research.md•19.6 kB
# Model Context Protocol (MCP) Research
## What is MCP?
The Model Context Protocol (MCP) is an open-source protocol developed by Anthropic that enables AI systems like Claude to securely connect with various data sources and tools. It provides a standardized interface that allows Large Language Models (LLMs) to:
- Access external data sources and tools beyond their built-in knowledge
- Interact with specific data sources or tools through a consistent API
- Receive responses in a standardized format optimized for LLM consumption
MCP works through a client-server architecture where:
- **MCP Servers** expose data, tools, and prompts through the protocol
- **MCP Clients** (like Claude, Cursor, WindSurf, Cline, Cherry Studio, HyperChat, Zed code editor, or custom applications) connect to these servers to access their capabilities
According to [Cloudflare's documentation](https://developers.cloudflare.com/agents/concepts/tools/#model-context-protocol-mcp), MCP defines a consistent interface for:
- **Tool Discovery**: Systems can dynamically discover available tools
- **Parameter Validation**: Tools specify their input requirements using JSON Schema
- **Error Handling**: Standardized error reporting and recovery
- **State Management**: Tools can maintain state across invocations
Official docs: https://modelcontextprotocol.io/introduction
## Which Problem Does MCP Solve?
MCP addresses several critical challenges in the AI ecosystem, e.g:
- **Context Window Limitations**: LLMs have finite context windows, so MCP servers allow them to access data beyond their built-in knowledge
- **Up-to-date Information**: They provide access to real-time or current data that wasn't available during model training
- **Private Data Access**: They enable secure access to private or proprietary information
- **Tool Use**: They allow LLMs to use external tools and services
- **Standardization**: They provide a consistent interface across different data sources
- **Security**: Servers control their own resources, with no need to share API keys with LLM providers
- **System Boundaries**: Maintains clear boundaries and separation of concerns between LLMs and external systems
## Why Should We Use MCP Instead of Building Custom Integrations?
Using MCP instead of custom integrations offers several significant advantages, e.g:
- **Standardization**: MCP provides a consistent interface, reducing the need to learn multiple APIs
- **Compatibility**: Applications built for MCP can work with any MCP-compatible client or server
- **Reduced Development Time**: No need to build and maintain custom integration code
- **Future-Proofing**: As the protocol evolves, our server implementation remains compatible without major changes
- **No Vendor Lock-in**: The open standard means you're not tied to any specific LLM provider
- **Separation of Concerns**: Clear boundaries between LLM functionality and external systems
## Examples of Adoption (Evidence of Traction)
1. **Growing Ecosystem**
   - [MCP.so](https://mcp.so/) lists over 3,200 MCP servers in their directory
   - The [official MCP GitHub organization](https://github.com/modelcontextprotocol) has 10,000+ followers
   - The [MCP servers repository](https://github.com/modelcontextprotocol/servers) was created 3 months ago and has over 20,000 stars and 2,000+ forks  
   - The Python SDK has 4,400+ stars and 410+ forks
   - The TypeScript SDK has 2,700+ stars and 270+ forks
2. **Major Company Support**
   - Anthropic (Claude) developed the protocol and supports it natively
   - Cloudflare has integrated MCP into their Agents platform
   - Quarkus has introduced Java-based MCP server implementations
3. **Diverse Server Implementations**
   **Web & Content Access**
   - Firecrawl MCP Server (web scraping)
   - Brave Search (web and local search using Brave's Search API)
   - Fetch (web content fetching and conversion for efficient LLM usage)
   - Puppeteer (browser automation and web scraping)
   **Data Storage & Management**
   - Filesystem MCP Server (file operations with configurable access controls)
   - JDBC MCP Server (database access to any JDBC-compatible database)
   - Neon MCP Server (database management via Neon API)
   - S3 MCP Server (access to Amazon S3 cloud storage)
   - [IPFS Gateway](https://mcp.so/server/Story%20Protocol%20SDK%20MCP/piplabs) (interaction with InterPlanetary File System)
   - LocalStorage MCP (persistent browser-based storage access)
   - Redis MCP Server (in-memory data structure store access)
   - MongoDB MCP Server (document-oriented database access)
   **AI Tools & Augmentation**
   - Sequential Thinking (structured problem-solving process)
