mcp-skills

# Work Resumption Analysis - mcp-skillset **Date:** 2025-12-16 **Days Since Last Commit:** 16 days (2025-11-30) **Version:** 0.7.0 **Branch:** main --- ## Executive Summary The mcp-skillset project is in a **stable post-release state** with a major CLI refactoring completed (ticket 1M-460). The project was released as v0.7.0 on 2025-11-30, and all major work streams are either complete or well-documented with clear next steps. **Current Status:** - ✅ Major CLI refactoring complete and merged - ✅ v0.7.0 release published - ✅ Test suite updated for new CLI structure - ⚠️ Some uncommitted local changes (MPM state, gitignore updates) - 📋 One untracked research document available (CLI usage analysis) **Recommended Next Actions:** 1. Commit or discard local changes 2. Review and decide on CLI usage analysis findings 3. Address pre-publication quality gate (coverage threshold temporarily lowered) 4. Consider recommended architectural improvements from previous analysis --- ## 1. Work Streams Identification ### Stream 1: CLI Refactoring (1M-460) - COMPLETE ✅ **Timeline:** 2025-11-30 (6 commits in ~4 hours) **Scope:** Extract 14 CLI commands from monolithic main.py into modular structure **Commits:** - `5ffed42` - Extract first 4 CLI commands (setup, install, search, list_skills) - `67eba48` - Extract 3 medium commands (search, doctor, demo) - `69a951b` - Extract recommend command - `f1d9902` - Extract stats and enrich commands - `0117acc` - Add per-repository progress bars for skill downloading - `6f8f62f` - Extract build-skill and config commands - `ee6a336` - Integrate all extracted commands into main.py - `7ec5de0` - Add CLI refactoring research documents - `1e98c7b` - Extract final 4 Priority 3 CLI commands (index, info, repo, discover) **Changes:** - Created 16 separate command modules in `src/mcp_skills/cli/commands/` - Simplified main.py from monolithic to clean entry point (69 lines) - Extracted shared utilities (console, progress tracking) - All commands registered via `cli.add_command()` pattern - 100% of CLI functionality preserved **Quality Issues:** - Test mock paths needed updating (fixed in 6e2b92f and 059d5ae) - Coverage temporarily reduced to 70% (from 85%) due to refactoring scope (pyproject.toml line 125) --- ### Stream 2: Claude CLI Integration (1M-432) - COMPLETE ✅ **Timeline:** 2025-11-29 to 2025-11-30 **Scope:** Add unit tests and documentation for Claude CLI integration **Commits:** - `afdb485` - Add unit tests for Claude CLI integration (9 test cases covering happy path, error handling, force flag, dry-run) - `e73f17a` - Update documentation for Claude CLI integration (CLAUDE_CLI_INTEGRATION.md) **Current Status:** - ✅ Integration implemented and tested in v0.6.8 - ✅ Tests cover: success case, error handling, force reinstall, dry-run modes - ✅ Documentation explains rationale and design decisions - ⚠️ Only Claude Code and Claude Desktop/Auggie fully supported (Cursor/Codex/Gemini not yet) --- ### Stream 3: Version Bump & Release (v0.7.0) - COMPLETE ✅ **Timeline:** 2025-11-30 **Scope:** Prepare and publish v0.7.0 release **Commits:** - `dda5bb5` - Bump version to 0.7.0 in pyproject.toml - `d15bfcc` - Add yaml, questionary, pyperclip to mypy ignore list - `0672466` - Fix code formatting for v0.7.0 release - `a1f7b90` - Code quality fixes for v0.7.0 release - `7557f4e` - Add release readiness report (RELEASE_READINESS_v0.7.0.md - 270 lines) - `690d040` - Add release summary (RELEASE_SUMMARY_v0.7.0.md - 322 lines) - `059d5ae` - Final test fixes after CLI refactoring **Release Artifacts:** - RELEASE_READINESS_v0.7.0.md - Comprehensive pre-release checklist (36 checks) - RELEASE_SUMMARY_v0.7.0.md - Detailed changes, architecture review, known issues - CHANGELOG.md updated with v0.7.0 entries **Status:** Release complete and published to PyPI --- ### Stream 4: Architecture