Mnemex

# Requirements Checklist: Multi-Agent Memory Consolidation **Purpose**: Validate that the feature specification is complete, consistent, and ready for implementation planning **Created**: 2025-11-24 **Feature**: [spec.md](../spec.md) ## User Stories Completeness - [x] CHK001 All user stories follow "As a [role], I want [goal], so that [benefit]" format - [x] CHK002 Each user story has explicit priority (P1, P2, P3) - [x] CHK003 Priority justifications explain WHY that priority level - [x] CHK004 Each story has "Independent Test" describing how it can be validated alone - [x] CHK005 All acceptance scenarios follow Given/When/Then format - [x] CHK006 User stories cover the five agents: Decay Analyzer, Cluster Detector, Semantic Merge, LTM Promoter, Relationship Discovery ## Requirements Quality - [x] CHK007 All functional requirements use MUST/SHOULD/MAY language (RFC 2119) - [x] CHK008 Each requirement is independently testable - [x] CHK009 Requirements are technology-agnostic (no implementation details) - [x] CHK010 No conflicting requirements identified - [x] CHK011 Requirements cover beads coordination mechanism (FR-006, FR-007) - [x] CHK012 Requirements include dry-run/preview mode (FR-010) - [x] CHK013 Requirements include CLI interface (FR-012) - [x] CHK014 Requirements include rate limiting (FR-014) ## Success Criteria Measurability - [x] CHK015 Each success criterion has a specific metric (number, percentage, time) - [x] CHK016 Metrics are objectively measurable (not subjective opinions) - [x] CHK017 Success criteria cover all five agents - [x] CHK018 Performance SLA defined (SC-006: 5 seconds per memory) - [x] CHK019 Data integrity criterion exists (SC-008: zero data loss) ## Edge Cases Coverage - [x] CHK020 Multiple cluster membership handling defined - [x] CHK021 Merge conflict resolution defined - [x] CHK022 Queue overflow handling defined - [x] CHK023 Agent failure recovery defined - [x] CHK024 Concurrent execution handling defined ## Key Entities Definition - [x] CHK025 ConsolidationAgent base class defined - [x] CHK026 ConsolidationTask (beads issue type) defined - [x] CHK027 ClusterResult output format defined - [x] CHK028 MergeResult output format defined - [x] CHK029 PromotionResult output format defined ## Dependencies & Integration Points - [x] CHK030 Beads integration described (message queue + audit log) - [x] CHK031 Existing consolidation.py compatibility considered - [x] CHK032 Existing promote_memory tool compatibility considered - [x] CHK033 LTM vault integration described - [x] CHK034 Existing cluster_memories tool compatibility considered ## Specification Status | Criterion | Status | |-----------|--------| | User Stories Complete | ✅ 5 stories with scenarios | | Requirements Complete | ✅ 14 functional requirements | | Success Criteria | ✅ 8 measurable outcomes | | Edge Cases | ✅ 5 edge cases with resolutions | | Key Entities | ✅ 5 entities defined | **Overall Status**: ✅ Ready for `/speckit.plan` ## Notes - This specification builds on existing CortexGraph infrastructure: - `src/cortexgraph/core/consolidation.py` - existing merge logic - `src/cortexgraph/core/cluster.py` - existing similarity detection - `src/cortexgraph/core/review.py` - existing decay zone logic - `src/cortexgraph/tools/promote.py` - existing LTM promotion - Beads provides the coordination layer - no need to build custom message queue - Consider whether to use Claude Agent SDK for agent orchestration (optional enhancement)