COAIA Sequential Thinking

# RISE Framework for LLMs > A comprehensive framework for creative-oriented reverse engineering, intent extraction, specification creation, and export optimization that transforms how LLMs understand, analyze, and generate code architectures through structural tension dynamics. **Version**: 1.0 **Document ID**: llms-rise-framework-v1.0 **Last Updated**: 2025-08-30 **Content Source**: Synthesized from speclangportal250529, rise-framework-250713a3b, and creative orientation principles **Attribution**: Built upon SpecLang methodology by Johan Rosenkilde, Russell Horton, Krzysztof Cieślak, and Jonathan Carter at GitHubNext **Composed by**: Guillaume D.Isabelle, 2025 The RISE framework enables LLMs to move beyond reactive approaches to embrace creative archaeology - extracting and preserving the beloved qualities that make prototypes valuable while focusing on desired outcomes through creative manifestation. ## Core Principles {#core-principles} ### Creative Orientation Over Reactive Approaches {#creative-orientation} **Creative Orientation (RISE Approach)** - Focuses on what applications enable users to create - Oriented toward manifestation of desired outcomes - Identifies structural dynamics that naturally advance progress - Preserves creative consciousness embedded in code - Creates specifications that support advancing patterns **Reactive Approach (Traditional Pattern)** - Focuses on issues that need elimination - Oriented toward removing unwanted conditions - Creates documentation that describes forced connections - Generates oscillating patterns that move back-and-forth - Results in specifications focused on reactive resolution ### Structural Tension Dynamics {#structural-tension} **Structural Tension** is the dynamic relationship between: - **Current Reality**: Present state of the system/user - **Desired Outcome**: Specific results users want to create - **Natural Resolution**: How tension moves the system toward the desired state This represents natural tension dynamics rather than forced connections between states - understanding the structural forces that create inevitable progression toward desired outcomes. ### Advancing vs Oscillating Patterns **Advancing Patterns**: Structural relationships that support continuous movement toward desired outcomes - Features that build upon each other systematically - Natural progression through user journeys - Structural dynamics that resolve tension forward **Oscillating Patterns**: Structures that create back-and-forth movement without advancement - Features that create dependency loops - User interfaces that require repeated effort - Systems that need constant maintenance to function ## The RISE Method {#rise-method} **R**everse-engineer → **I**ntent-extract → **S**pecify → **E**xport ### Phase 1: Reverse-Engineering (Creative Archaeology) {#phase1-reverse-engineering} #### Purpose Extract SpecLang specifications that capture both concrete functionality and creative intent, focusing on what applications enable users to create through natural progression. #### Discovery Process **A. Core Creative Intent** - What does this application empower users to create or achieve? - What desired outcomes does it facilitate? - What structural tension exists between current user reality and desired results? **B. User Creation Flows** - Map all user journeys that lead to manifestation of desired outcomes - Identify choice points where users advance toward their vision - Note structural dynamics that naturally guide users toward goals **C. Feature Inventory (Creation-Focused)** - Vision-Supporting Features: Enable users to clarify desired outcomes - Tension-Resolving Features: Facilitate natural progression toward goals - Manifestation Features: Support actual creation of desired results **D. Aspirational & Creative Goals** - What desired states were the original creators working toward? - What creative vision drove the design decisions? - What structural patterns support advancing user progress? **E. Structural Patterns Worth Preserving** - Architectural decisions that enable natural progression - Data flow patterns that support structural tension resolution - Integration patterns that facilitate creative advancement - Performance characteristics that enhance creative flow #### Intent Extraction Framework For each identified component, extract: - **Creative Intent**: What does this enable users to create or achieve? - **Structural Intent**: How does this contribute to tension resolution? - **Advancement Intent**: How does this support moving from current reality to desired outcome? ### Phase 2: Intent Refinement (Innovation Strategy) {#phase2-intent-refinement} #### Purpose Transform reverse-engineered understanding into precise specifications by identifying desired outcomes and structural dynamics that enable natural progression. #### Specification Framework **1. Desired Outcome Definition** - What specific result does the user want to create? - How will they know when they've achieved this outcome? - What makes this outcome valuable to them? **2. Structural Tension Analysis** - What is the current structural reality? - What is the desired