   - EverArt (AI image generation using various models)
   - ChatSum (chat message summarization)
   - 21st.dev Magic AI Agent (frontend interaction similar to V0)
   **Developer Tools**
   - GitHub MCP Server (repository management and file operations)
   - FastDomainCheck (bulk domain name registration status checking)
   
   **Utilities**
   - Time MCP Server (time and timezone conversion capabilities)
4. **Client Applications**
   - Claude (native support)
   - Cursor 
   - WindSurf
   - Cline
   - Cherry Studio
   - HyperChat
   - Zed code editor
5. **Language Support**
   - Python SDK
   - TypeScript SDK
   - Java SDK (via Quarkus)
   - Kotlin SDK
   - Rust SDK
## Growth and Future Potential
1. **Expanding Language Support**
   - Beyond the established Python, TypeScript, Java, and Kotlin SDKs
   - A new [Rust SDK](https://github.com/modelcontextprotocol/rust-sdk) has been released, expanding reach to systems programming
   - This multi-language approach ensures MCP can be integrated across diverse tech stacks
2. **Corporate Collaborations**
   - Java SDK is maintained in collaboration with Spring AI
   - Kotlin SDK is maintained in collaboration with JetBrains
   - These partnerships with leading development tool providers enhance credibility and adoption
3. **Developer Tooling**
   - Dedicated [MCP Inspector](https://github.com/modelcontextprotocol/inspector) visual testing tool
   - Starter templates for quick server creation:
     - create-python-server
     - create-typescript-server
     - create-kotlin-server
   - These tools lower the barrier to entry for new developers
4. **Active Development**
   - All repositories show recent updates as of March 2025
   - Active GitHub issues and pull requests indicate ongoing development
   - Regular community discussions demonstrate healthy engagement
5. **Strategic Advantages for Storacha**
   - MCP's growing ecosystem provides Storacha with a ready market of developers and applications
   - The protocol's standardization across AI systems makes Storacha's storage capabilities immediately useful to a wide range of applications
   - As AI agents become more prevalent, the need for secure, decentralized storage accessible via MCP will increase
6. **Expanded User Base Beyond Developers**
   - MCP enables Storacha to reach non-technical users through AI applications
   - End users of LLM applications can benefit from Storacha's storage without understanding the technical details
   - Content creators using AI tools can store and retrieve their assets on Storacha
   - Businesses utilizing AI workflows can leverage Storacha for trustless data storage
   - Researchers working with AI models can use Storacha for dataset storage and sharing
   - This broadens Storacha's total addressable market significantly beyond the developer community
## How Storacha Can Leverage MCP
- **Standardized Access Layer**: Implement an MCP server as the primary interface for LLMs to interact with Storacha storage
- **Simplified Integration**: Allow AI applications to easily connect to Storacha without custom code
- **Expanded Market Reach**: Make Storacha accessible to the growing ecosystem of MCP-compatible clients
- **Enhanced Feature Discovery**: Use MCP's tool discovery to expose Storacha's capabilities to LLMs
A Storacha MCP server would support core functionality including:
- **Upload operations**: Store files on Storacha
- **Retrieve operations**: Get files from Storacha by CID
- **List operations**: List uploaded files
- **Metadata operations**: Get information about stored files
- **Status operations**: Check the status of the Storacha service
- **Access control**: Leverage UCANs for fine-grained permissions
## Does MCP Solve the Agent Data-Sharing Problem?
Yes, MCP directly addresses the agent data-sharing problem, e.g:
- **Standardized Communication**: Provides a common language for agents to exchange data
- **Secure Access Control**: When combined with Storacha's UCAN integration, enables fine-grained access permissions
- **Autonomous Interaction**: Agents can discover and use tools from each other without human intervention
- **Verifiable Data Exchange**: Content addressing ensures data integrity across agent interactions
- **Privacy Preservation**: Agents control what data they share and with whom
- **Cross-Platform Compatibility**: Works across different agent frameworks and implementations
MCP serves as the standardized protocol layer that allows AI agents to seamlessly interact with Storacha's decentralized storage, enabling secure and autonomous data sharing without relying on centralized infrastructure.
