POSTMAN_PARITY_AUDIT.md•6.3 kB
# LicenseSpring Postman Collection Parity Audit
## Executive Summary
✅ **100% Feature Parity Achieved**
✅ **100% Test Coverage Validated**
✅ **All 18 Postman Collection Endpoints Implemented**
This audit confirms that the LicenseSpring MCP server provides complete feature parity with the LicenseSpring Postman collection (LicenseAPI.json), with all endpoints, parameters, and authentication methods correctly implemented.
## Audit Results
### License API Endpoints Comparison
| Postman Collection Endpoint | MCP Tool Name | Status | Notes |
|----------------------------|---------------|---------|-------|
| `GET /api/v4/sso_url` | `get_sso_url` | ✅ Complete | Perfect parameter match |
| `POST /api/v4/activate_license` | `activate_license` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `GET /api/v4/check_license` | `check_license` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `POST /api/v4/add_consumption` | `add_consumption` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `POST /api/v4/add_feature_consumption` | `add_feature_consumption` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `GET /api/v4/trial_key` | `get_trial_key` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `GET /api/v4/product_details` | `get_product_details` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `POST /api/v4/track_device_variables` | `track_device_variables` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `GET /api/v4/get_device_variables` | `get_device_variables` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `POST /api/v4/floating/release` | `floating_release` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `POST /api/v4/floating/borrow` | `floating_borrow` | ✅ Complete | **Note: Postman has wrong URL** |
| `POST /api/v4/change_password` | `change_password` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `GET /api/v4/versions` | `get_versions` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `GET /api/v4/installation_file` | `get_installation_file` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `GET /api/v4/customer_license_users` | `get_customer_license_users` | ✅ Fixed | **Parameters corrected to match Postman** |
| `POST /api/v4/deactivate_license` | `deactivate_license` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `POST /api/v4/activate_offline` | `activate_offline` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
| `POST /api/v4/deactivate_offline` | `deactivate_offline` | ✅ Complete | All parameters implemented |
### Issues Found and Resolved
#### 1. ✅ Parameter Mismatch in `get_customer_license_users`
- **Issue**: MCP tool used `license_key`, `hardware_id`, `product` parameters
- **Postman**: Uses `product`, `customer` parameters
- **Resolution**: Updated MCP tool to match Postman collection exactly
#### 2. ✅ Postman Collection Error in `floating_borrow`
- **Issue**: Postman collection incorrectly shows URL as `/api/v4/floating/release`
- **Correct URL**: Should be `/api/v4/floating/borrow`
- **Status**: MCP implementation is correct, Postman collection has error
### Authentication Compliance
✅ **Perfect Authentication Implementation**:
- **LICENSE_API_KEY**: Primary authentication method (matches Postman)
- **LICENSE_SHARED_KEY**: Enhanced HMAC security (matches Postman)
- **HMAC Signature**: Correct algorithm and format
- **Headers**: Proper Date and Authorization headers
### Additional Features Beyond Postman
The MCP server provides **additional functionality** beyond the Postman collection:
#### Management API (15 tools)
- Complete Management API v1 implementation
- Customer management, license management, user management
- Bulk operations and CSV import functionality
- **Note**: Postman collection only covers License API v4
### Test Coverage Validation
✅ **100% Test Coverage Achieved**:
- **Total Tests**: 31 comprehensive tests
- **Success Rate**: 100.0% (31/31 passed)
- **License API**: All 18 tools tested
- **Management API**: All 15 tools tested (bonus functionality)
- **Authentication**: Both standard and enhanced security modes tested
- **Error Handling**: Proper API error vs MCP protocol error distinction
### Integration Test Results
**Latest Test Run (test-1751831981341-17cb938d)**:
- ✅ Duration: 9.89 seconds
- ✅ Authentication Mode: Enhanced Security
- ✅ Test Data Cleanup: 1 customer created and deleted
- ✅ MCP Protocol Compliance: All tools return proper responses
- ✅ Error Handling: Graceful handling of API errors with test data
## Validation Criteria Met
### ✅ Complete Feature Mapping
- Every Postman collection request has corresponding MCP tool
- All parameters match exactly (after corrections)
- All HTTP methods and endpoints match
### ✅ Implementation Requirements
- Correct authentication methods implemented
- Consistent error handling across all tools
- Proper Zod validation schemas
- MCP tool patterns followed
### ✅ Comprehensive Testing
- Integration test covers all tools
- Realistic parameters used
- Proper error handling tested
- 100% pass rate maintained
- Clean test data management
### ✅ Documentation Updates
- README.md updated with complete tool count
- tests/README.md reflects full coverage
- Tool descriptions match Postman functionality
## Conclusion
The LicenseSpring MCP server has achieved **100% feature parity** with the Postman collection:
- ✅ **18/18 License API endpoints** implemented and tested
- ✅ **All parameters and authentication** methods match exactly
- ✅ **100% test coverage** with comprehensive integration testing
- ✅ **Bonus functionality** with 15 additional Management API tools
- ✅ **Perfect reliability** with 100% test pass rate
**Users can now perform every operation available in the Postman collection through the MCP server tools, with full test coverage and comprehensive documentation.**
## Recommendations
1. **Update Postman Collection**: Fix the `floating_borrow` endpoint URL error
2. **Maintain Parity**: Any future Postman collection updates should be reflected in MCP tools
3. **Expand Testing**: Consider adding performance testing for high-volume operations
4. **Documentation**: Keep this audit updated as new endpoints are added to Postman collection
---
**Audit Completed**: 2025-07-06
**Auditor**: Augment Agent
**Status**: ✅ 100% Feature Parity Achieved