Review - DOCUMENTED ✅ **Timeline:** 2025-11-30 **Scope:** Comprehensive analysis of codebase architecture and DI/SOA improvements **Commit:** - `d5cb2c9` - Comprehensive architecture review and Linear tickets for DI/SOA improvements **Key Findings:** - Identified Dependency Injection patterns (improvements needed) - Documented Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) opportunities - Created Linear tickets for follow-up work - Provided detailed recommendations for refactoring **Status:** Analysis complete, recommendations documented in commit and external doc --- ### Stream 5: HuggingFace Warnings - RESOLVED ✅ **Timeline:** 2025-11-30 **Scope:** Eliminate HuggingFace tokenizers fork warnings during setup **Commit:** - `9ff2721` - Eliminate HuggingFace tokenizers fork warnings during setup **Changes:** - Set environment variable in main.py: `TOKENIZERS_PARALLELISM = "false"` before imports - Prevents fork() warnings from HuggingFace during CLI execution **Status:** Complete, no user-facing warnings during setup --- ## 2. Intent Analysis ### What Problems Were Being Solved? **Problem 1: CLI Code Maintainability** - Original issue: Monolithic main.py getting difficult to maintain - Solution: Refactor into modular command structure - Result: Clear separation of concerns, easier to add new commands **Problem 2: Test Coverage After Refactoring** - Original issue: Test mock paths broke after CLI extraction - Solution: Update test fixtures and mocking strategy - Result: All tests passing, CLI refactoring validated **Problem 3: Release Readiness** - Original issue: Need to document release process and validate checklist - Solution: Create comprehensive release documentation - Result: Clear process for future releases, detailed changelog **Problem 4: Architecture Quality** - Original issue: Some architectural patterns could be improved (DI, SOA) - Solution: Comprehensive analysis and ticket creation - Result: Clear roadmap for architecture improvements **Problem 5: User Setup Experience** - Original issue: HuggingFace warnings confusing users during setup - Solution: Disable tokenizers parallelism early - Result: Clean output, better first-time user experience ### Technology Decisions Made 1. **CLI Modularization:** Chose click group with add_command() pattern - Pros: Standard in CLI frameworks, easy to test, clear hierarchy - Cons: Slightly more boilerplate than decorators 2. **Agent Installation Routing:** Separate Claude CLI path from JSON config - Pros: Uses official Claude CLI for Code, safe config manipulation for others - Cons: Two installation methods to maintain 3. **Test Coverage Threshold:** Temporarily lowered from 85% to 70% - Rationale: CLI refactoring increased untested surface area - Action: Needs to be raised back to 85% after full test coverage update --- ## 3. Completion Status ### ✅ Complete & Production-Ready | Work Item | Status | Commits | Tests | Docs | |-----------|--------|---------|-------|------| | CLI refactoring (1M-460) | COMPLETE | 9 | ✅ Updated | ✅ Research doc | | Claude CLI integration (1M-432) | COMPLETE | 2 | ✅ 9 cases | ✅ CLI_INTEGRATION.md | | v0.7.0 Release | COMPLETE | 7 | ✅ Passing | ✅ RELEASE_SUMMARY | | HF Warning fix | COMPLETE | 1 | ✅ N/A | ✅ Comments | | Architecture Review | COMPLETE | 1 | N/A | ✅ Tickets created | ### ⚠️ In Progress or Pending | Item | Status | Notes | |------|--------|-------| | CLI Usage Analysis Research | PENDING | Research doc created (claude-mcp-cli-usage-analysis-2025-11-30.md) - awaiting decisions on recommendations | | Test Coverage Restoration | PENDING | Coverage threshold at 70%, needs to be raised to 85% (pyproject.toml line 125) | | Agent Support Expansion | PENDING | Research identified Cursor/Codex/Gemini as unsupported - requires further research | | Architecture Improvements | PENDING | DI/SOA refactoring tickets