## Market Timing and Implementation Considerations
### Market Timing
1. **Protocol Maturity**
   - MCP has reached sufficient maturity with stable SDKs in multiple languages
   - The core specification is well-defined and unlikely to undergo major breaking changes
   - The community has validated the approach with thousands of implementations
2. **Competitive Positioning**
   - Early adoption would position Storacha as a leader in the decentralized storage space for AI Tooling
   - Few decentralized storage solutions currently offer MCP integration, creating a market differentiation opportunity
   - First-mover advantage in connecting decentralized storage to the AI ecosystem
3. **Market Readiness**
   - The AI agent ecosystem is rapidly expanding and creating demand for storage solutions
   - Growing awareness of centralized storage limitations is driving interest in alternatives
   - Increasing focus on AI data ownership and privacy aligns perfectly with Storacha's value proposition
4. **Strategic Window**
   - The AI ecosystem is currently establishing patterns for data storage and retrieval
   - Integration now could influence how AI applications approach storage in the future
   - Waiting too long risks other storage solutions becoming entrenched in the ecosystem
5. **Balancing Considerations**
   - **Pro-Implementation Now**: Capture early adopters, influence the ecosystem, establish thought leadership
   - **Potential Caution**: Smaller current user base might mean slower initial adoption, protocol could still evolve
## Client Integration
Understanding how clients integrate with MCP servers is essential for grasping the full ecosystem.
MCP clients typically integrate with servers through these common patterns, e.g:
1. **Direct SDK Integration**: Applications embed MCP client SDKs directly to connect to MCP servers
2. **AI Agent Framework Integration**: AI agent frameworks connect to MCP servers to extend agent capabilities
3. **LLM Application Plugins**: LLM applications like Claude Desktop and Cursor support MCP servers as plugins
### TypeScript/JavaScript Integration Example
```typescript
import { createClient } from '@modelcontextprotocol/typescript-sdk';
// Initialize the MCP client
const client = createClient({
  baseUrl: 'https://api.storacha.ai/mcp',
  // Optional authentication
  auth: {
    type: 'bearer',
    token: process.env.STORACHA_API_KEY
  }
});
// List available resources
const resources = await client.resources.list();
console.log('Available resources:', resources);
// Upload a file to Storacha
const uploadResult = await client.tools.invoke('upload', {
  file: new Blob([fileData], { type: 'application/octet-stream' }),
  name: 'example-document.pdf'
});
console.log('File uploaded with CID:', uploadResult.cid);
// Retrieve a file by CID
const retrieveResult = await client.tools.invoke('retrieve', {
  cid: 'bafybeigdyrzt5sfp7udm7hu76uh7y26nf3efuylqabf3oclgtqy55fbzdi'
});
console.log('Retrieved file data:', retrieveResult);
```
### LLM Application Integration (Claude)
Claude and similar LLM applications can access Storacha through their native MCP integration e.g:
1. Users install and configure the Storacha MCP server
2. The LLM application discovers the Storacha server and its capabilities
3. Users can then prompt the LLM to interact with their Storacha storage:
Example prompt:
```sh
Please upload this PDF to my Storacha storage and then list all my stored files.
```
Claude would then:
1. Recognize the task requires Storacha access
2. Use its MCP integration to connect to the Storacha server
3. Upload the file and list stored files using the MCP API
4. Return results to the user
### Integration with AI Agents
For autonomous AI agents, Storacha can serve as persistent memory:
```typescript
// Agent setup with Storacha integration
const agent = new Agent({
  llm: new Claude(),
  tools: [
    // Register Storacha as a memory tool
    {
      name: 'memory',
      description: 'Store and retrieve agent memory',
      connector: createMCPConnector({
        serverUrl: 'https://api.storacha.ai/mcp',
        authToken: process.env.STORACHA_API_KEY
      })
    }
  ]
});
// Agent can now read/write to Storacha
await agent.run(`
  1. Save my current context to persistent memory
  2. Retrieve my previous analysis about climate data
  3. Update my knowledge base with these new findings
`);
```
### Multi-Agent Collaboration via Storacha
Storacha can facilitate data sharing between multiple agents, e.g:
```typescript
// Agent A generates data
const analysisResults = {
  findings: "Temperature patterns show 1.5°C increase over 50 years",
  data: [/* time series data */],
  charts: [/* chart data */],
  timestamp: new Date().toISOString()
};
// Agent A stores data into Storacha
const resultCid = await agentA.tools.invoke("memory.store", {
  data: analysisResults,
  metadata: {
    type: "analysis", 
    topic: "climate-patterns",
    created: new Date().toISOString()
  },
});
console.log(`Data stored with CID: ${resultCid}`);
// --------------------------------------------
// Later, in a different context or application
// --------------------------------------------
// Agent B retrieves data shared by Agent A
try {
  const sharedData = await agentB.tools.invoke("memory.retrieve", {
    cid: resultCid
  });
  
  console.log("Retrieved shared analysis:", sharedData);
  
  // Agent B can now build upon Agent A's work
  await agentB.tools.invoke("memory.store", {
    data: {
      originalAnalysis: resultCid,
      extendedFindings: "Further analysis shows regional variations...",
      additionalData: [/* more data */]
    },
    metadata: {
      type: "extended-analysis",
      basedOn: resultCid,
      topic: "regional-climate-patterns"
    }
  });
} catch (error) {
  console.error("Failed to retrieve shared data:", error);
  // Handle permission issues or missing data
}
```
This TypeScript example demonstrates how multiple agents can share and build upon each other's data through Storacha. We can use UCAN-based permissions to ensure that only authorized agents can access shared resources, while the content-addressing (CIDs) guarantees data integrity across agent interactions.
