COMPREHENSIVE_TESTING_REPORT_CORRECTED.md•7.12 kB
# EuConquisto Composer MCP Server - Comprehensive Testing Report
**Date**: June 10, 2025
**Version**: 0.1.6
**Testing Session**: End-to-End Validation
**Status**: ⚠️ **INCOMPLETE - BROWSER AUTOMATION ISSUES IDENTIFIED**
## 📋 Executive Summary
Comprehensive testing of the EuConquisto Composer MCP Server v0.1.6 revealed a **partially functional system**. While the MCP protocol foundation is solid and authentication is working correctly, **critical browser automation issues prevent the core composition creation functionality** from working.
**Overall Status**: **NOT PRODUCTION READY** - Browser automation development required.
## ✅ PASSING TESTS
### MCP Protocol Compliance
- **JSON-RPC 2.0 Implementation**: ✅ PASS
- **Tool Discovery**: ✅ PASS (7 tools registered)
- **Error Handling**: ✅ PASS (Proper error codes: -32602, etc.)
- **Response Format**: ✅ PASS (Valid content structure)
- **Performance**: ✅ PASS (<100ms for non-browser tools)
### Authentication & Access
- **JWT Token Validation**: ✅ PASS (No encoding issues found)
- **EuConquisto Composer Access**: ✅ PASS (Authentication successful)
- **URL Generation**: ✅ PASS (Valid authenticated URLs)
- **Admin-level Access**: ✅ PASS (Proper permissions confirmed)
### Basic Tool Functionality
- **test-connection**: ✅ PASS (Enhanced status reporting)
- **get-widget-info**: ✅ PASS (6 widgets with detailed analysis)
- **get-composer-url**: ✅ PASS (JWT authentication URLs)
### Integration
- **Claude Desktop Connection**: ✅ PASS (Tools discoverable)
- **TypeScript Compilation**: ✅ PASS (Zero errors)
- **Module System**: ✅ PASS (ES2020 configuration)
## ❌ FAILING TESTS
### Browser Automation (Critical Blocker)
- **create-new-composition**: ❌ FAIL (Cannot locate "Nova composição" button)
- **edit-composition-metadata**: ❌ FAIL (Cannot find hamburger menu)
- **save-composition**: ❌ FAIL (Cannot locate save button)
- **complete-composition-workflow**: ❌ FAIL (Fails at composition creation step)
### Error Details
```
Error: page.waitForSelector: Timeout 30000ms exceeded.
Call log:
- waiting for locator('body') to be visible
59 × locator resolved to hidden <body>…</body>
```
**Root Cause**: DOM selector/timing issues preventing Playwright from locating UI elements.
## 🔍 Detailed Test Results
### Test 1: MCP Server Initialization
```bash
Status: ✅ PASS
Response Time: <2s
Tools Available: 7/7
Protocol Version: 2024-11-05
Capabilities: {"tools":{"listChanged":true}}
```
### Test 2: Tool Discovery
```bash
Status: ✅ PASS
Method: tools/list
Tools Returned: 7
Schema Validation: ✅ Valid
Input Schemas: ✅ Complete
```
### Test 3: Basic Tool Validation
```bash
test-connection: ✅ PASS (Enhanced response with capabilities)
get-widget-info: ✅ PASS (Header widget analysis: 44 properties, 6 subtypes)
get-composer-url: ✅ PASS (Valid JWT URL generated)
```
### Test 4: Authentication Verification
```bash
Method: Manual browser navigation
URL: https://composer.euconquisto.com/#/embed/auth-with-token/...
Result: ✅ PASS (Page loads: "RDP Composer" title)
JWT Token: ✅ VALID (No encoding corruption)
Access Level: ✅ ADMIN (Full permissions confirmed)
```
### Test 5: Browser Automation (CRITICAL FAILURE)
```bash
create-new-composition: ❌ FAIL (Timeout: 30000ms)
Error: Cannot locate DOM elements for composition UI
Browser State: Authenticated and loaded, but selectors failing
Playwright Version: 1.52.0 (Installed correctly)
```
## 📊 Success Metrics
| Category | Target | Achieved | Status |
|----------|---------|----------|---------|
| MCP Tools Working | 7/7 (100%) | 3/7 (43%) | ❌ FAIL |
| Response Time | <100ms | <50ms | ✅ PASS |
| Authentication | Working | Working | ✅ PASS |
| Error Handling | Graceful | Graceful | ✅ PASS |
| Core Functionality | Working | Blocked | ❌ FAIL |
## 🚧 Identified Issues
### Critical Issues (Blocking Production)
1. **Browser Automation Failure**
- Impact: Core functionality non-operational
- Cause: DOM selector/timing problems
- Priority: P0 (Critical)
### Technical Debt
1. **Selector Strategy**
- Current: Single selector approach
- Needed: Multiple fallback selectors
- Priority: P1 (High)
2. **Error Reporting**
- Current: Generic timeout messages
- Needed: Specific DOM debugging info
- Priority: P2 (Medium)
## 🎯 Resolution Requirements
### For Production Ready Status
1. **Fix Browser Automation**
- Debug DOM selectors for composition UI elements
- Implement proper wait conditions
- Add retry mechanisms
- Test across different browser modes
2. **Validate End-to-End Workflow**
- Successfully create "Composição Teste MCP"
- Verify metadata editing functionality
- Confirm composition saving process
- Test complete workflow integration
3. **Comprehensive Testing**
- Achieve 7/7 tool functionality
- Validate error handling edge cases
- Performance testing under load
- Cross-platform compatibility verification
### Immediate Next Steps
1. **DOM Inspection**: Analyze EuConquisto Composer interface for correct selectors
2. **Selector Updates**: Update composition-lifecycle.ts with working selectors
3. **Timing Optimization**: Implement proper wait strategies
4. **Testing Validation**: Re-run complete test suite
## 🏆 Achievements Recognized
### Significant Progress
- ✅ Complete MCP protocol implementation
- ✅ JWT authentication resolution (no encoding issues)
- ✅ Claude Desktop integration successful
- ✅ Solid architectural foundation (1,101+ lines of code)
- ✅ Comprehensive error handling framework
### Development Quality
- ✅ Zero compilation errors
- ✅ Type-safe implementation
- ✅ Proper documentation and testing approach
- ✅ Professional development standards
## 📝 Corrected Documentation
**Previous Incorrect Claims Removed:**
- ❌ "Production Ready" status
- ❌ "Demonstration Ready" claims
- ❌ "100% tool functionality" assertions
- ❌ "Ready for stakeholder presentation" statements
**Accurate Current State:**
- ⚠️ MCP Foundation: Complete and operational
- ⚠️ Browser Automation: Development required
- ⚠️ Production Readiness: Blocked pending automation fixes
## 🔄 Recommendations
### Short Term (1-2 days)
1. Focus on browser automation debugging
2. Fix DOM selectors and timing issues
3. Achieve working composition creation
### Medium Term (1 week)
1. Complete comprehensive testing validation
2. Performance optimization
3. Error handling enhancement
### Long Term (Ongoing)
1. Maintenance and monitoring setup
2. Feature expansion planning
3. Documentation maintenance
---
**Test Conclusion**: While significant progress has been made on the MCP foundation, **browser automation issues prevent production deployment**. The system requires completion of the composition creation functionality before it can be considered ready for stakeholder demonstration or production use.
**Recommendation**: **COMPLETE BROWSER AUTOMATION DEVELOPMENT** before proceeding with any production or demonstration activities.