/**
* Story 01: Enhanced Parameter Structure Refactor - Acceptance Criteria Tests
*
* Tests all 14 acceptance criteria for enhanced parameter structure in PostWebSocketCommandExecutor.
* Focuses on parameter validation, default handling, and mixed parameter combinations.
*
* CRITICAL: Following TDD methodology - these are failing tests that drive implementation.
*/
import { PostWebSocketCommandExecutor, ParameterValidationError, PostWebSocketCommand } from './post-websocket-command-executor';
import { MCPClient } from './mcp-client';
import { InitialHistoryReplayCapture } from './initial-history-replay-capture';
import WebSocket from 'ws';
// Mock WebSocket for testing parameter validation (not command execution)
const mockWebSocket = {
readyState: WebSocket.OPEN,
send: jest.fn(),
close: jest.fn(),
on: jest.fn(),
off: jest.fn(),
removeAllListeners: jest.fn()
} as unknown as WebSocket;
describe('Story 01: Enhanced Parameter Structure Refactor', () => {
let executor: PostWebSocketCommandExecutor;
let mockMCPClient: jest.Mocked<MCPClient>;
let mockHistoryCapture: jest.Mocked<InitialHistoryReplayCapture>;
beforeEach(() => {
// Create mocks for dependencies
mockMCPClient = {
callTool: jest.fn().mockResolvedValue({ success: true, result: 'mock-response' })
} as unknown as jest.Mocked<MCPClient>;
mockHistoryCapture = {
getRealTimeMessages: jest.fn().mockReturnValue([]),
getHistoryMessages: jest.fn().mockReturnValue([])
} as unknown as jest.Mocked<InitialHistoryReplayCapture>;
executor = new PostWebSocketCommandExecutor(mockMCPClient, mockHistoryCapture);
});
describe('AC 1.1: Enhanced structure acceptance', () => {
it('should accept enhanced structure without validation errors', async () => {
// Given: Enhanced parameter structure
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'mcp-client', command: 'pwd' }
];
// When: Processing the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should not throw validation errors
await expect(promise).resolves.toBeDefined();
});
it('should properly type and route enhanced commands', async () => {
// Given: Enhanced parameter structure
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'date' }
];
// When: Executing commands
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Command should be properly typed and routed
expect(results).toHaveLength(1);
expect(results[0].initiator).toBe('browser');
expect(results[0].command).toBe('date');
});
});
describe('AC 1.2: Invalid initiator validation', () => {
it('should throw clear error for invalid initiator', async () => {
// Given: Invalid initiator
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'invalid-type' as any, command: 'pwd' }
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should throw specific error
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow(ParameterValidationError);
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow("Initiator must be 'browser' or 'mcp-client'");
});
});
describe('AC 1.3: Basic cancellation parameter acceptance', () => {
it('should accept cancel parameter without errors', async () => {
// Given: Enhanced parameter with cancellation
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'nano /tmp/test', cancel: true }
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should accept without errors and prepare for timeout-based cancellation logic
await expect(promise).resolves.toBeDefined();
const results = await promise;
expect(results[0].cancelRequested).toBe(true);
});
});
describe('AC 1.4: Cancellation with custom timeout', () => {
it('should accept both cancel and waitToCancelMs parameters', async () => {
// Given: Custom cancellation timeout
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'mcp-client', command: 'sleep 30', cancel: true, waitToCancelMs: 5000 }
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should accept both parameters and prepare 5-second cancellation timeout
expect(results[0].cancelRequested).toBe(true);
expect(results[0].waitToCancelMs).toBe(5000);
});
});
describe('AC 1.5: Invalid timeout value rejection', () => {
it('should throw error for negative timeout values', async () => {
// Given: Invalid negative timeout
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'mcp-client', command: 'pwd', cancel: true, waitToCancelMs: -100 }
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should throw specific error
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow(ParameterValidationError);
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow("waitToCancelMs must be positive number");
});
it('should throw error for zero timeout values', async () => {
// Given: Invalid zero timeout
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'pwd', cancel: true, waitToCancelMs: 0 }
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should throw specific error
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow("waitToCancelMs must be positive number");
});
});
describe('AC 1.6: Timeout without cancellation handling', () => {
it('should accept but log warning when waitToCancelMs provided with cancel false', async () => {
// Mock console.warn to capture warning
const warnSpy = jest.spyOn(console, 'warn').mockImplementation();
// Given: Timeout without cancellation
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'pwd', cancel: false, waitToCancelMs: 5000 }
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should accept but log warning and execute normally
expect(warnSpy).toHaveBeenCalledWith("waitToCancelMs ignored when cancel is false");
expect(results[0].cancelRequested).toBe(false);
expect(results[0].waitToCancelMs).toBe(5000); // Preserved but ignored
warnSpy.mockRestore();
});
});
describe('AC 1.7: Default cancellation timeout', () => {
it('should default waitToCancelMs to 10000 when cancel is true', async () => {
// Given: Command with cancel but no waitToCancelMs
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'sleep 20', cancel: true }
];
// When: Processing the configuration
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should default waitToCancelMs to 10000 (10 seconds)
expect(results[0].cancelRequested).toBe(true);
expect(results[0].waitToCancelMs).toBe(10000);
});
});
describe('AC 1.8: Default cancel behavior', () => {
it('should default cancel to false when not provided', async () => {
// Given: Command with no cancel parameter
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'mcp-client', command: 'pwd' }
];
// When: Processing the configuration
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should default cancel to false and execute normally
expect(results[0].cancelRequested).toBe(false);
expect(results[0].waitToCancelMs).toBe(10000); // Default timeout even when not cancelling
});
});
describe('AC 1.9: Minimal parameter command execution', () => {
it('should execute normally with only required parameters', async () => {
// Given: Command with only required parameters
