mcp-adr-analysis-server

# 🎓 Tutorial 3: Advanced Analysis Techniques **Learning Goal**: Master advanced architectural analysis including security scanning, performance optimization, deployment validation, and team collaboration workflows. **Prerequisites**: - Completed [Tutorial 1: Your First MCP Analysis](01-first-steps.md) - Completed [Tutorial 2: Working with Existing Projects](02-existing-projects.md) - Familiarity with security concepts and deployment processes **Time Required**: 60 minutes --- ## 📚 What You'll Learn 1. **Security Analysis** - Comprehensive security scanning and credential detection 2. **Performance Architecture** - Analyzing and documenting performance-related decisions 3. **Deployment Validation** - Zero-tolerance deployment readiness checking 4. **Team Collaboration** - Multi-developer workflows and knowledge sharing 5. **Advanced AI Techniques** - Using APE, Reflexion, and Knowledge Generation frameworks 6. **Troubleshooting** - Systematic problem diagnosis and resolution --- ## 🛡️ Step 1: Comprehensive Security Analysis ### Understanding Security in Architecture Security isn't just about code - it's about architectural decisions that affect your entire system: - **Data flow and storage decisions** - **Authentication and authorization architecture** - **Network security and API design** - **Deployment and infrastructure security** ### Deep Security Scanning Start with a comprehensive security analysis of your project: ```json { "tool": "analyze_content_security", "parameters": { "content": "Scan entire project for security vulnerabilities and sensitive information", "contentType": "code", "userDefinedPatterns": [ "api[_-]?key.*=.*[\"'][^\"']+[\"']", "secret[_-]?token.*=.*[\"'][^\"']+[\"']", "password.*=.*[\"'][^\"']+[\"']", "private[_-]?key.*=.*[\"'][^\"']+[\"']" ] } } ``` **Common Security Issues Detected:** - **Hardcoded API keys** in configuration files - **Database passwords** in environment files - **Private keys** committed to repository - **Session secrets** in code - **Third-party tokens** in configuration ### Configure Project-Specific Security Patterns Every project has unique security considerations: ```json { "tool": "configure_custom_patterns", "parameters": { "projectPath": ".", "existingPatterns": [ "internal[_-]?api[_-]?url", "admin[_-]?secret", "encryption[_-]?key", "jwt[_-]?secret" ] } } ``` ### Generate Security Masking Strategy ```json { "tool": "generate_content_masking", "parameters": { "content": "Configuration file with sensitive information", "detectedItems": [ { "type": "api_key", "content": "sk-1234567890abcdef", "startPosition": 45, "endPosition": 65, "severity": "high" } ], "maskingStrategy": "environment" } } ``` ### Exercise: Security ADR Creation **Create a comprehensive security ADR:** 1. **Document your authentication architecture** 2. **Identify data protection mechanisms** 3. **Document network security decisions** 4. **Create incident response procedures** ```json { "tool": "generate_adr_from_decision", "parameters": { "decisionData": { "title": "Security Architecture - Defense in Depth Strategy", "context": "Application handles sensitive user data and requires comprehensive security across all layers.", "decision": "Multi-layered security architecture with authentication, authorization, encryption, and monitoring", "rationale": "Defense in depth provides multiple security barriers, reducing risk if any single layer is compromised. Industry best practice for applications handling sensitive data.", "consequences": [ "Comprehensive protection against multiple attack vectors", "Improved compliance with security standards", "Higher complexity in implementation and maintenance", "Need for security expertise across development team", "Performance overhead from multiple security checks" ] }, "adrDirectory": "./adrs" } } ``` --- ## 🚀 Step 2: Performance Architecture Analysis ### Performance-Related Architectural Decisions Performance isn't just about optimization - it's about architectural decisions that affect scalability: - **Database design and query patterns** - **Caching strategies and data flow** - **API design and communication patterns** - **Frontend architecture and asset delivery** ### Analyze Performance Architecture ```json { "tool": "analyze_project_ecosystem", "parameters": { "projectPath": ".", "enhancedMode": true, "recursiveDepth": "comprehensive", "conversationContext": { "focusAreas": ["performance", "scalability"], "constraints": ["high-traffic", "low-latency"] } } } ``` ### Generate Performance-Focused ADRs Based on your analysis, document key performance decisions: ```json { "tool": "suggest_adrs", "parameters": { "projectPath": ".", "analysisScope": "architecture", "maxSuggestions": 5, "conversationContext": { "userRequest": "Focus on performance and scalability architectural decisions" } } } ``` ### Example: Caching Strategy ADR ```json { "tool": "generate_adr_from_decision", "parameters": { "decisionData": { "title": "Caching Architecture - Multi-Layer Strategy", "context": "Application serves high-traffic loads with frequently accessed data that changes infrequently.", "decision": "Multi-layer caching with Redis for application cache, CDN for static assets, and database query caching", "rationale": "Reduces database load by 80%, improves response times to <100ms for cached content, and provides horizontal scaling capability. Proven pattern for high-traffic applications.", "consequences": [ "Significantly improved response times and user experience", "Reduced database load and improved overall system capacity", "Cache invalidation complexity requires careful coordination", "Additional infrastructure components to monitor and maintain", "Potential for cache consistency issues during updates" ] }, "adrDirectory": "./adrs" } } ``` ### Exercise: Performance Audit **Conduct a performance architecture review:** 1. **Identify bottlenecks** in your current architecture 2. **Document caching decisions** (or lack thereof) 3. **Analyze database query patterns** and indexing strategies 4. **Review API design** for efficiency 5. **Create performance-focused ADRs** for major decisions --- ## 🔥 Step 3: Zero-Tolerance Deployment Validation ### Understanding Deployment Readiness Modern deployment requires comprehensive validation to prevent production issues: - **All tests passing** with adequate coverage - **Security vulnerabilities** addressed - **Performance benchmarks** met - **Configuration** properly managed - **Monitoring and alerting** configured ### Comprehensive Deployment Analysis ```json { "tool": "deployment_readiness", "parameters": { "operation": "check_readiness", "targetEnvironment": "production", "strictMode": true, "integrateTodoTasks": true, "updateHealthScoring": true } } ``` **This validates:** - **Test Coverage** - Minimum thresholds met - **Security Scanning** - No high-severity vulnerabilities - **Dependency Audit** - No known security issues - **Configuration** - Environment-specific settings ready - **Documentation** - Deployment procedures documented ### Advanced Deployment Progress Tracking ```json { "tool": "analyze_deployment_progress", "parameters": { "analysisType": "pre_deployment", "targetEnvironment": "production", "projectPath": "." } } ``` ### Generate Deployment Guidance ```json { "tool": "generate_deployment_guidance", "parameters": { "adrDirectory": "./adrs", "targetEnvironment": "production", "deploymentType": "kubernetes", "includeSecurityChecks": true } } ``` ### Smart Git Push with Security Validation ```json { "tool": "smart_git_push", "parameters": { "operation": "pre_push_validation", "forceSecurityCheck": true, "projectPath": "." } } ``` ### Exercise: Deployment Readiness Checklist **Create a comprehensive pre-deployment validation:** 1. **Run deployment readiness check** 2. **Address any blocking issues** 3. **Document deployment procedures** 4. **Create rollback plans** 5. **Validate monitoring and alerting** --- ## 👥 Step 4: Team Collaboration Workflows ### Multi-Developer ADR Processes Large teams need structured processes for architectural decision-making: - **Decision proposal and review workflows** - **Collaborative ADR creation and editing** - **Knowledge sharing and onboarding** - **Architectural change management** ### Get Intelligent Workflow Guidance ```json { "tool": "get_workflow_guidance", "parameters": { "goal": "Establish team architectural decision workflow for 10+ developers", "currentPhase": "planning", "constraints": ["distributed team", "multiple time zones", "varying experience levels"], "availableTime": "2 weeks for implementation" } } ``` ### Development Guidance for Teams ```json { "tool": "get_development_guidance", "parameters": { "developmentPhase": "implementation", "adrDirectory": "./adrs", "technologyStack": ["typescript", "react", "node.js", "postgresql"], "constraints": ["microservices architecture", "cloud-native deployment"] } } ``` ### Create Research Templates For complex decisions requiring research: ```json { "tool": "create_research_template", "parameters": { "title": "Database Scaling Strategy Research", "researchType": "technology", "includeMetadata": true } } ``` ### Generate Research Questions ```json { "tool": "generate_research_questions", "parameters": { "analysisType": "architecture", "context": "Evaluating microservices communication patterns for high-throughput system", "researchScope": "broad", "maxQuestions": 8 } } ``` ### Exercise: Team Decision Workflow **Design and implement a team decision process:** 1. **Define decision authorities** - Who makes what types of decisions? 