architectural-analysis-recommendations-2025-07-21.mdā¢1.93 kB
Recommended Architectural Refactoring
1. Unified Tool Architecture
// Base tool class with common patterns
export abstract class BaseToolV110 {
protected processingStartTime: number;
protected validationErrors: string[];
constructor(protected config: ToolConfig) {
this.processingStartTime = 0;
this.validationErrors = [];
}
abstract async execute(input: any): Promise<ToolResult>;
protected validateInput(input: any): ValidationResult {
// Common validation logic
}
protected createErrorResponse(error: Error): ErrorResponse {
// Consistent error formatting
}
}
// Specific tool implementation
export class SmartGuidanceToolV110 extends BaseToolV110 {
async execute(input: GuidanceInput): Promise<GuidanceResult> {
// Tool-specific logic only
}
}
2. Configuration Unification
// Single configuration system
export interface SystemConfig {
api: APIConfig;
authentication: AuthConfig;
browser: BrowserConfig;
tools: ToolsConfig;
}
export class ConfigurationManager {
static load(): SystemConfig {
// Unified configuration loading
}
static validate(config: SystemConfig): ValidationResult {
// Comprehensive validation
}
}
3. Dependency Injection Container
// DI container for all dependencies
export class DIContainer {
register<T>(token: string, factory: () => T): void;
resolve<T>(token: string): T;
}
// Tool factory with DI
export class ToolFactory {
constructor(private container: DIContainer) {}
createTool<T extends BaseTool>(toolType: ToolType): T {
return this.container.resolve(toolType);
}
}
This comprehensive analysis reveals that the architectural issues are more severe than initially apparent. The system has significant architectural debt that impacts maintainability, testability, and extensibility. The v1.1.0 tools, while functional, represent an architectural anti-pattern that needs significant refactoring.