TASK-JWT-CONSOLIDATION-001-v1.0.0.mdā¢11.6 kB
# TASK: JWT Token Architecture Consolidation
**Task ID**: TASK-JWT-CONSOLIDATION-001
**Created**: July 2, 2025
**Owner**: Claude Code
**Priority**: MEDIUM (High for Phase 1)
**Type**: System Architecture Cleanup
**Estimated Duration**: 2-6 hours (phased approach)
---
## šÆ **TASK OBJECTIVE**
Consolidate JWT token management from multiple scattered file locations into a single, maintainable architecture to resolve sync issues, improve security, and reduce technical debt.
## š **BACKGROUND**
### **Issue Discovered**
During July 2, 2025 testing session, JWT token updates were not reflected in browser automation because tokens exist in multiple locations with inconsistent update status.
### **Current Problem**
- **5+ JWT token files** scattered across project structure
- **Manual synchronization** required for token updates
- **Debugging complexity** when determining which token is active
- **Security risk** from multiple token copies
- **Maintenance overhead** for keeping files in sync
### **Reference Documentation**
- **Analysis**: `/docs/analysis/jwt-token-architecture-issue-analysis-v1.0.0.md`
- **Current Implementation**: `dist/browser-automation-simple-fixed.js` (hardcoded paths)
---
## šļø **IMPLEMENTATION PHASES**
### **Phase 1: Immediate Consolidation (HIGH PRIORITY)**
**Duration**: 2-3 hours
**Goal**: Resolve immediate sync and confusion issues
#### **Tasks**
1. **Audit Current Token Usage**
```bash
# Find all JWT token references in codebase
grep -r "jwt" /path/to/project --include="*.js" --include="*.ts"
grep -r "correct-jwt" /path/to/project
find . -name "*jwt*" -type f
```
2. **Choose Primary Token Location**
- **Recommended**: `/config/secrets/jwt-token.txt`
- **Alternative**: Keep current `/archive/authentication/correct-jwt-new.txt`
- **Create directory structure if needed**
3. **Update All Script References**
- `dist/browser-automation-simple-fixed.js`
- `tools/servers/jwt-redirect-server-v1.0.2.js`
- Any testing scripts in `/tests/authentication/`
- Update hardcoded paths to use single location
4. **Create Migration Script**
```javascript
// tools/auth/migrate-jwt-tokens.js
const fs = require('fs');
const path = require('path');
class JWTMigrator {
constructor() {
this.primaryLocation = './config/secrets/jwt-token.txt';
this.legacyLocations = [
'./archive/authentication/correct-jwt-new.txt',
'./correct-jwt-new.txt',
'./tools/servers/correct-jwt-new.txt'
];
}
migrate() {
// 1. Find most recent token
// 2. Copy to primary location
// 3. Backup legacy files
// 4. Remove duplicates
// 5. Update all references
}
validate() {
// Ensure single token file exists and is valid
}
}
```
5. **Remove Duplicate Files**
- Create backup archive first
- Remove all duplicate token files
- Update documentation
#### **Success Criteria Phase 1**
- ā
Only ONE JWT token file exists in project
- ā
All scripts reference single token location
- ā
Token updates work consistently across all components
- ā
Documentation updated to reflect single location
### **Phase 2: Architecture Improvement (MEDIUM PRIORITY)**
**Duration**: 3-4 hours
**Goal**: Create maintainable token management system
#### **Tasks**
1. **Create TokenManager Class**
```javascript
// src/auth/token-manager.js
class TokenManager {
constructor(configPath = './config/authentication.json') {
this.config = this.loadConfig(configPath);
this.tokenPath = this.config.jwt.tokenPath;
}
loadToken() {
// Single method to load JWT token
// Include validation and error handling
}
validateToken() {
// Check expiration, format, signatures
}
updateToken(newToken) {
// Single method to update token
// Include backup and validation
}
}
```
2. **Create Configuration File**
```json
// config/authentication.json
{
"jwt": {
"tokenPath": "./config/secrets/jwt-token.txt",
"environment": "development",
"validation": {
"enabled": true,
"expirationWarning": 604800000
}
}
}
```
3. **Update All Scripts to Use TokenManager**
- Replace direct file reads with TokenManager calls
- Add proper error handling
- Include token validation
4. **Add Security Improvements**
- Proper file permissions (600) for token file
- Add `.gitignore` entry for secrets directory
- Create token template for setup
#### **Success Criteria Phase 2**
- ā
Centralized TokenManager class handles all token operations
- ā
Configuration-based token management
- ā
Proper security practices implemented
- ā
Easy token updates through single interface
### **Phase 3: Advanced Features (LOW PRIORITY)**
**Duration**: 1-2 hours
**Goal**: Add monitoring and automation capabilities
#### **Tasks**
1. **Token Expiration Monitoring**
```javascript
// Add to TokenManager
checkExpiration() {
// Warn when token approaching expiration
// Automatic validation on load
}
```
2. **Environment Variable Support**
```javascript
// Support JWT_TOKEN environment variable
// Fallback hierarchy: env var ā config file ā file system
```
3. **Testing Framework**
```javascript
// tests/auth/token-manager.test.js
// Comprehensive test suite for token management
```
---
## š§ **IMPLEMENTATION DETAILS**
### **File Structure Changes**
```
BEFORE:
āāā archive/authentication/correct-jwt-new.txt
āāā archive/authentication/correct-jwt.txt
āāā correct-jwt-new.txt
āāā tools/servers/correct-jwt-new.txt
āāā [other scattered token files]
AFTER:
āāā config/
ā āāā authentication.json
ā āāā secrets/
