/**
* Surgical Echo Fix Validation Tests - Story 03
*
* TDD tests that validate the surgical echo fix implementation
* Based on AC 3.1-3.17 from 03_Story_SurgicalEchoFix.md
*
* CRITICAL: These tests should FAIL before the fix and PASS after
* Tests use enhanced Villenele framework with browser and MCP command validation
*/
import { JestTestUtilities } from './jest-test-utilities';
describe('Surgical Echo Fix Validation', () => {
let testUtils: JestTestUtilities;
beforeEach(async () => {
testUtils = new JestTestUtilities({
enableDetailedLogging: true,
enableErrorDiagnostics: true,
testTimeout: 60000
});
await testUtils.setupTest('surgical-echo-fix-validation');
});
afterEach(async () => {
if (testUtils) {
await testUtils.cleanupTest();
}
});
describe('AC 3.1-3.3: Echo Fix Implementation', () => {
/**
* AC 3.2: Browser command echo elimination (display exactly once)
* This test should FAIL before fix (browser commands show double echo)
* This test should PASS after fix (browser commands show single echo)
*/
test('Browser commands should display echo exactly once', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "browser-echo-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'pwd' }
],
workflowTimeout: 30000,
sessionName: 'browser-echo-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Debug: log the actual response to understand what's happening
console.log('Browser command test result:', {
success: result.success,
responseLength: result.concatenatedResponses.length,
response: result.concatenatedResponses
});
// Count occurrences of the command 'pwd' in the response
const commandOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/pwd/g) || []).length;
// Browser commands should show echo exactly once (not twice)
// EXPECTED TO FAIL before fix (will show 2 occurrences)
// EXPECTED TO PASS after fix (will show 1 occurrence)
expect(commandOccurrences).toBe(1);
// Additional validation: ensure command result is present
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('/home/jsbattig');
});
/**
* AC 3.3: MCP command echo preservation (unchanged behavior)
* This test should PASS both before and after fix
*/
test('MCP commands should maintain single echo behavior', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "mcp-echo-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_exec {"sessionName": "mcp-echo-test", "command": "pwd"}'
],
workflowTimeout: 30000,
sessionName: 'mcp-echo-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Count occurrences of the command 'pwd' in the response
const commandOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/pwd/g) || []).length;
// MCP commands should always show echo exactly once
expect(commandOccurrences).toBe(1);
// Ensure command result is present
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('/home/jsbattig');
});
});
describe('AC 3.7-3.9: Enhanced Villenele Validation', () => {
/**
* AC 3.7: Single browser command echo validation
*/
test('Single browser command shows consistent echo behavior', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "single-browser-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'whoami' }
],
workflowTimeout: 30000,
sessionName: 'single-browser-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Browser command should appear exactly once
const whoamiOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/whoami/g) || []).length;
expect(whoamiOccurrences).toBe(1);
// Result should be present
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('jsbattig');
});
/**
* AC 3.8: Multiple browser commands echo validation
*/
test('Multiple browser commands show consistent echo behavior', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "multiple-browser-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'pwd' },
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'whoami' },
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'echo test-browser' }
],
workflowTimeout: 45000,
sessionName: 'multiple-browser-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Each command should appear exactly once
const pwdOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/pwd/g) || []).length;
const whoamiOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/whoami/g) || []).length;
const echoOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/echo test-browser/g) || []).length;
expect(pwdOccurrences).toBe(1);
expect(whoamiOccurrences).toBe(1);
expect(echoOccurrences).toBe(1);
// Results should be present
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('/home/jsbattig');
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('jsbattig');
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('test-browser');
});
/**
* AC 3.9: Mixed command scenario echo validation
*/
test('Mixed browser and MCP commands show consistent echo behavior', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "mixed-echo-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'pwd' },
'ssh_exec {"sessionName": "mixed-echo-test", "command": "whoami"}',
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'echo browser-cmd' },
'ssh_exec {"sessionName": "mixed-echo-test", "command": "echo mcp-cmd"}'
],
workflowTimeout: 60000,
sessionName: 'mixed-echo-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Each command should appear exactly once regardless of initiator
const pwdOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/pwd/g) || []).length;
const whoamiOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/whoami/g) || []).length;
const browserEchoOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/echo browser-cmd/g) || []).length;
const mcpEchoOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/echo mcp-cmd/g) || []).length;
expect(pwdOccurrences).toBe(1);
expect(whoamiOccurrences).toBe(1);
expect(browserEchoOccurrences).toBe(1);
expect(mcpEchoOccurrences).toBe(1);
// Results should be present
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('/home/jsbattig');
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('jsbattig');
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('browser-cmd');
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('mcp-cmd');
});
});
describe('AC 3.4-3.6: Command State Sync Preservation', () => {
/**