created - ready for implementation | ### 📋 Local Changes Not Yet Committed ``` M .claude/agents/.dependency_cache # MPM dependency cache update M .claude/agents/.mpm_deployment_state # MPM state update M .gitignore # Added entries (likely .mcp.json) M .mcp.json # MCP server config ?? docs/research/claude-mcp-cli-usage-analysis-2025-11-30.md # Untracked research ``` **Status:** These should be committed or discarded before continuing work --- ## 4. Risk Detection ### 🔴 Critical Issues: NONE No blocking issues or critical bugs detected. --- ### 🟠 Medium-Priority Issues **Issue 1: Test Coverage Threshold Temporarily Lowered** - **Severity:** Medium - **Current Status:** Coverage at 70% (should be 85%) - **Location:** pyproject.toml line 125 - **Impact:** Can't publish updates until coverage restored - **Root Cause:** CLI refactoring increased test surface area faster than test coverage - **Recommended Action:** 1. Review which CLI command tests are missing coverage 2. Add focused unit tests for untested code paths 3. Raise threshold back to 85% in pyproject.toml 4. Estimated effort: 2-4 hours --- **Issue 2: Untracked Research Document** - **Severity:** Low-Medium (organizational) - **Status:** Research complete, recommendations pending user decision - **File:** docs/research/claude-mcp-cli-usage-analysis-2025-11-30.md (640 lines) - **Content:** - Comprehensive analysis of Claude CLI usage - Current implementation already correct for Claude Code - Identified gaps: Only 3 agents supported (missing Cursor, Codex, Gemini) - Three options presented (Minimal docs update, add auto-remove flag, or full agent support) - **Recommended Action:** 1. Review research findings 2. Decide on priority: Documentation only vs new agent support 3. Commit or discard file 4. Estimated decision time: 30 minutes --- ### 🟡 Low-Priority Issues **Issue 3: Uncommitted Local Changes** - **Severity:** Low - **Files:** 4 modified, 1 untracked - **Impact:** Unclear project state, may interfere with new work - **Recommended Action:** - Review changes with `git diff` - Commit legitimate changes or discard unwanted changes - Clarify which are intentional vs artifacts - Estimated time: 15 minutes --- **Issue 4: Architectural Debt Identified** - **Severity:** Low (documented, not urgent) - **Details:** Architecture review (commit d5cb2c9) identified: - Dependency Injection patterns that could be improved - Service-Oriented Architecture opportunities - Created Linear tickets for improvements - **Impact:** Code maintainability, testability - **Recommended Action:** Review created tickets, prioritize improvements - **Estimated effort:** 4-8 hours per ticket (to be determined) --- ### Anti-Patterns & Technical Debt Introduced **Minor:** Refactoring work is clean with no new anti-patterns detected. Code follows established patterns: - Click command modules follow consistent structure - Tests properly mocked and organized - Documentation updated alongside code --- ## 5. Recommended Next Actions ### Phase 1: Project Cleanup (1-2 hours) - IMMEDIATE **Action 1.1: Review and Commit/Discard Local Changes** ```bash git status # Review all changes git diff .claude/agents/ # Check MPM state changes git diff .gitignore # Check gitignore additions git diff .mcp.json # Check MCP config changes ``` **Decision Required:** - Are these intentional configuration changes? - Should they be committed or discarded? - Do they reflect new development environment setup? **Effort:** 15 minutes --- **Action 1.2: Review CLI Usage Analysis Research** - **File:** docs/research/claude-mcp-cli-usage-analysis-2025-11-30.md (640 lines) - **Review:** Key findings and three options presented - **Decision Required:** Which option to pursue? - **Option A:** Documentation only (1 hour, no code changes) - **Option B:** Add `--auto-remove` flag (2 hours, safer than always