AI Agent MCP Server

# US-040-047 Feedback Application - Final Completion Summary **Date:** 2025-10-20 **Status:** ✅ 8/8 Complete (100%) --- ## Summary All 8 backlog stories (US-040 through US-047) have been successfully updated to v2/v3 based on feedback from `/feedback/US-040-047_v2_comments.md`. **Total Stories Updated:** 8 **Global Changes Applied:** 3 patterns **Story-Specific Changes:** 5 tools updated **Completion Time:** ~2 hours --- ## Files Created/Updated ### ✅ Completed (8/8) 1. **US-040 v3** - `/artifacts/backlog_stories/US-040_implement_validate_artifact_tool_v3.md` - Removed `checklist_id` parameter - Added `artifact_id` parameter with inference - Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` - Added ArtifactTypeInference class with TYPE_PREFIX_MAP - Updated 8 acceptance criteria scenarios - Added Decision 3 (checklist inference) and Decision 4 (task_id) 2. **US-044 v2** - `/artifacts/backlog_stories/US-044_implement_add_task_tool_v2.md` - Removed `generator` and `artifact_type` from TaskMetadata - Added Pydantic validators for inference - Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` - Updated 8 acceptance criteria scenarios - Added Decision 1 (artifact_type), Decision 2 (generator), Decision 3 (task_id) 3. **US-043 v3** - `/artifacts/backlog_stories/US-043_implement_store_artifact_tool_v3.md` - Global replace: `PATTERNS_BASE_DIR` → `ARTIFACTS_BASE_DIR` - Documented PATTERNS_BASE_DIR as separate config for templates - Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` - Updated all acceptance criteria paths - Added Decision 5 (ARTIFACTS_BASE_DIR separation) and Decision 6 (task_id) 4. **US-042 v3** - `/artifacts/backlog_stories/US-042_implement_resolve_artifact_path_tool_v3.md` - Removed `artifact_type` input parameter - Added artifact type inference from artifact_id - Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` - Updated 7 acceptance criteria scenarios - Added Decision 1 (artifact_type removal) and Decision 2 (task_id) 5. **US-041 v3** - `/artifacts/backlog_stories/US-041_migrate_validation_checklists_json_resources_v3.md` - Updated status to v3 - Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` in documentation examples - Added Decision 1 (task_id terminology) - Added feedback v2 references 6. **US-046 v2** - `/artifacts/backlog_stories/US-046_tool_invocation_logging_v2.md` - Global replace: `request_id` → `task_id` throughout document - Updated decorator signature and log entry examples - Updated query examples (jq filters for task_id) - Added comprehensive Decision 1 explaining rename 7. **US-045 v2** - `/artifacts/backlog_stories/US-045_add_sub_artifact_evaluation_generator_instructions_v2.md` - Removed `generator` attribute from all XML task examples - Removed `artifact_type` attribute from metadata format - Updated all generator instruction examples - Added Decision 1 (artifact_type inference) and Decision 2 (generator inference) 8. **US-047 v2** - `/artifacts/backlog_stories/US-047_integration_testing_all_tools_v2.md` - Global replace: `request_id` → `task_id` - Updated `ValidateArtifactInput` examples: `checklist_id` → `artifact_id` - Updated `ResolveArtifactPathInput` examples: removed `artifact_type` - Updated `TaskMetadata` examples: removed `artifact_type` and `generator` - Added 3 decisions in Decisions Made section - Updated Related Documents with feedback v2 references --- ## Global Change Patterns Applied ### Pattern 1: Artifact ID Inference **Applied to:** US-040, US-042, US-044 **Implementation:** ```python TYPE_PREFIX_MAP = { "EPIC": "epic", "PRD": "prd", "HLS": "hls", "US": "backlog_story", "SPEC": "tech_spec", "ADR": "adr", "SPIKE": "spike", "TASK": "task", "VIS": "product_vision", "INIT": "initiative" } @validator('artifact_type', pre=True, always=True) def infer_artifact_type(cls, v, values): if v is None and 'artifact_id' in values: prefix = values['artifact_id'].split('-')[0] return TYPE_PREFIX_MAP[prefix] return v ``` **Benefits:** - Simpler client interface (fewer parameters) - Eliminates mismatched artifact_id/type errors - Consistent across all tools **Example:** ```python # OLD v2 ValidateArtifactInput( artifact_content=text, checklist_id="epic_validation_v1" ) # NEW v3 ValidateArtifactInput( artifact_content=text, artifact_id="EPIC-006", # Infers checklist_id automatically task_id="task-123" # Mandatory ) ``` --- ### Pattern 2: Configuration Separation **Applied to:** US-043 **Implementation:** ```python class Settings(BaseSettings): PATTERNS_BASE_DIR: str = "/opt/mcp/patterns" # Templates (read-only) ARTIFACTS_BASE_DIR: str = "/workspace/artifacts" # Generated (read-write) VALIDATION_RESOURCES_DIR: str = "/opt/mcp/validation" ``` **Benefits:** - Flexible deployment (separate template and artifact storage) - Security hardening (patterns can be read-only) - Clear separation of concerns **Example:** ```python # OLD v2: {PATTERNS_BASE_DIR}/epic/EPIC-006_v1.md # NEW v3: {ARTIFACTS_BASE_DIR}/epic/EPIC-006_v1.md ``` --- ### Pattern 3: Task ID Tracking **Applied to:** All 8 stories **Implementation:** ```python # Mandatory parameter in all tool inputs class ToolInput(BaseModel): # ... other fields task_id: str = Field(..., description="Task tracking ID for log correlation") # Logged in all tool invocations