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'ls' }
];
// When: Executing the configuration
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should execute normally without timeout or cancellation logic
expect(results).toHaveLength(1);
expect(results[0].initiator).toBe('browser');
expect(results[0].command).toBe('ls');
expect(results[0].cancelRequested).toBe(false);
});
});
describe('AC 1.10: Invalid cancel type rejection', () => {
it('should throw error for non-boolean cancel value', async () => {
// Given: Invalid cancel value
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'pwd', cancel: 'maybe' as any }
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should throw specific error
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow(ParameterValidationError);
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow("cancel must be boolean value (true or false)");
});
});
describe('AC 1.11: Invalid timeout type rejection', () => {
it('should throw error for non-numeric waitToCancelMs', async () => {
// Given: Invalid waitToCancelMs
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'pwd', cancel: true, waitToCancelMs: 'soon' as any }
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should throw specific error
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow(ParameterValidationError);
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow("waitToCancelMs must be numeric value in milliseconds");
});
});
describe('AC 1.12: Missing required initiator', () => {
it('should throw error for missing initiator', async () => {
// Given: Missing initiator
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ command: 'pwd', cancel: true } as any
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should throw specific error
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow(ParameterValidationError);
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow("initiator field required: must be 'browser' or 'mcp-client'");
});
});
describe('AC 1.13: Missing required command', () => {
it('should throw error for missing command', async () => {
// Given: Missing command
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', cancel: true } as any
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should throw specific error
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow(ParameterValidationError);
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow("command field required: must be non-empty string");
});
it('should throw error for empty command string', async () => {
// Given: Empty command string
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: ' ' }
];
// When: Validating the configuration
const promise = executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should throw specific error
await expect(promise).rejects.toThrow("command field required: must be non-empty string");
});
});
describe('AC 1.14: Mixed parameter combinations handling', () => {
it('should handle complex configuration with all parameter variations', async () => {
// Given: Complex configuration with all parameter variations
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'pwd' }, // Basic browser
{ initiator: 'mcp-client', command: 'date' }, // Basic MCP
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'nano file.txt', cancel: true }, // Browser + default cancel
{ initiator: 'mcp-client', command: 'sleep 30', cancel: true, waitToCancelMs: 3000 }, // MCP + custom cancel
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'echo done' } // Basic browser final
];
// When: Processing the configuration
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Each command should be validated according to its specific parameters
expect(results).toHaveLength(5);
// Validate first command - Basic browser
expect(results[0].initiator).toBe('browser');
expect(results[0].command).toBe('pwd');
expect(results[0].cancelRequested).toBe(false);
// Validate second command - Basic MCP
expect(results[1].initiator).toBe('mcp-client');
expect(results[1].command).toBe('date');
expect(results[1].cancelRequested).toBe(false);
// Validate third command - Browser + default cancel
expect(results[2].initiator).toBe('browser');
expect(results[2].command).toBe('nano file.txt');
expect(results[2].cancelRequested).toBe(true);
expect(results[2].waitToCancelMs).toBe(10000); // Default timeout
// Validate fourth command - MCP + custom cancel
expect(results[3].initiator).toBe('mcp-client');
expect(results[3].command).toBe('sleep 30');
expect(results[3].cancelRequested).toBe(true);
expect(results[3].waitToCancelMs).toBe(3000); // Custom timeout
// Validate fifth command - Basic browser final
expect(results[4].initiator).toBe('browser');
expect(results[4].command).toBe('echo done');
expect(results[4].cancelRequested).toBe(false);
// And maintain sequential execution order regardless of parameter complexity
expect(results.map(r => r.command)).toEqual(['pwd', 'date', 'nano file.txt', 'sleep 30', 'echo done']);
});
it('should prepare appropriate execution strategy for each command type', async () => {
// Given: Mixed initiator types
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'pwd' },
{ initiator: 'mcp-client', command: 'date' }
];
// When: Processing the configuration
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should prepare correct execution strategy per command
expect(results[0].initiator).toBe('browser');
expect(results[1].initiator).toBe('mcp-client');
// Execution strategy is prepared but actual routing logic will be in future stories
});
});
describe('Legacy string format support', () => {
it('should handle legacy string commands with default parameters', async () => {
// Given: Legacy string commands
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
'pwd',
'date'
];
// When: Processing the configuration
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should convert to enhanced structure with defaults
expect(results).toHaveLength(2);
expect(results[0].initiator).toBe('mcp-client'); // Default initiator
expect(results[0].command).toBe('pwd');
expect(results[0].cancelRequested).toBe(false);
expect(results[0].waitToCancelMs).toBe(10000);
expect(results[1].initiator).toBe('mcp-client'); // Default initiator
expect(results[1].command).toBe('date');
expect(results[1].cancelRequested).toBe(false);
});
it('should handle mixed legacy and enhanced formats', async () => {
// Given: Mixed formats
const commands: PostWebSocketCommand[] = [
'pwd', // Legacy
{ initiator: 'browser', command: 'date', cancel: true } // Enhanced
];
// When: Processing the configuration
const results = await executor.executeCommands(commands, mockWebSocket);
// Then: Should handle both formats correctly
expect(results[0].initiator).toBe('mcp-client'); // Legacy default
expect(results[0].cancelRequested).toBe(false);
expect(results[1].initiator).toBe('browser'); // Enhanced specified
expect(results[1].cancelRequested).toBe(true);
});
});
});