Tally MCP

<!-- Generated by SpecStory --> # Continue with task 31 (2025-06-15 13:23:39) _**User**_ Please continue with task 31 --- _**Assistant**_ --- I'll check what task 31 is and its current status to continue working on it. --- --- I can see task 31 is about fixing model interface type mismatches in test suites. Let me check the current status of task 23 first to make sure its dependencies are satisfied, and then start working on this task. --- --- Great! I can see that task 23 is done and task 31 has no dependencies blocked. Task 31 is about fixing model interface type mismatches in test suites. Based on the description, this relates to issues with ShareLinkType enum, FormPublicationSettings, EmbedCodeSettings, and TeamMember/TeamResponse interfaces that were identified during the comprehensive unit testing work. Let me set task 31 to "in-progress" and start by analyzing the current state of the codebase to understand the specific type mismatches: --- --- Now let me start by running the current tests to see what type mismatches exist: --- ```bash npm test -- --testPathPattern="FormSharingTool|TeamManager" --verbose ``` ``` ╰─ ^[[200~npm test -- --testPathPattern="FormSharingTool|TeamManager" --verbose^[[201~ ╭─    ~/dev/projects/tally-mcp    develop ·········································· ✔  13:24:25   ╰─ npm test - ``` --- Let me try running the tests more specifically: --- ```bash npm test -- --testPathPattern="form-sharing-tool|team-manager" --verbose ``` ``` ❯ npm test -- --testPathPattern="form-sharing-tool|team-manager" --verbose > tally-mcp@1.0.0 test > jest --testPathPattern=form-sharing-tool|team-manager --verbose RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts FAIL src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts FormSharingTool RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts constructor RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should create an instance with FormPublicationService (5 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts publishForm RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should publish form successfully with minimal input (2 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should publish form with all optional parameters (2 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle publication errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle unknown errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should filter out undefined optional parameters (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts unpublishForm RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should unpublish form successfully (2 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle unpublish errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getPublicationSettings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should get publication settings successfully (4 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle get settings errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts updatePublicationSettings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should update publication settings successfully (2 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should filter out undefined values from settings (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle update settings errors (2 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts generateEmbedCode RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should generate embed code successfully with minimal input (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should generate embed code with all options (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle embed code generation errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts generateShareLink RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✕ should generate share link successfully (3 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should generate share link with security options (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle share link generation errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getShareLinks RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should get share links successfully (3 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle get share links errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts deactivateShareLink RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should deactivate share link successfully (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle deactivate share link errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getFormSharingStats RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should get sharing stats successfully (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle get sharing stats errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getFormAnalytics RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should get analytics with default period (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should get analytics with custom period (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle get analytics errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts performBulkOperation RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should perform bulk publish operation successfully (2 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should perform bulk operation without settings (4 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle bulk operation errors (3 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts validateFormForPublication RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should validate form successfully when form can be published (2 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should validate form with validation issues (4 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle validation errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts edge cases and error handling RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✕ should handle empty form IDs array in bulk operation (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✕ should handle invalid email in notification emails (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✕ should handle invalid datetime in publish date (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ● FormSharingTool › generateShareLink › should generate share link successfully expect(received).toEqual(expected) // deep equality - Expected - 1 + Received + 1 @@ -8,9 +8,9 @@ "formId": "form-123", "id": "link-123", "type": "standard", "url": "https://tally.so/r/custom-slug", }, - "message": "Generated DIRECT share link for form form-123", + "message": "Generated STANDARD share link for form form-123", "shareUrl": "https://tally.so/r/custom-slug", "success": true, } 453 | customSlug: 'my-form' 454 | }); > 455 | expect(result).toEqual({ | ^ 456 | success: true, 457 | data: mockShareLinkResult, 458 | message: 'Generated DIRECT share link for form form-123', at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts:455:22) ● FormSharingTool › edge cases and error handling › should handle empty form IDs array in bulk operation expect(received).rejects.toThrow() Received promise resolved instead of rejected Resolved to value: {"error": "[ { \"code\": \"too_small\", \"minimum\": 1, \"type\": \"array\", \"inclusive\": true, \"exact\": false, \"message\": \"Array must contain at least 1 element(s)\", \"path\": [ \"formIds\" ] } ]", "message": "Failed to perform bulk operation", "success": false} 828 | // Act & Assert 829 | // The zod schema should throw a validation error for empty array > 830 | await expect(formSharingTool.performBulkOperation(input)).rejects.toThrow(); | ^ 831 | }); 832 | 833 | it('should handle invalid email in notification emails', async () => { at expect (node_modules/expect/build/index.js:113:15) at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts:830:13) ● FormSharingTool › edge cases and error handling › should handle invalid email in notification emails expect(received).rejects.toThrow() Received promise resolved instead of rejected Resolved to value: {"error": "[ { \"validation\": \"email\", \"code\": \"invalid_string\", \"message\": \"Invalid email\", \"path\": [ \"notificationEmails\", 0 ] } ]", "message": "Failed to publish form", "success": false} 840 | // Act & Assert 841 | // The zod schema should throw a validation error for invalid email > 842 | await expect(formSharingTool.publishForm(input)).rejects.toThrow(); | ^ 843 | }); 844 | 845 | it('should handle invalid datetime in publish date', async () => { at expect (node_modules/expect/build/index.js:113:15) at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts:842:13) ● FormSharingTool › edge cases and error handling › should handle invalid datetime in publish date expect(received).rejects.toThrow() Received promise resolved instead of rejected Resolved to value: {"error": "[ { \"code\": \"invalid_string\", \"validation\": \"datetime\", \"message\": \"Invalid datetime\", \"path\": [ \"publishDate\" ] } ]", "message": "Failed to publish form", "success": false} 852 | // Act & Assert 853 | // The zod schema should throw a validation error for invalid datetime > 854 | await expect(formSharingTool.publishForm(input)).rejects.toThrow(); | ^ 855 | }); 856 | }); 857 | }); at expect (node_modules/expect/build/index.js:113:15) at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts:854:13) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts FAIL src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts TeamManager RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts constructor RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should create an instance with required dependencies (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should create an instance with default config when none provided (4 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts createTeam RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should create a team successfully after validating workspace RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should throw error if workspace validation fails (8 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts getTeam RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should get team details successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should propagate service errors (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts updateTeam RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should update team without parent change (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should validate hierarchy when changing parent team RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should handle setting parentTeamId to undefined (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts deleteTeam RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should delete team without options (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should reassign members when reassignMembersTo option provided (2 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✕ should delete child teams when deleteChildTeams option is true (2 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should move child teams to parent when deleteChildTeams is false RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts getTeams RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should get teams list successfully (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should pass all options to service (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts addTeamMember RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should add team member with default role and permissions RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should add team member with custom role and permissions (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should throw error if team validation fails RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts removeTeamMember RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should remove team member successfully (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts updateTeamMember RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should update team member role and permissions (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should update only role when permissions not provided RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts bulkUpdateMemberships RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should perform bulk membership updates RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts moveUsersBetweenTeams RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should move users between teams successfully (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should use default member role when newRole not provided RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts moveTeam RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should move team to new parent RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should make team a root team when newParentTeamId is undefined (3 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts edge cases and error handling RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should handle empty user array in moveUsersBetweenTeams RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should handle team with no members in deleteTeam with reassignment (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✕ should handle team with no child teams in deleteTeam (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts method chaining RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ✓ should chain operations correctly RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts ● TeamManager › deleteTeam › should delete child teams when deleteChildTeams option is true expect(jest.fn()).toHaveBeenCalledWith(...expected) - Expected + Received - "child-team-1", + "team-123", {"deleteChildTeams": true}, Number of calls: 1 265 | 266 | // Assert > 267 | expect(deleteSpy).toHaveBeenCalledWith('child-team-1', { deleteChildTeams: true }); | ^ 268 | expect(deleteSpy).toHaveBeenCalledWith('child-team-2', { deleteChildTeams: true }); 269 | }); 270 | at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts:267:25) ● TeamManager › edge cases and error handling › should handle team with no child teams in deleteTeam expect(jest.fn()).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(expected) Expected number of calls: 1 Received number of calls: 0 579 | const deleteSpy = jest.spyOn(teamManager, 'deleteTeam'); 580 | // Should only be called once (for the main team, not recursively) > 581 | expect(deleteSpy).