/CD Testing**: GitHub Actions workflows - [ ] **Test Contribution**: Guidelines for new tests ### 🛠️ Documcp Actions for Phase 1 ```bash # Update existing documentation mcp1_update_existing_documentation --focusAreas=["version", "tools", "api"] # Generate missing how-to guides mcp1_populate_diataxis_content --includeProjectSpecific=true # Create testing documentation mcp1_generate_readme_template --templateType=documentation ``` ### ⏱️ Timeline: 1-2 weeks ### 👥 Effort: Moderate --- ## 🔧 Phase 2: API Documentation & JSDoc (High Priority) ### 🎯 Objectives - Document 318 undocumented functions - Add JSDoc to 209 interfaces and 29 classes - Create comprehensive API reference - Generate auto-documentation ### 📋 Tasks #### 2.1 JSDoc Implementation **Massive Undertaking**: 556 undocumented code elements - [ ] **Functions**: 318 functions need JSDoc comments - [ ] **Interfaces**: 209 interfaces need documentation - [ ] **Classes**: 29 classes need comprehensive docs - [ ] **Types**: Document complex type definitions #### 2.2 API Reference Enhancement - [ ] **Tool Documentation**: All 18 core tools - [ ] **Parameter Documentation**: Complete parameter lists - [ ] **Response Documentation**: Expected outputs - [ ] **Example Integration**: Real-world usage examples #### 2.3 Auto-Documentation Setup - [ ] **TypeDoc Integration**: Automated API docs - [ ] **OpenAPI/Swagger**: REST API documentation - [ ] **GitHub Actions**: Auto-generate on commits ### 🛠️ Documcp Actions for Phase 2 ```bash # Generate JSDoc templates mcp1_populate_diataxis_content --focusAreas=["api", "functions", "interfaces"] # Update API reference mcp1_update_existing_documentation --focusAreas=["api", "reference"] # Validate documentation mcp1_validate_content --includeCodeValidation=true ``` ### ⏱️ Timeline: 3-4 weeks ### 👥 Effort: Substantial (556 code elements) --- ## 📚 Phase 3: Advanced Documentation Features (Medium Priority) ### 🎯 Objectives - Enhance prompting guide with advanced techniques - Create workflow documentation - Add migration guides - Implement interactive examples ### 📋 Tasks #### 3.1 Advanced Prompting Documentation - [x] **Basic Prompting Guide**: Created ✅ - [ ] **Advanced Techniques**: Chain-of-thought, multi-tool workflows - [ ] **Tool-Specific Patterns**: Optimized prompts per tool - [ ] **Troubleshooting Prompts**: Error recovery strategies - [ ] **Performance Optimization**: Prompt efficiency tips #### 3.2 Workflow Documentation - [ ] **Multi-Tool Workflows**: Common tool combinations - [ ] **Enterprise Workflows**: Large-scale usage patterns - [ ] **CI/CD Integration**: Automated workflows - [ ] **Team Collaboration**: Multi-developer workflows #### 3.3 Migration & Upgrade Guides - [ ] **Deprecated Tools**: mcp0_manage_todo_json → mcp-shrimp-task-manager - [ ] **Version Migration**: v2.0.x → v2.1.0 changes - [ ] **Configuration Updates**: Breaking changes - [ ] **API Changes**: Tool signature updates ### 🛠️ Documcp Actions for Phase 3 ```bash # Setup advanced structure mcp1_setup_structure --includeExamples=true # Populate with project-specific content mcp1_populate_diataxis_content --populationLevel=intelligent # Create migration guides mcp1_generate_readme_template --templateType=documentation ``` ### ⏱️ Timeline: 2-3 weeks ### 👥 Effort: Moderate --- ## 🔍 Phase 4: Quality Assurance & Validation (Medium Priority) ### 🎯 Objectives - Validate all documentation for accuracy - Fix broken links and references - Ensure Diataxis compliance - Implement documentation testing ### 📋 Tasks #### 4.1 Content Validation - [ ] **Link Checking**: Validate all internal/external links - [ ] **Code Example Testing**: Ensure