compare

Instructions

Implementation Reference

• src/index.ts:178-192 (registration)

  Registration of the 'compare' tool in the MCP ListTools response, defining name, description, and input schema.

  {
    name: 'compare',
    description: 'Full analysis pipeline: extract producer schemas, trace consumer usage, and compare them to find mismatches. Returns a detailed report.',
    inputSchema: {
      type: 'object',
      properties: {
        producerDir: { type: 'string', description: 'Path to MCP server source directory' },
        consumerDir: { type: 'string', description: 'Path to consumer/client source directory' },
        format: { type: 'string', enum: ['json', 'markdown', 'summary'], description: 'Output format' },
        strict: { type: 'boolean', description: 'Strict mode for comparison' },
        direction: { type: 'string', enum: ['producer_to_consumer', 'consumer_to_producer', 'bidirectional'], description: 'Data flow direction (default: producer_to_consumer)' },
      },
      required: ['producerDir', 'consumerDir'],
    },
  },

• src/index.ts:57-63 (schema)

  Zod input schema (CompareInput) used for validating 'compare' tool arguments.

  const CompareInput = z.object({
    producerDir: z.string().describe('Path to MCP server source directory'),
    consumerDir: z.string().describe('Path to consumer/client source directory'),
    format: z.enum(['json', 'markdown', 'summary']).optional().describe('Output format (default: json)'),
    strict: z.boolean().optional().describe('Strict mode: treat missing optional properties as warnings'),
    direction: z.enum(['producer_to_consumer', 'consumer_to_producer', 'bidirectional']).optional().describe('Data flow direction for compatibility checking (default: producer_to_consumer)'),
  });

• src/index.ts:377-403 (handler)

  Tool handler in CallToolRequest: parses input, invokes compareDirectories, formats and returns the result.

  case 'compare': {
    const input = CompareInput.parse(args);
    log(`Comparing: ${input.producerDir} vs ${input.consumerDir}`);
  
    const result = await compareDirectories(
      input.producerDir,
      input.consumerDir,
      {
        strict: input.strict,
        direction: input.direction
      }
    );
  
    const format = (input.format || 'json') as OutputFormat;
    const output = formatResult(result, format);
  
    log(`Analysis complete: ${result.summary.matchCount} matches, ${result.summary.mismatchCount} mismatches`);
  
    return {
      content: [
        {
          type: 'text',
          text: output,
        },
      ],
    };
  }

• src/compare/index.ts:321-337 (helper)

  Convenience helper: orchestrates extraction from directories and calls compareSchemas.

  export async function compareDirectories(
    backendDir: string,
    frontendDir: string,
    options: CompareOptions = {}
  ): Promise<TraceResult> {
    // Import dynamically to avoid circular deps
    const { extractProducerSchemas } = await import('../extract/index.js');
    const { traceConsumerUsage } = await import('../trace/index.js');
    
    console.log(`\n[Compare] Backend: ${backendDir}`);
    console.log(`[Compare] Frontend: ${frontendDir}\n`);
    
    const producers = await extractProducerSchemas({ rootDir: backendDir });
    const consumers = await traceConsumerUsage({ rootDir: frontendDir });
    
    return compareSchemas(producers, consumers, options);
  }

• src/compare/index.ts:27-93 (helper)

  Core comparison function: matches producers and consumers, detects argument and property mismatches.

  export function compareSchemas(
    producers: ProducerSchema[],
    consumers: ConsumerSchema[],
    options: CompareOptions = {}
  ): TraceResult {
    // Default to producer_to_consumer (API response pattern)
    const direction = options.direction || 'producer_to_consumer';
  
    console.log(`[Comparator] Comparing ${producers.length} producers vs ${consumers.length} consumers`);
    console.log(`[Comparator] Direction: ${direction}`);
  
    const matches: Match[] = [];
    const mismatches: Mismatch[] = [];
  
    // Index producers by tool name for quick lookup
    const producerMap = new Map<string, ProducerSchema>();
    for (const producer of producers) {
      producerMap.set(producer.toolName, producer);
    }
  
    // Analyze each consumer usage
    for (const consumer of consumers) {
      const producer = producerMap.get(consumer.toolName);
  
      if (!producer) {
        // Tool not found in producer definitions
        mismatches.push({
          toolName: consumer.toolName,
          issueType: 'UNKNOWN_TOOL',
          description: `Tool "${consumer.toolName}" is called but not defined in producer`,
          consumerLocation: consumer.callSite,
        });
        continue;
      }
  
      // Check argument mismatches (consumer → producer direction)
      const argMismatches = checkArgumentMismatches(producer, consumer, direction);
      mismatches.push(...argMismatches);
  
      // Check expected property mismatches (producer → consumer direction)
      const propMismatches = checkPropertyMismatches(producer, consumer, options, direction);
      mismatches.push(...propMismatches);
  
      // If no mismatches for this call, it's a match
      if (argMismatches.length === 0 && propMismatches.length === 0) {
        matches.push({
          toolName: consumer.toolName,
          producerLocation: producer.location,
          consumerLocation: consumer.callSite,
        });
      }
    }
  
    return {
      timestamp: new Date().toISOString(),
      producerSource: producers.length > 0 ? producers[0].location.file : '',
      consumerSource: consumers.length > 0 ? consumers[0].callSite.file : '',
      matches,
      mismatches,
      summary: {
        totalTools: producers.length,
        totalCalls: consumers.length,
        matchCount: matches.length,
        mismatchCount: mismatches.length,
      },
    };
  }