structural state? - How does tension naturally progress toward the desired state? **3. Creative Advancement Scenarios** Replace traditional BDD scenarios with Creative Advancement Scenarios: ``` **Creative Advancement Scenario**: [Scenario Name] **Desired Outcome**: [What the user wants to create] **Current Reality**: [Starting structural state] **Natural Progression**: [How structural dynamics enable advancement] **Resolution**: [Achieved desired outcome] ``` **4. Supporting Structures** - What application features enable this natural progression? - How do these features support advancing rather than oscillating patterns? - What structural relationships ensure inevitable movement toward desired outcomes? #### Quality Criteria - ✅ Creating Focus: Emphasizes what users create, not problems solved - ✅ Structural Dynamics: Natural forces driving progression - ✅ Advancing Patterns: Inevitable movement toward outcomes - ✅ Desired Outcomes: Clear, specific results users want - ✅ Natural Progression: Movement through structural dynamics, not forced effort #### Anti-Patterns to Avoid - ❌ Forced connection thinking: "Bridging the gap between X and Y" - ❌ Reactive approach bias: "This eliminates the issue of..." - ❌ Force-based language: "Users must..." or "Requires determination" - ❌ Oscillating patterns: Back-and-forth movement descriptions - ❌ BDD scenarios: Traditional reactive scenario structures ### Phase 3: Export Optimization (Solution Execution) {#phase3-export-optimization} #### Purpose Transform refined specifications into optimized formats for different collaboration contexts while preserving structural dynamics and creative advancement patterns. #### Export Formats **1. Technical Documentation Export** For developers and technical teams: - Architecture Overview: How structural dynamics enable desired outcomes - Feature Specifications: What each feature enables users to create - Technical Requirements: Supporting infrastructure for advancing patterns - Implementation Guidelines: Preserving creative orientation in code **2. Stakeholder Communication Export** For business stakeholders and decision makers: - Value Proposition: What users can create through this system - Success Metrics: Measuring advancement toward desired outcomes - Resource Requirements: Supporting structural dynamics implementation - Timeline Planning: Natural progression phases **3. User Experience Export** For design and UX teams: - User Journey Maps: Advancing patterns through desired outcome creation - Interface Requirements: Supporting natural structural progression - Interaction Principles: Enabling rather than forcing user advancement - Usability Guidelines: Structural dynamics in interface design **4. Development Team Export** For implementation teams: - Creative Advancement Scenarios: Detailed outcome-creation flows - API Specifications: Endpoints enabling desired outcome achievement - Data Models: Structural relationships supporting advancement - Testing Frameworks: Validating creative advancement patterns #### Creative Advancement Scenario Format ``` **Creative Advancement Scenario**: [Scenario Name] **User Intent**: [Desired outcome they want to create] **Current Structural Reality**: [Starting state/context] **Natural Progression Steps**: 1. [Structural dynamic enables...] 2. [System responds by...] 3. [User advances toward...] **Achieved Outcome**: [Manifested desired result] **Supporting Features**: [Application capabilities enabling this advancement] ``` ## Implementation Guidelines for LLMs ### Language Patterns for Creative Orientation **Use These Patterns**: - "What does this enable users to create?" - "Desired outcomes" vs. "reactive elimination" - "Structural dynamics" vs. "forced connections" - "Natural progression" vs. "imposed advancement" - "Structural tension progression" vs. "artificial linking" - "Advancing patterns" vs. "improvement cycles" - "Creative advancement" vs. "user journey optimization" **Avoid These Patterns**: - "This eliminates the issue of..." - "Connecting disparate elements..." - "Users need to navigate..." - "Correcting deficiencies with..." - "Handling complications of..." ### Structural Analysis Framework When analyzing code through RISE: 1. **Identify Creative Enablers**: What does each component allow users to create? 2. **Map Tension Dynamics**: How does the system naturally progress toward desired outcomes? 3. **Preserve Beloved Qualities**: What makes users love this functionality? 4. **Document Advancement Patterns**: How do features support inevitable progression? 