removing) - **Option C:** Full agent support (21-39 hours, requires research per agent) **Effort:** 30 minutes (review) + decision time --- ### Phase 2: Code Quality Restoration (2-4 hours) - HIGH PRIORITY **Action 2.1: Restore Test Coverage to 85%** - **Current Status:** Coverage at 70% (temporarily lowered, pyproject.toml line 125) - **Required:** Identify untested CLI commands and add coverage - **Approach:** 1. Run pytest with coverage: `uv run pytest --cov` 2. Review coverage report (may need --no-cov-on-fail flag) 3. Identify untested command modules 4. Add focused unit tests for missing paths 5. Raise pyproject.toml threshold back to 85% **Why This Matters:** - Blocks future releases (pre-publish quality gate) - Refactoring surface area needs better coverage - Should be done before new features **Effort:** 2-4 hours --- ### Phase 3: Strategic Improvements (Time-Permitting) **Action 3.1: Address CLI Usage Analysis Recommendations** Based on research findings (Option A - Minimal): - Update README with agent compatibility table - Document `--force` flag behavior clearly - List unsupported agents (Cursor, Codex, Gemini) - **Effort:** 1 hour (pure documentation) Or Option B if user decision favors it: - Add `--auto-remove` flag to install command - Update tests for new flag - **Effort:** 2 hours --- **Action 3.2: Review Architecture Improvement Tickets** From commit d5cb2c9: - Check Linear for created DI/SOA improvement tickets - Assess priority and effort for each ticket - Consider scheduling for next sprint - **Effort:** 30 minutes (assessment) --- **Action 3.3: Consider Next Features** Potential work streams based on git history: 1. **Agent Support Expansion** - Add Cursor/Codex/Gemini support (if high priority) 2. **Architecture Refactoring** - Implement DI/SOA improvements 3. **Performance Optimization** - Address any identified bottlenecks 4. **Documentation Updates** - Improve clarity on agent support --- ## 6. Project Health Metrics ### Code Quality - **Test Coverage:** 70% (was 85%, temporarily lowered due to CLI refactoring) ⚠️ - **Latest Commits:** All green, no known issues ✅ - **Type Checking:** mypy configured (Python 3.11+) ✅ - **Code Formatting:** Passing with Biome/Ruff ✅ ### Documentation - **README:** Comprehensive with examples ✅ - **API Docs:** Docstrings in code ✅ - **Release Notes:** v0.7.0 summary detailed ✅ - **Architecture Docs:** Review document available ✅ - **Research Docs:** CLI analysis available (pending decision) ⏳ ### Release Status - **Version:** 0.7.0 published to PyPI ✅ - **Last Release:** 2025-11-30 (16 days ago) ✅ - **Next Release:** Pending coverage restoration, then ~4 weeks out --- ## 7. Key Files to Review ### Critical (Understand current state) - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/src/mcp_skills/cli/main.py` - Refactored entry point (69 lines) - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/src/mcp_skills/cli/commands/` - 16 extracted commands - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/docs/RELEASE_SUMMARY_v0.7.0.md` - Release notes - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/pyproject.toml` - Version, test config (lines 120-126) ### Important (Context for decisions) - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/docs/research/claude-mcp-cli-usage-analysis-2025-11-30.md` - Pending decisions - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/CHANGELOG.md` - Full changelog - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/.mcp.json` - Local config (uncommitted) - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/.gitignore` - Updated (uncommitted) ### Reference (Historical context) - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/docs/CLAUDE_CLI_INTEGRATION.md` - Integration rationale - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/docs/RELEASE_READINESS_v0.7.0.md` - Pre-release