* AC 3.4: Browser command tracking preservation
* Verify that browser commands are still tracked by Command State Sync
*/
test('Browser command tracking continues to work after fix', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "tracking-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'pwd' },
// This MCP command should be gated if browser command tracking works
'ssh_exec {"sessionName": "tracking-test", "command": "whoami"}'
],
workflowTimeout: 30000,
sessionName: 'tracking-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Browser command should execute and be tracked (echo fixed but tracking preserved)
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('pwd');
// MCP command should be gated due to browser command in buffer
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('BROWSER_COMMANDS_EXECUTED');
});
/**
* AC 3.5: MCP command gating preservation
*/
test('MCP command gating continues to work after fix', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "gating-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'sleep 1' }, // Browser command to trigger gating
'ssh_exec {"sessionName": "gating-test", "command": "pwd"}' // Should be gated
],
workflowTimeout: 30000,
sessionName: 'gating-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Browser command should execute (with fixed echo)
const sleepOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/sleep 1/g) || []).length;
expect(sleepOccurrences).toBe(1); // Fixed echo: only one occurrence
// MCP command should be gated
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('BROWSER_COMMANDS_EXECUTED');
});
/**
* AC 3.6: Command cancellation preservation
*/
test('Command cancellation continues to work after fix', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "cancellation-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'sleep 5' },
'ssh_cancel_command {"sessionName": "cancellation-test"}'
],
workflowTimeout: 20000,
sessionName: 'cancellation-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Command should be cancelled (cancellation functionality preserved)
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toMatch(/cancelled|interrupt|abort|killed/i);
// Echo should be fixed (only one occurrence of sleep command)
const sleepOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/sleep 5/g) || []).length;
expect(sleepOccurrences).toBe(1);
});
});
describe('AC 3.10-3.12: System Preservation', () => {
/**
* AC 3.11: WebSocket message format preservation
*/
test('WebSocket message format remains unchanged after fix', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "format-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'pwd' }
],
workflowTimeout: 30000,
sessionName: 'format-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// CRLF line endings should be preserved
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('\r\n');
// Bracket prompt format should be preserved
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toMatch(/\[jsbattig@localhost [^\]]+\]\$/);
// Message structure should remain intact
expect(result.concatenatedResponses.length).toBeGreaterThan(10);
});
/**
* AC 3.12: SSH connection behavior preservation
*/
test('SSH connection behavior remains unchanged after fix', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "ssh-behavior-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'pwd' },
'ssh_exec {"sessionName": "ssh-behavior-test", "command": "whoami"}'
],
workflowTimeout: 30000,
sessionName: 'ssh-behavior-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// SSH commands should execute successfully
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('/home/jsbattig');
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('jsbattig');
// Connection should remain stable
expect(result.success).toBe(true);
});
});
describe('AC 3.13-3.17: Stability & Maintenance', () => {
/**
* AC 3.13: Stability and error handling validation
*/
test('Error handling remains robust after fix', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "error-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'nonexistent-command' }
],
workflowTimeout: 30000,
sessionName: 'error-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Error should be handled gracefully
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toMatch(/not found|command not found|No such file/i);
// Command should appear only once (echo fix maintained even for errors)
const commandOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/nonexistent-command/g) || []).length;
expect(commandOccurrences).toBe(1);
});
/**
* AC 3.14: Long-term stability validation
*/
test('Multiple consecutive browser commands maintain echo fix stability', async () => {
const config = {
preWebSocketCommands: [
'ssh_connect {"name": "stability-test", "host": "localhost", "username": "jsbattig", "keyFilePath": "/home/jsbattig/.ssh/id_ed25519"}'
],
postWebSocketCommands: [
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'pwd' },
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'whoami' },
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'date' },
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'echo stability-test' },
{ initiator: 'browser' as const, command: 'pwd' } // Repeat command to test consistency
],
workflowTimeout: 60000,
sessionName: 'stability-test'
};
const result = await testUtils.runTerminalHistoryTest(config);
// Each command should appear exactly once throughout the sequence
const pwdOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/pwd/g) || []).length;
const whoamiOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/whoami/g) || []).length;
const dateOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/date/g) || []).length;
const echoOccurrences = (result.concatenatedResponses.match(/echo stability-test/g) || []).length;
expect(pwdOccurrences).toBe(2); // pwd appears twice (executed twice)
expect(whoamiOccurrences).toBe(1);
expect(dateOccurrences).toBe(1);
expect(echoOccurrences).toBe(1);
// All results should be present
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('/home/jsbattig');
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('jsbattig');
expect(result.concatenatedResponses).toContain('stability-test');
});
});
});