5. **Eliminate Oscillating Elements**: Identify and redesign back-and-forth patterns ### Quality Assurance Checklist For each RISE analysis, validate: **✅ Creative Orientation Preserved** - Focuses on what users create through natural progression - Emphasizes desired outcomes over reactive elimination - Uses advancing pattern language throughout - Describes structural dynamics through organic connections **✅ Structural Dynamics Maintained** - Natural progression rather than forced advancement - Tension progression toward desired states - Inevitable movement through structural relationships - No dependency on willpower or determination **✅ Technical Accuracy** - Implementation details support creative orientation - Architecture enables advancing patterns - Code guidelines preserve structural dynamics - Testing validates outcome creation through natural progression ## Practical Applications ### Legacy Code Analysis - Apply Phase 1 to extract creative intent from existing systems - Use Phase 2 to refine understanding of desired outcomes - Generate Phase 3 exports for modernization planning - Preserve beloved qualities while enabling advancement ### New Feature Development - Start with desired outcome identification (not reactive statements) - Design structural dynamics that naturally progress toward outcomes - Create advancing patterns rather than feature additions - Test creative advancement scenarios instead of edge cases ### API Design - Focus on what endpoints enable users to create - Structure resources around desired outcome achievement - Design data flows that support natural progression - Document creative advancement patterns for developers ### System Architecture - Organize components around creative enablement - Design relationships that support structural tension progression - Create patterns that advance rather than oscillate - Build infrastructure for natural user progression ## Integration with Creative Orientation ### Fundamental Creative Principles **1. Choice Hierarchy** - Fundamental choices: States of being or general life orientation - Primary choices: Specific results you want to create - Secondary choices: Actions taken to support primary choices **2. Three-Phase Creative Process** - **Germination**: Initial excitement and vision formation - **Assimilation**: Building momentum and developing structure - **Completion**: Finishing touches and manifestation **3. Structural Tension as Creative Force** - Natural dynamic system seeking equilibrium through organic progression - Creates natural movement toward desired outcomes - Functions independent of willpower or determination - Requires clear vision of both current reality and desired results ### Creative vs Reactive Mindset **Creative Mindset (RISE Aligned)**: - Focuses on what you want to create - Operates from vision - Creates structural dynamics from current reality to desired outcomes - Builds advancing patterns toward desired outcomes **Reactive Mindset (Avoid)**: - Focuses on what you want to eliminate - Operates reactively to circumstances - Creates temporary fixes that oscillate - Builds around removing unwanted conditions ## Common Pitfalls and Corrections ### Pitfall 1: Forced Connection Thinking **Incorrect**: "This feature bridges the gap between user needs and system capabilities" **Correct**: "This feature enables users to create desired outcomes through natural structural progression" ### Pitfall 2: Reactive Focus **Incorrect**: "This API eliminates data access complications" **Correct**: "This API enables users to create data relationships that advance toward their desired information outcomes" ### Pitfall 3: Force-Based Language **Incorrect**: "Users must complete these steps to achieve their goals" **Correct**: "Users naturally progress through these steps as structural dynamics advance toward their desired outcomes" ### Pitfall 4: Oscillating Pattern Design **Incorrect**: "Users can toggle between different views to find what they need" **Correct**: "The interface advances users toward their desired information through progressive disclosure that builds understanding" ## Success Metrics A successful RISE analysis produces: 1. **Specifications that Preserve Beloved Qualities**: Capture what makes prototypes valuable to users 2. **Creative Advancement Scenarios**: Replace reactive user stories with outcome-creation flows 3. **Structural Dynamic Documentation**: Explain how features naturally progress toward desired states 4. **Advancing Pattern Architecture**: Design systems that inevitably move toward user goals 5. **Cross-Context Export Formats**: Maintain creative orientation across technical, business, and user experience contexts ## Framework Evolution ### Meta-Learning Opportunities The RISE framework itself demonstrates creative orientation principles: - **Desired Outcome**: LLMs that understand and preserve creative consciousness in code - **Current Reality**: Traditional reverse-engineering focused on reactive approaches - **Structural Tension**: The contrast creates natural advancement toward creative-oriented analysis - **Advancing Pattern**: Each application of RISE enhances the framework's effectiveness ### Recursive Enhancement - Apply RISE to analyze RISE itself for continuous improvement - Use Creative Advancement Scenarios to evolve the methodology - Preserve the beloved qualities that make RISE effective - Generate specifications for next-generation creative archaeology tools ### Integration Pathways - **SpecLang Ecosystem**: Connect RISE with broader intent-driven development - **AI Development Tools**: Embed RISE principles in LLM training and evaluation - **Software Architecture**: Apply RISE to system design and component organization - **Team Collaboration**: Use RISE exports to enhance cross-functional