examples work - [ ] **Version Consistency**: All references up-to-date - [ ] **Accuracy Review**: Technical content verification #### 4.2 Diataxis Compliance - [ ] **Structure Validation**: Proper categorization - [ ] **Content Quality**: Each section serves its purpose - [ ] **Navigation Flow**: Logical user journeys - [ ] **Cross-References**: Proper linking between sections #### 4.3 Documentation Testing - [ ] **Automated Testing**: Doc tests in CI/CD - [ ] **Link Monitoring**: Continuous link validation - [ ] **Content Freshness**: Automated staleness detection - [ ] **User Feedback**: Documentation feedback system ### 🛠️ Documcp Actions for Phase 4 ```bash # Comprehensive validation mcp1_validate_content --validationType=all mcp1_check_documentation_links --check_external_links=true # Diataxis compliance check mcp1_validate_diataxis_content --confidence=strict # Deploy to GitHub Pages mcp1_deploy_pages --ssg=mkdocs ``` ### ⏱️ Timeline: 1-2 weeks ### 👥 Effort: Light to Moderate --- ## 📈 Success Metrics ### 🎯 Target Metrics - **Documentation Score**: 35% → 90%+ - **API Coverage**: 60% → 95%+ - **How-To Coverage**: 0% → 80%+ - **JSDoc Coverage**: 0% → 90%+ - **Link Health**: Unknown → 98%+ ### 📊 Tracking Progress - **Weekly Reviews**: Progress against phase objectives - **Automated Metrics**: Documentation coverage reports - **User Feedback**: Community input on documentation quality - **Usage Analytics**: Most accessed documentation sections --- ## 🛠️ Implementation Strategy ### 🔄 Iterative Approach 1. **Phase 1**: Foundation fixes (immediate impact) 2. **Phase 2**: API documentation (developer experience) 3. **Phase 3**: Advanced features (power users) 4. **Phase 4**: Quality assurance (long-term maintenance) ### 👥 Resource Allocation - **High Priority**: Phases 1-2 (immediate developer needs) - **Medium Priority**: Phases 3-4 (advanced features and quality) - **Continuous**: Link validation and content freshness ### 🚀 Quick Wins - [x] **Prompting Guide**: Created comprehensive guide ✅ - [x] **Version Fix**: Updated API reference to v2.1.0 ✅ - [ ] **Testing Docs**: Document extensive test suite - [ ] **Installation Guide**: Streamlined setup process --- ## 📋 Next Steps ### Immediate Actions (This Week) 1. **Complete Phase 1 Tasks**: Version sync, how-to guides 2. **Begin JSDoc Implementation**: Start with most-used functions 3. **Update Website**: Deploy corrected documentation 4. **Community Feedback**: Gather input on prompting guide ### Short-term Goals (Next Month) 1. **Complete API Documentation**: Full JSDoc coverage 2. **Advanced Prompting**: Enhance prompting guide 3. **Testing Documentation**: Complete test suite docs 4. **Validation Pipeline**: Implement doc testing ### Long-term Vision (Next Quarter) 1. **Documentation Excellence**: 90%+ coverage achieved 2. **Community Contribution**: Easy documentation contributions 3. **Automated Maintenance**: Self-updating documentation 4. **Best-in-Class UX**: Industry-leading documentation experience --- ## 🎯 Call to Action **Ready to transform your documentation from 35% to 90%+ coverage?** 1. **Start with Phase 1**: Fix critical gaps immediately 2. **Leverage Documcp**: Use MCP tools for efficient generation 3. **Community Input**: Gather feedback on prompting guide 4. **Iterate Rapidly**: Weekly progress reviews and adjustments **The comprehensive prompting guide is now ready - your users can immediately benefit from better prompting strategies while we work on the remaining phases.** --- _This plan leverages methodological pragmatism - systematic verification of each phase with explicit acknowledgment of effort and timeline constraints._