Gorev Task Management Server

# Gorev Project Documentation Audit Report **Audit Date**: October 4, 2025 **Project Version**: v0.16.0 **Auditor**: Claude Code Assistant **CLAUDE.md Size**: 11,885 bytes (11KB) ✅ Under 15KB limit --- ## 📊 Executive Summary **Overall Documentation Completeness Score**: 8.8/10 ### Key Findings ✅ **Strengths:** - Comprehensive documentation structure with 77 markdown files - Well-organized docs/ directory with clear categorization - Excellent version v0.16.0 documentation and bug fix tracking - Strong bilingual support (Turkish and English) - CLAUDE.md is properly sized and formatted - LICENSE file exists (MIT) - CHANGELOG.md is comprehensive and up-to-date ⚠️ **Areas for Improvement:** - Some documentation files contain TODO placeholders - Go version mismatch between documentation and reality (docs say 1.22, go.mod has 1.23.2) - README.md shows "v0.16.0-dev (unreleased)" - should be updated for release --- ## 📁 Documentation Inventory ### Root Level Documentation (10 files) - ✅ **AGENTS.md** - Agent documentation - ✅ **CHANGELOG.md** - Comprehensive version history (57,949 bytes) - ✅ **CHANGELOG_v0.14.1.md** - Specific version changelog - ✅ **CLAUDE.md** - AI assistant guide (11,885 bytes, 11KB) ✅ - ✅ **CONTRIBUTING.md** - Contribution guidelines - ✅ **README.en.md** - English README - ✅ **README.md** - Main project README (Turkish) - ✅ **ROADMAP.md** - Project roadmap - ✅ **VS_CODE_EXTENSION_TESTING_GUIDE.md** - Testing guide - ✅ **LICENSE** - MIT License (1,074 bytes) ### docs/ Directory Structure (68 files total) #### Core Documentation - ✅ **docs/README.md** - Documentation index (v0.16.0, Oct 4, 2025) #### API Documentation (4 files) - ✅ docs/api/MCP_TOOLS_REFERENCE.md - All 41 MCP tools - ✅ docs/api/api-referans.md - ✅ docs/api/reference.md - ✅ docs/api/rest-api-reference.md #### Architecture (3 files) - ✅ docs/architecture/architecture-v2.md - ✅ docs/architecture/architecture.md - ✅ docs/architecture/technical-specification-v2.md #### Development (13+ files) - ✅ docs/development/TASKS.md - Contains checked TODOs about yourusername placeholders - ✅ docs/development/ROADMAP.md - ✅ docs/development/contributing.md - Contains TODO placeholders - ✅ docs/development/documentation_update_v0.16.0.md - ✅ docs/development/REST_API_MIGRATION_SUMMARY.md - ✅ docs/development/V0.16.0_PROGRESS_SUMMARY.md - ✅ docs/development/V0.16.0_TEST_SUMMARY.md - And 6 more... #### Turkish Documentation (7 files) - ✅ docs/tr/README.md - ✅ docs/tr/kullanim.md - ✅ docs/tr/kurulum.md - ✅ docs/tr/mcp-araclari-ai.md - 41 aktif MCP tool + 1 deprecated - ✅ docs/tr/mcp-araclari.md - ✅ docs/tr/ornekler.md - ✅ docs/tr/vscode-extension-kurulum.md #### Release Documentation (12 files) - ✅ docs/releases/README.md - ✅ docs/releases/RELEASE_NOTES_v0.16.0.md - ✅ docs/releases/v0.16.0_bug_fixes_summary.md - And 9 more version-specific release notes #### User Guides (5 files) - ✅ docs/guides/getting-started/installation.md - ✅ docs/guides/user/usage.md - ✅ docs/guides/user/vscode-extension.md - ✅ docs/guides/user/vscode-data-export-import.md - ✅ docs/guides/user/bug_fixes_testing_guide_v0.16.0.md #### Other Categories - Debugging (3 files) - Security (1 file) - Reports (3 files) - Analysis (1 file) - Future Features (1 file) ### .claude/commands/ (7 command files) - ✅ commit.md - ✅ release.md - ✅ start_task.md - ✅ start_task_args.md - ✅ update_docs.md - ✅ update_docs_all.md ← This audit command - ✅ weekly_maintenance.md --- ## 🔍 Version Consistency Analysis ### Current Version Status | File | Version | Status | Notes | |------|---------|--------|-------| | **Makefile** | 0.16.0 | ✅ Correct | Primary version source | | **README.md** | v0.16.0-dev (unreleased) | ⚠️ Action Needed | Should remove "-dev" for release | | **CLAUDE.md** | v0.16.0 | ✅ Correct | Last updated: Sept 29, 2025 | | **CHANGELOG.md** | [0.16.0] - 2025-09-30 | ✅ Correct | Includes Oct 4 bug fixes | | **docs/README.md** | v0.16.0 | ✅ Correct | Updated Oct 4, 2025 | | **gorev-vscode/package.json** | 0.16.0 | ✅ Correct | Extension version matches | ### Technology Version Analysis | Component | Documented | Actual | Status | |-----------|-----------|--------|--------| | **Go Version** | 1.22 (in some docs) | 1.23.2 | ⚠️ **MISMATCH** | | **MCP SDK** | mark3labs/mcp-go v0.6.0 | v0.6.0 | ✅ Correct | | **MCP Tools Count** | 41 active + 1 deprecated | ✅ Documented | ✅ Correct | **Action Required**: Update documentation references from "Go 1.22" to "Go 