logger.info( "tool_invocation_completed", task_id=params.task_id, # First field for easy correlation # ... other fields ) ``` **Benefits:** - Better log traceability - Correlation across tool calls in same workflow - Aligns with task tracking system terminology **Example:** ```python # OLD v2: request_id="req-123" # NEW v3: task_id="task-123" ``` --- ## Story-Specific Changes ### US-040: validate_artifact Tool **Changes:** 1. ✅ Removed `checklist_id` parameter → Add `artifact_id` parameter 2. ✅ Added ArtifactTypeInference class with TYPE_PREFIX_MAP 3. ✅ Inference: `EPIC-006` → `epic` → `epic_validation_v1` 4. ✅ Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` (mandatory) **Impact:** Simpler interface, automatic checklist selection --- ### US-044: add_task Tool **Changes:** 1. ✅ Removed `generator` parameter from TaskMetadata 2. ✅ Removed `artifact_type` parameter from TaskMetadata 3. ✅ Added inference validators for both fields 4. ✅ Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` (mandatory) **Impact:** Cleaner metadata format, inference from artifact_id **Example:** ```python # OLD v1 TaskMetadata( artifact_id="HLS-006", artifact_type="hls", # REMOVED generator="hls-generator", # REMOVED parent_id="PRD-006" ) # NEW v2 TaskMetadata( artifact_id="HLS-006", # Type and generator inferred automatically parent_id="PRD-006" ) ``` --- ### US-043: store_artifact Tool **Changes:** 1. ✅ Changed `PATTERNS_BASE_DIR` → `ARTIFACTS_BASE_DIR` (global replace) 2. ✅ Documented PATTERNS_BASE_DIR as separate config for templates 3. ✅ Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` (mandatory) **Impact:** Clear separation between templates and generated artifacts --- ### US-042: resolve_artifact_path Tool **Changes:** 1. ✅ Removed `artifact_type` input parameter 2. ✅ Added artifact type inference from artifact_id prefix 3. ✅ Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` (mandatory) **Impact:** Simpler interface, inference from artifact_id **Example:** ```python # OLD v2 ResolveArtifactPathInput( artifact_type="epic", # REMOVED artifact_id="006", # Changed to full ID version=1, request_id="req-123" # Renamed ) # NEW v3 ResolveArtifactPathInput( artifact_id="EPIC-006", # Full ID, type inferred version=1, task_id="task-123" # Mandatory ) ``` --- ### US-041: Migrate Validation Checklists **Changes:** 1. ✅ Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` in documentation examples 2. ✅ Updated logging examples 3. ✅ Minimal changes (documentation-only story) **Impact:** Terminology consistency across documentation --- ### US-046: Tool Invocation Logging **Changes:** 1. ✅ Global find/replace: `request_id` → `task_id` 2. ✅ Updated decorator signature 3. ✅ Updated all log entry examples 4. ✅ Updated query examples (jq filters for task_id) **Impact:** Consistent terminology in logging and querying --- ### US-045: Sub-artifact Evaluation in Generators **Changes:** 1. ✅ Removed `generator` attribute from XML task examples 2. ✅ Removed `artifact_type` attribute from metadata format 3. ✅ Updated all generator instruction examples 4. ✅ Renamed `request_id` → `task_id` in documentation **Impact:** Simpler generator metadata format **Example:** ```xml <!-- OLD --> <task artifact_id="HLS-006" artifact_type="hls" generator="hls-generator" parent_id="PRD-006" /> <!-- NEW --> <task artifact_id="HLS-006" parent_id="PRD-006" /> ``` --- ### US-047: Integration Testing **Changes:** 1. ✅ Global replace: `request_id` → `task_id` 2. ✅ Updated test examples for US-040 (artifact_id inference) 3. ✅ Updated test examples for US-042 (remove artifact_type) 4. ✅ Updated test examples for US-044 (remove artifact_type/generator) 5. ✅ Added 3 decisions in Decisions Made section **Impact:** Test examples demonstrate new tool interfaces --- ## Verification Checklist - [x] All 8 stories use `task_id` consistently - [x] All inference logic documented with TYPE_PREFIX_MAP - [x] All Decisions Made sections updated - [x] All acceptance criteria cover new scenarios - [x] All related stories cross-referenced - [x] All feedback v2 references added to Related Documents - [x] All code examples updated with new interfaces - [x] All XML examples updated with simplified metadata --- ## Next Steps ### 1. Communication - Update development team on tool interface changes - Document migration guide for existing code - Update generator prompts (US-045 changes) - Update CLAUDE.md if needed ### 2. Implementation - Begin implementing US-040 v3 (validate_artifact with inference) - Begin implementing US-044 v2 (add_task with inference) - Begin implementing US-043 v3 (store_artifact with ARTIFACTS_BASE_DIR) - Begin implementing US-042 v3 (resolve_artifact_path with inference) ### 3. Testing - Implement US-047 v2 (integration tests for all tools) - Verify inference logic works correctly - Verify task_id propagation through tool chain - Verify ARTIFACTS_BASE_DIR separation works correctly --- ## Related Documents - **Original Feedback:** `/feedback/US-040-047_v2_comments.md` - **Change Tracking:** `/feedback/US-040-047_v2_changes_applied.md` - **Completion Summary:** `/feedback/US-040-047_completion_summary.md` (mid-process) - **Final Summary:** This document --- **Completion Status:** ✅ ALL 8 STORIES COMPLETE **Generated By:** Claude Code **Date:** 2025-10-20 **Session:** Context restored and continued