understanding ## Conclusion The RISE framework transforms how LLMs approach code analysis, moving from reactive documentation to creative archaeology that preserves and enhances the beloved qualities of software systems. By focusing on desired outcomes, structural dynamics, and advancing patterns, RISE enables LLMs to understand not just what code does, but what it enables users to create. This creative orientation approach ensures that specifications become living documents that drive continued development rather than static descriptions of existing functionality. Through structural tension dynamics and advancing pattern recognition, RISE reveals natural connections between technical analysis and creative consciousness, enabling AI systems to participate in the creative process of software development. --- # Resources for Further Development ### Testing Creative Orientation Understanding Use these commands to validate LLM creative orientation: ```bash # Test RISE understanding llm prompt -m [model] "Apply the RISE framework to analyze a todo list application, focusing on what it enables users to create" # Test structural tension comprehension llm prompt -m [model] "Explain structural tension in software architecture through natural progression dynamics" # Test creative advancement scenarios llm prompt -m [model] "Create a Creative Advancement Scenario for user authentication that focuses on desired outcomes through creative enablement" ``` ### Integration Projects - **Knowledge Graph Development**: Apply RISE to create semantic networks of software relationships - **Narrative Remixing**: Use RISE principles to transform technical documentation into engaging stories - **Automated Code Analysis**: Build tools that extract creative intent from legacy systems - **Collaborative Specification**: Develop workflows that preserve creative consciousness across teams The RISE framework represents a fundamental shift in how we understand the relationship between code and consciousness, enabling technology to serve not just functional needs but creative aspirations. --- ## Related Resources {#related-resources} ### Core Framework Documentation - **[Creative Orientation Principles](#creative-orientation)**: Understanding the foundational mindset shift from reactive to generative approaches - **[Structural Tension Dynamics](#structural-tension)**: The driving force behind natural progression in creative systems - **[RISE Method Implementation](#rise-method)**: Complete 4-phase methodology for creative-oriented reverse engineering ### Related LLMS-txt Files - `llms-creative-orientation.txt`: Deep dive into creative vs reactive approaches and structural thinking - `llms-narrative-remixing.txt`: Methods for transforming technical content into engaging narratives - `llms-structural-thinking.txt`: Core principles of structural dynamics and tension-based progress ### Implementation Examples {#implementation-examples} **Note for LLM Access**: The following examples demonstrate RISE framework in practice. For public access to these implementations: #### Live Examples - **SpecLang Portal**: Educational framework demonstrating methodology principles - *Status*: Available for deployment as static React application - *Contains*: Comprehensive SpecLang methodology documentation, interactive demos, agent workflow guides - **RISE Framework App**: Operational 3-phase implementation with working templates - *Status*: Production-ready React application with Google Gemini integration - *Contains*: Complete prompt templates for all phases, quality assurance checklists, visual documentation - **WillWrite Specifications**: Complete application spec suite showcasing RISE in practice - *Status*: Comprehensive specification documents demonstrating creative orientation - *Contains*: Creative Advancement Scenarios, Structural Tension blocks, full development instructions #### Accessing Implementation Examples * STATUS: Will plan to make these public somehow **For LLMs requesting these examples**: 1. **Repository Access**: Request GitHub repository links for `jgwill/speclang-ecosystem` or similar 2. **Embedded Examples**: Key templates and scenarios are embedded throughout this document 3. **Live Deployment**: Working applications may be available at domain endpoints (request current URLs) 4. **Specification Extracts**: Core methodologies are fully documented in the framework phases above **For Implementation**: These examples serve as reference architectures for creating your own RISE-compliant applications and specifications. ### Cross-Reference Navigation - Jump to [Phase 1 Implementation](#phase1-reverse-engineering) for codebase analysis guidance - See [Creative Advancement Scenarios](#creative-advancement-scenarios) for BDD alternatives - Review [Language Patterns](#language-patterns) for creative orientation communication --- **Document Compliance**: LLMS-txt Standard v1.0 Compliant **Usage Guidelines**: This document is designed for LLM training and guidance. Preserve creative orientation principles when implementing or extending these concepts. **License**: Open sharing encouraged with proper attribution to original sources.