ā āāā jwt-token.txt # ONLY location
āāā src/auth/
ā āāā token-manager.js # Centralized management
āāā tools/auth/
āāā migrate-jwt-tokens.js # Migration utility
āāā validate-tokens.js # Validation utility
```
### **Code Migration Pattern**
```javascript
// BEFORE (in multiple files):
const tokenPath = join(__dirname, 'archive/authentication/correct-jwt-new.txt');
const jwtToken = readFileSync(tokenPath, 'utf-8').trim();
// AFTER (everywhere):
const TokenManager = require('./src/auth/token-manager');
const tokenManager = new TokenManager();
const jwtToken = tokenManager.loadToken();
```
---
## ā
**TESTING REQUIREMENTS**
### **Phase 1 Testing**
1. **File Consolidation Test**
- Verify only one token file exists
- Confirm all scripts can read token
- Test token update propagation
2. **Functionality Test**
- Browser automation still works
- JWT redirect server functions
- MCP server authentication succeeds
3. **Backward Compatibility**
- Existing workflows continue to function
- No breaking changes introduced
### **Phase 2 Testing**
1. **TokenManager Test**
- Token loading and validation
- Error handling for missing/invalid tokens
- Configuration file processing
2. **Integration Test**
- All components use TokenManager
- Token updates through centralized interface
- Security permissions properly set
### **Phase 3 Testing**
1. **Advanced Features Test**
- Expiration monitoring works
- Environment variable support
- Comprehensive test suite passes
---
## š **SUCCESS METRICS**
### **Immediate Success (Phase 1)**
- **File Count**: JWT token files reduced from 5+ to 1
- **Update Time**: Token updates take <30 seconds to propagate
- **Error Rate**: Zero sync-related authentication failures
- **Documentation**: 100% of documentation reflects single location
### **Long-term Success (Phase 2-3)**
- **Maintainability**: New developers can understand token setup in <5 minutes
- **Security**: Zero exposed token files outside designated location
- **Reliability**: Automated token validation prevents expired token issues
- **Developer Experience**: Token management requires minimal manual intervention
---
## ā ļø **RISKS AND MITIGATION**
### **Risk 1: Breaking Existing Functionality**
- **Mitigation**: Comprehensive testing after each phase
- **Rollback**: Complete backup before starting migration
- **Testing**: Validate all authentication flows after changes
### **Risk 2: Missing Token References**
- **Mitigation**: Thorough codebase audit using grep/find tools
- **Validation**: Test all entry points and scripts
- **Documentation**: Update all setup instructions
### **Risk 3: Token Security During Migration**
- **Mitigation**: Proper file permissions throughout process
- **Security**: Secure deletion of old token files
- **Audit**: Verify no tokens left in unexpected locations
---
## š **DELIVERABLES**
### **Phase 1 Deliverables**
- ā
**Migration Script**: `tools/auth/migrate-jwt-tokens.js`
- ā
**Updated Scripts**: All scripts reference single token location
- ā
**Documentation**: Updated setup and troubleshooting guides
- ā
**Validation Script**: Verify single token file exists and works
### **Phase 2 Deliverables**
- ā
**TokenManager Class**: `src/auth/token-manager.js`
- ā
**Configuration**: `config/authentication.json`
- ā
**Updated Components**: All components use TokenManager
- ā
**Security**: Proper file permissions and .gitignore entries
### **Phase 3 Deliverables**
- ā
**Monitoring**: Token expiration checking
- ā
**Environment Support**: Environment variable integration
- ā
**Test Suite**: Comprehensive testing framework
- ā
**Documentation**: Complete architecture documentation
---
## š **EXECUTION PLAN**
### **Pre-Implementation**
1. **Review Analysis Document**: `/docs/analysis/jwt-token-architecture-issue-analysis-v1.0.0.md`
2. **Create Feature Branch**: `feature/jwt-token-consolidation`
3. **Backup Current State**: Full project backup before changes
### **Implementation Sequence**
1. **Execute Phase 1**: Immediate consolidation (2-3 hours)
2. **Test and Validate**: Ensure no breaking changes
3. **Execute Phase 2**: Architecture improvement (3-4 hours)
4. **Test and Validate**: Comprehensive integration testing
5. **Execute Phase 3** (Optional): Advanced features (1-2 hours)
### **Post-Implementation**
1. **Update Documentation**: All guides and troubleshooting docs
2. **Create PR**: Submit for review and merge
3. **Monitor**: Ensure stable operation after deployment
4. **Knowledge Transfer**: Update team on new token management
---
## š **SUPPORT AND ESCALATION**
### **Claude Desktop Coordination**
- **Analysis Complete**: JWT architecture issue fully documented
- **Testing Support**: Available for post-implementation validation
- **Documentation**: Will update guides after implementation complete
### **Required Decisions**
- **Primary Token Location**: Confirm preferred directory structure
- **Migration Timing**: Coordinate with ongoing development
- **Rollback Procedures**: Ensure rapid rollback capability if needed
---
**Task Status**: ā
**READY FOR EXECUTION**
**Next Action**: Claude Code implementation of Phase 1
**Priority**: MEDIUM (High for Phase 1 immediate consolidation)
**Estimated Completion**: Phase 1: 2-3 hours, Full implementation: 6-8 hours
**Risk Level**: LOW (with proper testing and backup procedures)
**šÆ Objective**: Transform scattered JWT token management into clean, maintainable, secure architecture**