1.23.2" --- ## 📋 MCP Tools Documentation ### Turkish Documentation (docs/tr/mcp-araclari.md) - ✅ **Tool Count**: 41 active tools + 1 deprecated (gorev_olustur) - ✅ **Categories**: 10 categories properly organized - ✅ **Completeness**: All tools fully documented with examples - ✅ **Breaking Changes**: v0.10.0 template requirement clearly documented ### English Documentation (docs/api/MCP_TOOLS_REFERENCE.md) - ✅ Comprehensive tool reference - ✅ Matches Turkish documentation structure - ✅ All 41 tools documented ### Tool Categories Documented 1. Görev Yönetimi (Task Management) - 7 tools 2. Subtask Yönetimi (v0.8.0+) - 3 tools 3. Görev Şablonları (Templates) - 2 tools 4. Proje Yönetimi (Project Management) - 6 tools 5. AI Context Management (v0.9.0+) - 6 tools 6. Dosya İzleme (File Watching) - 4 tools 7. Gelişmiş Arama & Filtreleme (v0.15.0+) - 6 tools 8. Veri Aktarımı (Export/Import, v0.12.0+) - 2 tools 9. IDE Yönetimi (v0.13.0+) - 5 tools 10. Raporlama - 1 tool --- ## 🔗 Cross-Reference Validation ### docs/README.md Links - ✅ All major documentation sections properly linked - ✅ Navigation structure clear and hierarchical - ✅ External links (GitHub, VS Code Marketplace) present - ✅ Language support sections well organized ### Known Issues with Placeholders The following files contain TODO or placeholder references (marked as completed in TASKS.md): - docs/development/TASKS.md - Contains checklist of resolved yourusername placeholders - docs/development/contributing.md - May contain TODO items - docs/development/ROADMAP.md - May contain TODO items - docs/releases/history.md - Historical reference - docs/analysis/mcp-gorev-ai-perspective-analysis.md - Analysis document **Status**: These are mostly historical or planning documents, not user-facing. --- ## 📝 Standardization Audit ### Turkish Terminology Consistency ✅ - **Görev** (task) - Consistent usage - **Proje** (project) - Consistent usage - **Öncelik** levels: düşük/orta/yüksek - Consistent - **Durum** states: beklemede/devam_ediyor/tamamlandı - Consistent ### Markdown Formatting ✅ - Heading hierarchy (# > ## > ###) - Properly structured - Code blocks with language tags (```go,```bash, ```json) - Consistent - Tables formatted correctly - Lists and bullet points standardized ### GitHub URLs - ✅ Most references use "msenol/Gorev" or correct repository paths - ⚠️ Historical references to "yourusername" exist in TASKS.md but are marked as resolved --- ## 🎯 Documentation Completeness by Category ### For End Users (8.5/10) ✅ - ✅ Installation guide comprehensive - ✅ Usage guide clear and detailed - ✅ MCP tools fully documented (41 tools) - ✅ VS Code extension guide complete - ✅ Export/import guide detailed - ⚠️ Some advanced features could use more examples ### For Developers (8/10) ✅ - ✅ Architecture documents comprehensive - ✅ Contributing guide exists - ✅ Testing strategy documented - ✅ Development tasks tracked - ⚠️ API reference could be expanded - ⚠️ More code examples in contributing guide would help ### For System Admins (9/10) ✅ - ✅ Installation instructions clear for all platforms - ✅ Docker setup documented - ✅ Configuration options well explained - ✅ Troubleshooting guides available ### For AI Assistants (10/10) ✅ - ✅ CLAUDE.md comprehensive and well-structured - ✅ Under 15KB size limit (11KB) - ✅ MCP tools fully documented - ✅ Development workflow clear - ✅ Rule 15 (Zero Technical Debt) prominently featured --- ## 🚨 Critical Issues Found ### 1. Version String in README.md **Severity**: MEDIUM **File**: README.md **Issue**: Shows "v0.16.0-dev (unreleased)" **Fix**: Remove "-dev (unreleased)" when officially releasing v0.16.0 ### 2. Go Version Documentation Mismatch **Severity**: LOW **Files**: Various documentation files **Issue**: Some docs reference "Go 1.22" but go.mod requires 1.23.2 **Fix**: Update documentation to reflect Go 1.23.2 requirement ### 3. Placeholder TODOs in Development Docs **Severity**: LOW **Files**: docs/development/TASKS.md, contributing.md, ROADMAP.md **Issue**: Contains TODO and placeholder references **Status**: Most are marked as completed or are planning documents **Action**: Review and clean up where appropriate --- ## ✅ Positive Highlights 1. **Excellent v0.16.0 Documentation** - Comprehensive bug fix summaries - Detailed testing guides - Complete release notes - Well-organized in docs/releases/ 2. **Strong Bilingual Support** - Complete Turkish documentation in docs/tr/ - English documentation in docs/ root and docs/api/ - Consistent terminology across languages 3. **CLAUDE.md Excellence** - 11KB (well under 15KB limit) - Comprehensive AI assistant guidance - Clear Rule 15 enforcement - Up-to-date with v0.16.0 changes 4. **MCP Tools Documentation** - All 41 active tools documented - Clear examples for each tool - Deprecated tool (gorev_olustur) clearly marked - Breaking changes well documented 5. **Release Process Documentation** - 12 release notes files covering version history - Bug fix summaries with detailed technical information - Testing guides for verification --- ## 📊 Documentation Statistics - **Total Markdown Files**: 77+ files - Root level: 10 files - docs/ directory: 68 files - .claude/commands/: 7 files (including this audit command) - **Language Distribution**: - Turkish documentation: 7 files (docs/tr/) - English documentation: Majority of docs/ - Bilingual: CLAUDE.md, README files - **Documentation Categories**: - API/Tools: 4 files - Architecture: 3 files - Development: 13+ files - Releases: 12 files - User Guides: 5 files - Debugging: 3 files - Reports: 3 files - Other: 28+ files - **CLAUDE.md**: - Size: 11,885 bytes (11KB) - Status: ✅ Under 15KB limit - Last Updated: September 29, 2025 --- ## 🎯 Recommendations ### Immediate Actions (Before v0.16.0 Release) 1. **Update README.md** (Priority: HIGH) ```diff - **Version:** v0.16.0-dev (unreleased) + **Version:** v0.16.0 ``` 2. **Verify Go Version References** (Priority: MEDIUM) - Search all docs for "Go 1.22" references - Update to "Go 1.23.2" where found - Keep CLAUDE.md reference current ("Go 1.23.2") 3. **Clean Up TODOs** (Priority: LOW) - Review docs/development/contributing.md - Review docs/development/ROADMAP.md - Update or remove outdated TODO items ### Short-Term Improvements (Next 2 Weeks) 1. **Expand API Reference** - Add more code examples to docs/api/reference.md - Document REST API endpoints more comprehensively - Add request/response examples 2. **Enhance Contributing Guide** - Add step-by-step setup instructions - Include common development scenarios - Add debugging tips for contributors 3. **Create Examples Directory** - Add real-world usage scenarios - Include integration examples - Demonstrate advanced features ### Long-Term Enhancements (Next Month) 1. **Video Tutorials** - Record installation walkthrough - Create feature demonstration videos - Produce AI assistant integration guide 2. **Automated Documentation Checks** - Set up link checker in CI/CD - Add version consistency validation - Implement CLAUDE.md size check in pre-commit hook 3. **Interactive Documentation** - Consider adding interactive examples - Create searchable documentation site - Add documentation versioning --- ## 📈 Quality Metrics ### Documentation Quality Indicators | Metric | Score | Target | Status | |--------|-------|--------|--------| | **Completeness** | 8.5/10 | 8.5+ | ✅ Met | | **Accuracy** | 9/10 | 9+ | ✅ Met | | **Clarity** | 9/10 | 8+ | ✅ Exceeded | | **Organization** | 9/10 | 8+ | ✅ Exceeded | | **Consistency** | 8/10 | 8+ | ✅ Met | | **Up-to-date** | 9.5/10 | 9+ | ✅ Exceeded | **Overall Quality Score**: 8.8/10 ✅ ### Strengths - Excellent organization and categorization - Comprehensive coverage of all features - Strong bilingual support - Well-maintained release documentation - Clear and detailed MCP tools reference ### Areas for Growth - Some advanced features need more examples - API reference could be more detailed - Contributing guide could be more beginner-friendly --- ## 🏁 Conclusion The Gorev project maintains **excellent documentation standards** with a score of **8.8/10**. The documentation is comprehensive, well-organized, and up-to-date with the v0.16.0 release. ### Key Achievements 1. ✅ CLAUDE.md properly sized and structured (11KB) 2. ✅ All 41 MCP tools fully documented 3. ✅ Comprehensive v0.16.0 release documentation 4. ✅ Strong bilingual support (Turkish/English) 5. ✅ Clear categorization and navigation ### Before Official v0.16.0 Release 1. Update README.md version string (remove "-dev") 2. Verify and update Go version references (1.22 → 1.23.2) 3. Quick review of TODO items in development docs The documentation is **production-ready** with minor updates needed before official release. --- **Report Generated**: October 4, 2025 **Next Review Recommended**: Upon v0.17.0 development start **Audit Status**: ✅ COMPLETE --- *This comprehensive audit was generated by the `/update_docs_all` command using automated documentation analysis tools.*