checklist - `/Users/masa/Projects/mcp-skillset/tests/cli/` - CLI test suite --- ## 8. Timeline Summary ``` 2025-11-29 18:28 - mypy ignore list updates 18:24 - Variable shadowing fix 18:23 - Code formatting 2025-11-30 (Release Day) 13:15 - Claude CLI integration docs 13:12 - Claude CLI integration tests 13:29 - Formatting fixes 13:31 - mypy ignore additions 13:37 - Version bump to 0.7.0 15:35 - HuggingFace warnings fix 15:40 - Architecture review & tickets 15:41 - Work summary 15:53 - First 4 CLI commands extracted 16:00 - 3 medium commands extracted 16:56 - recommend command extracted 17:15 - stats & enrich commands extracted 17:42 - Progress bars added 17:44 - build-skill & config commands extracted 17:56 - All commands integrated into main.py 17:57 - CLI refactoring research docs 17:58 - Final 4 Priority 3 commands extracted 18:06 - Code quality fixes 18:07 - Release readiness report 18:09 - Release summary 18:54 - Test mock paths fixed (1M-460) 21:38 - Final test implementation fixes 2025-12-16 (Today - 16 days later) Current: Work resumed for analysis ``` **Observation:** Intense single-day development (13:15-21:38) completing major refactoring and release. Now in stable maintenance state. --- ## 9. Linear Ticket Context ### Active Tickets Referenced **1M-460: CLI Refactoring** ✅ COMPLETE - Extract monolithic main.py into modular command structure - 14+ commands extracted into separate modules - All commands registered via add_command() - Tests updated and passing - Status: SHIPPED in v0.7.0 **1M-432: Claude CLI Integration** ✅ COMPLETE - Add unit tests for Claude MCP integration - Documentation of integration approach - Status: SHIPPED in v0.7.0 ### Related Work (From Architecture Review) Tickets created from commit d5cb2c9: - **DI Pattern Improvements** - Refactor services with dependency injection - **SOA Improvements** - Better service-oriented architecture - **Status:** Created, awaiting prioritization **Project:** MCP-SkillSet: Dynamic RAG Skills **URL:** https://linear.app/1m-hyperdev/project/mcp-skillset-dynamic-rag-skills-for-code-assistants-0000af8da9b0/overview **Team:** 1M HyperDev --- ## 10. Next Developer Session - Quick Start ### If Continuing This Work: 1. **First (10 min):** Clean up local state ```bash git status # Review changes # Decide: commit or discard ``` 2. **Second (30 min):** Review research findings - Read: `docs/research/claude-mcp-cli-usage-analysis-2025-11-30.md` - Decide: Option A (docs), Option B (auto-remove flag), or Option C (new agents) 3. **Third (2-4 hours):** Restore test coverage - Run: `uv run pytest --cov` (after fixing config) - Identify: Untested CLI commands - Add: Focused unit tests - Update: pyproject.toml threshold 4. **Fourth (1 hour):** Implement chosen option from research - Documentation only (1 hour) - OR add --auto-remove flag (2 hours) - OR research new agent support (7-13 hours) ### Estimated Total Time - **Cleanup & Review:** 1 hour - **Coverage Restoration:** 2-4 hours - **Next Steps:** 1-13 hours depending on choice --- ## Conclusions **Project Status:** ✅ Healthy, post-release stable state **Strengths:** - Recent major refactoring successfully completed and shipped - Clean modular CLI architecture established - Comprehensive test and release documentation - No critical issues blocking development - Clear roadmap from architecture review **Immediate Needs:** - Restore test coverage to 85% (blocker for next release) - Clean up uncommitted local changes - Review and decide on CLI usage analysis recommendations - Commit decisions into tracking system **Next Phase:** - Address whichever work stream user prioritizes - Consider architecture improvement tickets from review - Plan for agent support expansion if priority 1 **Recommendation:** Start with Phase 1 (cleanup) today, then tackle coverage restoration (Phase 2) before new features.