## Potential Challenges and Considerations
While implementing an MCP server for Storacha offers significant advantages, it's important to consider potential challenges and limitations.
### Implementation and Maintenance Costs
1. **Ongoing Maintenance**: The MCP standard is still evolving, which may require ongoing updates to maintain compatibility
2. **Testing Overhead**: Supporting multiple clients and ensuring consistent behavior adds testing complexity
### Ecosystem Risks
1. **Adoption Uncertainty**: While growing rapidly, MCP's long-term adoption trajectory is still uncertain
2. **Protocol Evolution**: Changes to the MCP standard could require significant updates to Storacha's MCP server implementation
3. **Client Dependencies**: Heavy reliance on specific MCP clients like Claude creates dependencies on their continued support
### Business Considerations
1. **ROI Timeline**: The return on investment might take time to materialize as the MCP ecosystem matures
2. **Market Fragmentation**: If competing protocols emerge, resources could be split between supporting multiple standards
3. **Differentiation Challenges**: If MCP becomes widely adopted across the distributed storage industry (which is likely given its growing popularity), simply supporting MCP would no longer be a unique selling point for Storacha (Access Controlled Data, Mutability, Encryption)
### Mitigation Strategies
1. **Phased Implementation**: Starting with core functionality and adding features incrementally
2. **Regular Evaluation**: Monitoring MCP ecosystem developments and adjusting strategy accordingly
3. **Community Engagement**: Actively participating in the MCP community to influence the standard's evolution
4. **Feature Differentiation**: Developing new features as we see traction with the MCP integration, such as:
   - Enhanced UCAN-based permissioning
   - AI-focused data caching and retrieval optimizations
   - Advanced encryption for sensitive AI data
   - Data mutability features
   - Multi-agent coordination tools
## Development Resources
1. **Official Documentation**
   - [MCP.io](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/)
   - [SDKs in multiple languages](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/tutorials/building-mcp-with-llms)
2. **Development Tools**
   - MCP Inspector for testing servers
   - LLM-assisted development ([Building MCP with LLMs](https://modelcontextprotocol.io/tutorials/building-mcp-with-llms))
3. **Implementation Examples**
   - [Quarkus MCP Servers](https://quarkus.io/blog/introducing-mcp-servers/) (Java)
   - Various open-source implementations on [mcp.so](https://mcp.so/)
4. **Community Support**
   - GitHub repositories
   - Discord communities
   - Technical forums
## Conclusion
I believe that implementing an MCP server for Storacha represents a strategic opportunity with significant potential benefits, e.g:
1. **Market Position**: Storacha would be among the first decentralized storage solutions to offer native MCP integration, establishing a leadership position in connecting AI applications to decentralized storage.
2. **Technical Feasibility**: With robust SDKs available in multiple languages and numerous examples to reference, implementation is technically feasible with modest development resources.
3. **Timing Advantage**: The current moment represents an ideal window where the protocol is mature enough to build on while the ecosystem is still establishing standards for AI data storage.
4. **Broader Audience**: MCP integration would expand Storacha's potential user base beyond developers to include end-users of AI applications, content creators, businesses, and researchers.
5. **Strategic Alignment**: The combination of MCP's standardized access with Storacha's decentralized storage creates a powerful solution that addresses growing concerns about AI data ownership, privacy, and vendor lock-in.