2. **Create proposal templates** - Standardize decision documentation 3. **Establish review processes** - How are decisions reviewed and approved? 4. **Set up knowledge sharing** - How do team members stay informed? 5. **Plan onboarding** - How do new team members learn the architecture? --- ## 🧠 Step 5: Advanced AI Techniques ### Automatic Prompt Engineering (APE) The APE framework optimizes prompts for better analysis results: ```json { "tool": "analyze_project_ecosystem", "parameters": { "projectPath": ".", "enhancedMode": true, "conversationContext": { "useAPE": true, "optimizeFor": "architectural_insights" } } } ``` **APE Benefits:** - **Better accuracy** in architectural pattern detection - **More relevant suggestions** based on project context - **Improved consistency** across analysis runs - **Adaptive prompting** based on project characteristics ### Knowledge Generation Framework Build comprehensive understanding through iterative analysis: ```json { "tool": "suggest_adrs", "parameters": { "projectPath": ".", "conversationContext": { "useKnowledgeGeneration": true, "buildComprehensiveUnderstanding": true } } } ``` ### Reflexion Framework Self-correcting analysis through iterative refinement: ```json { "tool": "compare_adr_progress", "parameters": { "adrDirectory": "./adrs", "conversationContext": { "useReflexion": true, "validateFindings": true, "iterativeRefinement": true } } } ``` ### Exercise: AI-Enhanced Analysis **Run an AI-enhanced architectural analysis:** 1. **Enable all AI frameworks** in your analysis calls 2. **Compare results** with standard analysis 3. **Document quality improvements** you observe 4. **Create ADRs** for AI framework usage decisions --- ## 🔧 Step 6: Advanced Troubleshooting ### Systematic Problem Diagnosis When things go wrong, systematic troubleshooting saves time: ```json { "tool": "troubleshoot_guided_workflow", "parameters": { "operation": "analyze_failure", "failureInfo": { "failureType": "deployment_failure", "failureDetails": "Container startup fails with dependency connection timeout", "context": { "reproducible": true, "frequency": "always", "impact": "critical" } } } } ``` ### Generate Test Plans ```json { "tool": "troubleshoot_guided_workflow", "parameters": { "operation": "generate_test_plan", "failureInfo": { "failureType": "performance_degradation", "failureDetails": "API response times increased from 100ms to 2000ms after deployment" } } } ``` ### Diagnostic Workflows ```json { "tool": "troubleshoot_guided_workflow", "parameters": { "operation": "run_diagnostics", "projectPath": "." } } ``` ### Exercise: Create Troubleshooting Playbooks **Document systematic troubleshooting approaches:** 1. **Identify common failure scenarios** in your project 2. **Create diagnostic workflows** for each scenario 3. **Generate test plans** for validation 4. **Document resolution procedures** 5. **Create ADRs** for troubleshooting and monitoring decisions --- ## 📊 Step 7: Advanced Health Scoring and Analytics ### Comprehensive Health Assessment ```json { "tool": "smart_score", "parameters": { "operation": "recalculate_scores", "components": ["all"], "projectPath": ".", "forceUpdate": true, "updateSources": true } } ``` ### Score Optimization ```json { "tool": "smart_score", "parameters": { "operation": "optimize_weights", "projectPath": ".", "rebalanceWeights": true } } ``` ### Trend Analysis ```json { "tool": "smart_score", "parameters": { "operation": "get_score_trends", "includeHistory": true, "projectPath": "." } } ``` ### Exercise: Health Monitoring Dashboard **Create a project health monitoring system:** 1. **Establish baseline scores** for all components 2. **Set up regular monitoring** (weekly or monthly) 3. **Define improvement targets** for each component 4. **Create action plans** for score improvements 5. **Document the monitoring process** in an ADR --- ## 🎯 Step 8: Advanced Rule Generation and Validation ### Generate Comprehensive Architectural Rules ```json { "tool": "generate_rules", "parameters": { "source": "both", "adrDirectory": "./adrs", "projectPath": ".", "ruleTypes": ["all"], "outputFormat": "json" } } ``` ### Validate Code Compliance ```json { "tool": "validate_rules", "parameters": { "projectPath": ".", "ruleTypes": ["security", "patterns", "dependencies"], "outputFormat": "detailed" } } ``` ### Create Machine-Readable Rule Sets ```json { "tool": "create_rule_set", "parameters": { "name": "Project Architectural Standards", "description": "Comprehensive architectural rules for development team", "rules": [ { "category": "security", "rule": "No hardcoded credentials in source code", "severity": "error" }, { "category": "performance", "rule": "Database queries must use prepared statements", "severity": "warning" } ], "format": "json" } } ``` ### Exercise: Automated Compliance Checking **Set up automated architectural compliance:** 1. **Generate rules** from your ADRs and code patterns 2. **Create validation scripts** for CI/CD integration 3. **Set up automated checking** in your development workflow 4. **Document the compliance process** 5. **Train your team** on the rules and validation process --- ## 🌐 Step 9: Environment Analysis and Optimization ### Comprehensive Environment Assessment ```json { "tool": "analyze_environment", "parameters": { "projectPath": ".", "environmentType": "production", "includeOptimizations": true } } ``` **This analyzes:** - **Infrastructure configuration** and optimization opportunities - **Resource utilization** and scaling recommendations - **Security configuration** and hardening suggestions - **Monitoring and observability** setup - **Cost optimization** opportunities ### Exercise: Environment Architecture Documentation **Document your environment architecture:** 1. **Analyze all environments** (dev, staging, production) 2. **Document infrastructure decisions** in ADRs 3. **Create environment-specific configurations** 4. **Establish monitoring and alerting** 5. **Plan disaster recovery procedures** --- ## 🏆 Step 10: Mastery Integration ### Complete Project Health Assessment Run a comprehensive analysis using all advanced techniques: ```json { "tool": "analyze_project_ecosystem", "parameters": { "projectPath": ".", "enhancedMode": true, "knowledgeEnhancement": true, "learningEnabled": true, "includeEnvironment": true, "recursiveDepth": "comprehensive", "conversationContext": { "useAPE": true, "useKnowledgeGeneration": true, "useReflexion": true, "comprehensiveAnalysis": true } } } ``` ### Final Validation and Scoring ```json { "tool": "deployment_readiness", "parameters": { "operation": "all", "targetEnvironment": "production", "strictMode": true } } ``` ### 🎯 Master the Context File for Decision-Making As an advanced practitioner, `.mcp-server-context.md` becomes your strategic decision-making tool. Here's how masters use it: #### Pattern-Driven Architecture ``` @.mcp-server-context.md Analyze the patterns we've discovered across all analyses. What architectural style is emerging and what does it suggest about our next decisions? ``` **Master's Insight**: The context file aggregates patterns across multiple sessions, revealing architectural trends invisible in single analyses. #### Score-Based Prioritization ``` @.mcp-server-context.md Show me the score breakdown by component. Which areas have improved most and which need attention? What's the correlation between our decisions and score changes? ``` **Use Case**: Prioritize architectural improvements based on data, not gut feeling. #### Knowledge Gap Intelligence ``` @.mcp-server-context.md What knowledge gaps have been identified? Cross-reference them with our active intents and recommend which gaps to address first. ``` **Advanced Technique**: Let the memory system guide your learning path. #### Team Coordination ``` @.mcp-server-context.md Generate a status report for the team: what patterns are discovered, what decisions are pending, what blockers exist, and what each team member should focus on based on the memory graph. ``` **Team Lead Power Move**: Automatically generate team coordination from project memory. #### Temporal Analysis ``` @.mcp-server-context.md Compare our current state with 2 weeks ago. What architectural decisions led to the biggest improvements? What patterns have become stronger or weaker? ``` **Strategic Insight**: Understand cause-and-effect in architectural evolution. #### Predictive Recommendations ``` @.mcp-server-context.md Based on discovered patterns, our architecture score trajectory, and similar projects in memory, what architectural decisions should we prioritize in the next sprint? ``` **Master Level**: Use historical data for predictive architectural planning. ### Context File Advanced Workflows **Pre-Architecture Review:** ```bash # Before team review meeting @.mcp-server-context.md Prepare an executive summary: key patterns, critical decisions, risk areas, and recommended actions ``` **Post-Deployment Analysis:** ```bash # After production deployment @.mcp-server-context.md Compare pre-deployment and post-deployment states. What changed? What patterns emerged? Update our learnings. ``` **Continuous Learning:** ```bash # Regular practice @.mcp-server-context.md What new patterns or relationships were discovered this week? How do they relate to our existing knowledge? ``` ### Exercise: Architectural Excellence Portfolio **Create a comprehensive architectural documentation portfolio:** 1. **Complete security analysis** with masking strategies 2. **Performance architecture** documentation 3. **Deployment validation** with zero-tolerance standards 4. **Team collaboration** workflows 5. **Advanced AI-enhanced** analysis results 6. **Troubleshooting playbooks** and procedures 7. **Health monitoring** dashboard 8. **Compliance checking** automation 9. **Environment optimization** recommendations --- ## 🎯 Mastery Success Criteria By completing this advanced tutorial, you should have: ✅ **Security Expertise** - Comprehensive security analysis and protection strategies ✅ **Performance Architecture** - Documented performance-related architectural decisions ✅ **Deployment Mastery** - Zero-tolerance deployment validation processes ✅ **Team Leadership** - Collaborative architectural decision-making workflows ✅ **AI Proficiency** - Advanced AI techniques for enhanced analysis ✅ **Troubleshooting Skills** - Systematic problem diagnosis and resolution ✅ **Quality Assurance** - Health monitoring and compliance checking ✅ **Operational Excellence** - Environment optimization and monitoring --- ## 🚀 Beyond Mastery: Becoming an Architecture Leader ### **Immediate Next Steps** 1. **Implement advanced techniques** in your current project 2. **Train your team** on advanced workflows 3. **Establish center of excellence** for architectural decisions ### **Career Development** - **Become the architecture SME** for your organization - **Mentor other developers** in architectural decision-making - **Contribute to open source** architectural tools and frameworks - **Speak at conferences** about AI-assisted architecture ### **Continuous Learning** - **Stay current** with architectural patterns and technologies - **Experiment** with new AI techniques and frameworks - **Build** your own architectural analysis tools - **Share knowledge** through blog posts and presentations --- ## 🎪 **Advanced Techniques Showcase** ### **What Makes You Advanced Now** 1. **Systematic Approach** - You use comprehensive, methodical analysis 2. **Security First** - You integrate security considerations throughout 3. **Performance Aware** - You understand performance implications of architectural decisions 4. **Team Oriented** - You facilitate collaborative architectural decision-making 5. **AI Enhanced** - You leverage advanced AI techniques for better analysis 6. **Quality Focused** - You implement automated compliance and health monitoring 7. **Operationally Minded** - You consider deployment and operational concerns ### **Your Advanced Toolkit** You now have mastery of all 37 MCP tools and can: - **Conduct comprehensive security analysis** with custom patterns - **Implement zero-tolerance deployment validation** - **Facilitate team architectural decision processes** - **Use advanced AI frameworks** for enhanced analysis - **Create systematic troubleshooting procedures** - **Implement automated compliance checking** - **Optimize environments** for performance and cost --- ## 🏆 **Congratulations - You're Now an Advanced Practitioner!** You've mastered advanced architectural analysis techniques and are ready to lead architectural decision-making in any organization. Your skills in AI-assisted architecture, security analysis, and team collaboration make you a valuable contributor to any development team. **Keep Growing:** - **Experiment** with new techniques and approaches - **Share your knowledge** with the community - **Push the boundaries** of what's possible with AI-assisted architecture - **Build amazing things** with your newfound expertise --- **Want to contribute back?** Consider: - **[Contributing to the project](https://github.com/tosin2013/mcp-adr-analysis-server/blob/main/../../CONTRIBUTING.md)** - **Sharing your experience** through blog posts or presentations - **Mentoring others** in architectural decision-making - **Building extensions** to the MCP ADR Analysis Server --- _This completes the MCP ADR Analysis Server tutorial series. You've progressed from beginner to advanced practitioner with comprehensive skills in AI-assisted architectural analysis. Use these skills to build better software and help your teams make excellent architectural decisions._