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1); | ^ 582 | }); 583 | }); 584 | at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts:581:25) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts Test Suites: 2 failed, 2 total Tests: 6 failed, 61 passed, 67 total Snapshots: 0 total Time: 0.598 s, estimated 1 s Ran all test suites matching /form-sharing-tool|team-manager/i. ╭─    ~/dev/projects/tally-mcp    develop !2 ?1 ·································· 1 ✘  13:24:33   ╰─ ``` --- Perfect! I can see the current type mismatch issues. Let me analyze the specific problems: --- --- Let me examine the current model interfaces and implementation to understand the type mismatches: --- Read file: src/models/index.ts --- Read file: src/models/form-sharing-models.ts --- --- Now let me check the FormSharingTool implementation to see how it handles the ShareLinkType enum: --- Read file: src/tools/form-sharing-tool.ts --- Let me check the generateShareLink method specifically: --- Read file: src/tools/form-sharing-tool.ts --- --- Now let me check how the FormPublicationService actually generates the share link result to understand the type mismatch: --- Read file: src/services/form-publication-service.ts --- --- Let me check the generateShareLink method to see how it determines the share link type: --- Read file: src/services/form-publication-service.ts --- --- Now let me check the failing tests to better understand what needs to be fixed: --- Read file: src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts --- --- Let me check the mock data to see what `mockShareLinkResult` contains: --- Read file: src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts --- --- Now I can see the issue! In the test, `mockShareLinkResult` has `type: ShareLinkType.STANDARD`, but the test is expecting the message to say "DIRECT". Let me also check the error handling pattern issue. Let me examine the error handling tests: --- Read file: src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts --- --- Perfect! Now I understand the issues clearly. Let me update the task with my progress and start fixing the type mismatches: --- --- --- Let me update the task instead since it doesn't have subtasks: --- --- --- Now let me start fixing the issues. First, let's fix the FormSharingTool test mock data: --- --- --- I see that fixing the ShareLinkType has exposed the deeper issue mentioned in the task description - the mock data structures don't match the updated interfaces. Let me fix the mock data structures systematically: --- --- --- Now let me fix the EmbedCodeSettings mock: --- --- Now let me fix the ShareLinkResult mock to match the interface: --- --- --- Given the extensive number of interface mismatches, let me run the test now to see if the key fix (ShareLinkType) has resolved the main failing test, and then address error handling: --- ```bash npm test -- --testPathPattern="form-sharing-tool" --testNamePattern="should generate share link successfully" ``` ``` ╭─    ~/dev/projects/tally-mcp    develop !2 ?1 ·································· 1 ✘  13:24:33   ❯ npm test -- --testPathPattern="form-sharing-tool" --testNamePattern="should generate share link successfully" > tally-mcp@1.0.0 test > jest --testPathPattern=form-sharing-tool --testNamePattern=should generate share link successfully PASS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts FormSharingTool constructor ○ skipped should create an instance with FormPublicationService publishForm ○ skipped should publish form successfully with minimal input ○ skipped should publish form with all optional parameters ○ skipped should handle publication errors ○ skipped should handle unknown errors ○ skipped should filter out undefined optional parameters unpublishForm ○ skipped should unpublish form successfully ○ skipped should handle unpublish errors getPublicationSettings ○ skipped should get publication settings successfully ○ skipped should handle get settings errors updatePublicationSettings ○ skipped should update publication settings successfully ○ skipped should filter out undefined values from settings ○ skipped should handle update settings errors generateEmbedCode ○ skipped should generate embed code successfully with minimal input ○ skipped should generate embed code with all options ○ skipped should handle embed code generation errors generateShareLink ✓ should generate share link successfully (6 ms) ○ skipped should generate share link with security options ○ skipped should handle share link generation errors getShareLinks ○ skipped should get share links successfully ○ skipped should handle get share links errors deactivateShareLink ○ skipped should deactivate share link successfully ○ skipped should handle deactivate share link errors getFormSharingStats ○ skipped should get sharing stats successfully ○ skipped should handle get sharing stats errors getFormAnalytics ○ skipped should get analytics with default period ○ skipped should get analytics with custom period ○ skipped should handle get analytics errors performBulkOperation ○ skipped should perform bulk publish operation successfully ○ skipped should perform bulk operation without settings ○ skipped should handle bulk operation errors validateFormForPublication ○ skipped should validate form successfully when form can be published ○ skipped should validate form with validation issues ○ skipped should handle validation errors edge cases and error handling ○ skipped should handle empty form IDs array in bulk operation ○ skipped should handle invalid email in notification emails ○ skipped should handle invalid datetime in publish date Test Suites: 1 passed, 1 total Tests: 36 skipped, 1 passed, 37 total Snapshots: 0 total Time: 0.358 s, estimated 1 s Ran all test suites matching /form-sharing-tool/i with tests matching "should generate share link successfully". ╭─    ~/dev/projects/tally-mcp    develop !3 ?1 ···································· ✔  13:27:27   ╰─ ``` --- --- Great! The ShareLinkType issue is fixed. Now let's address the error handling pattern issue. Let me test the error handling edge cases: --- ```bash npm test -- --testPathPattern="form-sharing-tool" --testNamePattern="edge cases and error handling" ``` ``` ╭─    ~/dev/projects/tally-mcp    develop !3 ?1 ···································· ✔  13:27:27   ❯ npm test -- --testPathPattern="form-sharing-tool" --testNamePattern="edge cases and error handling" > tally-mcp@1.0.0 test > jest --testPathPattern=form-sharing-tool --testNamePattern=edge cases and error handling RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts FAIL src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts FormSharingTool RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts constructor RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should create an instance with FormPublicationService RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts publishForm RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should publish form successfully with minimal input RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should publish form with all optional parameters RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle publication errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle unknown errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should filter out undefined optional parameters RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts unpublishForm RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should unpublish form successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle unpublish errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getPublicationSettings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get publication settings successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle get settings errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts updatePublicationSettings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should update publication settings successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should filter out undefined values from settings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle update settings errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts generateEmbedCode RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should generate embed code successfully with minimal input RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should generate embed code with all options RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle embed code generation errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts generateShareLink RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should generate share link successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should generate share link with security options RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle share link generation errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getShareLinks RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get share links successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle get share links errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts deactivateShareLink RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should deactivate share link successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle deactivate share link errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getFormSharingStats RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get sharing stats successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle get sharing stats errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getFormAnalytics RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get analytics with default period RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get analytics with custom period RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle get analytics errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts performBulkOperation RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should perform bulk publish operation successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should perform bulk operation without settings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle bulk operation errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts validateFormForPublication RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should validate form successfully when form can be published RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should validate form with validation issues RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle validation errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts edge cases and error handling RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✕ should handle empty form IDs array in bulk operation (5 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✕ should handle invalid email in notification emails (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✕ should handle invalid datetime in publish date (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ● FormSharingTool › edge cases and error handling › should handle empty form IDs array in bulk operation expect(received).rejects.toThrow() Received promise resolved instead of rejected Resolved to value: {"error": "[ { \"code\": \"too_small\", \"minimum\": 1, \"type\": \"array\", \"inclusive\": true, \"exact\": false, \"message\": \"Array must contain at least 1 element(s)\", \"path\": [ \"formIds\" ] } ]", "message": "Failed to perform bulk operation", "success": false} 840 | // Act & Assert 841 | // The zod schema should throw a validation error for empty array > 842 | await expect(formSharingTool.performBulkOperation(input)).rejects.toThrow(); | ^ 843 | }); 844 | 845 | it('should handle invalid email in notification emails', async () => { at expect (node_modules/expect/build/index.js:113:15) at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts:842:13) ● FormSharingTool › edge cases and error handling › should handle invalid email in notification emails expect(received).rejects.toThrow() Received promise resolved instead of rejected Resolved to value: {"error": "[ { \"validation\": \"email\", \"code\": \"invalid_string\", \"message\": \"Invalid email\", \"path\": [ \"notificationEmails\", 0 ] } ]", "message": "Failed to publish form", "success": false} 852 | // Act & Assert 853 | // The zod schema should throw a validation error for invalid email > 854 | await expect(formSharingTool.publishForm(input)).rejects.toThrow(); | ^ 855 | }); 856 | 857 | it('should handle invalid datetime in publish date', async () => { at expect (node_modules/expect/build/index.js:113:15) at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts:854:13) ● FormSharingTool › edge cases and error handling › should handle invalid datetime in publish date expect(received).rejects.toThrow() Received promise resolved instead of rejected Resolved to value: {"error": "[ { \"code\": \"invalid_string\", \"validation\": \"datetime\", \"message\": \"Invalid datetime\", \"path\": [ \"publishDate\" ] } ]", "message": "Failed to publish form", "success": false} 864 | // Act & Assert 865 | // The zod schema should throw a validation error for invalid datetime > 866 | await expect(formSharingTool.publishForm(input)).rejects.toThrow(); | ^ 867 | }); 868 | }); 869 | }); at expect (node_modules/expect/build/index.js:113:15) at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts:866:13) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts Test Suites: 1 failed, 1 total Tests: 3 failed, 34 skipped, 37 total Snapshots: 0 total Time: 0.325 s, estimated 1 s Ran all test suites matching /form-sharing-tool/i with tests matching "edge cases and error handling". ╭─    ~/dev/projects/tally-mcp    develop !3 ?1 ·································· 1 ✘  13:27:36   ╰─ ``` --- --- Perfect! Now I can see the error handling pattern issue clearly. The implementation currently catches Zod validation errors and returns `{success: false, error: string}` objects, but the tests expect the methods to throw exceptions. I need to decide which pattern to use. Based on the task description, I should standardize this. Looking at the current implementation, it's designed to return error objects rather than throw, which is a common API pattern. I think the tests should be updated to match this pattern rather than changing the implementation to throw. Let me update the tests to expect error objects instead of thrown exceptions: --- --- --- Now let me fix the other two error handling tests: --- --- --- Now let me test the error handling fixes: --- ```bash npm test -- --testPathPattern="form-sharing-tool" --testNamePattern="edge cases and error handling" ``` ``` ❯ npm test -- --testPathPattern="form-sharing-tool" --testNamePattern="edge cases and error handling" > tally-mcp@1.0.0 test > jest --testPathPattern=form-sharing-tool --testNamePattern=edge cases and error handling RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts PASS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts FormSharingTool RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts constructor RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should create an instance with FormPublicationService RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts publishForm RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should publish form successfully with minimal input RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should publish form with all optional parameters RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle publication errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle unknown errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should filter out undefined optional parameters RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts unpublishForm RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should unpublish form successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle unpublish errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getPublicationSettings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get publication settings successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle get settings errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts updatePublicationSettings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should update publication settings successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should filter out undefined values from settings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle update settings errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts generateEmbedCode RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should generate embed code successfully with minimal input RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should generate embed code with all options RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle embed code generation errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts generateShareLink RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should generate share link successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should generate share link with security options RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle share link generation errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getShareLinks RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get share links successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle get share links errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts deactivateShareLink RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should deactivate share link successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle deactivate share link errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getFormSharingStats RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get sharing stats successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle get sharing stats errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts getFormAnalytics RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get analytics with default period RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should get analytics with custom period RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle get analytics errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts performBulkOperation RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should perform bulk publish operation successfully RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should perform bulk operation without settings RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle bulk operation errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts validateFormForPublication RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should validate form successfully when form can be published RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should validate form with validation issues RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ○ skipped should handle validation errors RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts edge cases and error handling RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle empty form IDs array in bulk operation (5 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle invalid email in notification emails (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts ✓ should handle invalid datetime in publish date (1 ms) RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts RUNS src/tools/__tests__/form-sharing-tool.test.ts Test Suites: 1 passed, 1 total Tests: 34 skipped, 3 passed, 37 total Snapshots: 0 total Time: 0.357 s, estimated 1 s Ran all test suites matching /form-sharing-tool/i with tests matching "edge cases and error handling". ╭─    ~/dev/projects/tally-mcp    develop !3 ?1 ···································· ✔  13:28:15   ╰─ ``` --- --- --- Excellent! The error handling pattern is now consistent. Now let me test the TeamManager issues. Let me run the TeamManager tests to see the current state: --- ```bash npm test -- --testPathPattern="team-manager" --verbose ``` ``` ❯ npm test -- --testPathPattern="team-manager" --verbose > tally-mcp@1.0.0 test > jest --testPathPattern=team-manager --verbose FAIL src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts TeamManager constructor ✓ should create an instance with required dependencies (2 ms) ✓ should create an instance with default config when none provided (1 ms) createTeam ✓ should create a team successfully after validating workspace (2 ms) ✓ should throw error if workspace validation fails (9 ms) getTeam ✓ should get team details successfully (1 ms) ✓ should propagate service errors (4 ms) updateTeam ✓ should update team without parent change (1 ms) ✓ should validate hierarchy when changing parent team (1 ms) ✓ should handle setting parentTeamId to undefined deleteTeam ✓ should delete team without options ✓ should reassign members when reassignMembersTo option provided (1 ms) ✕ should delete child teams when deleteChildTeams option is true (2 ms) ✓ should move child teams to parent when deleteChildTeams is false getTeams ✓ should get teams list successfully (1 ms) ✓ should pass all options to service (1 ms) addTeamMember ✓ should add team member with default role and permissions (1 ms) ✓ should add team member with custom role and permissions ✓ should throw error if team validation fails removeTeamMember ✓ should remove team member successfully (3 ms) updateTeamMember ✓ should update team member role and permissions (1 ms) ✓ should update only role when permissions not provided (1 ms) bulkUpdateMemberships ✓ should perform bulk membership updates (1 ms) moveUsersBetweenTeams ✓ should move users between teams successfully (1 ms) ✓ should use default member role when newRole not provided moveTeam ✓ should move team to new parent ✓ should make team a root team when newParentTeamId is undefined (1 ms) edge cases and error handling ✓ should handle empty user array in moveUsersBetweenTeams ✓ should handle team with no members in deleteTeam with reassignment ✕ should handle team with no child teams in deleteTeam (1 ms) method chaining ✓ should chain operations correctly ● TeamManager › deleteTeam › should delete child teams when deleteChildTeams option is true expect(jest.fn()).toHaveBeenCalledWith(...expected) - Expected + Received - "child-team-1", + "team-123", {"deleteChildTeams": true}, Number of calls: 1 265 | 266 | // Assert > 267 | expect(deleteSpy).toHaveBeenCalledWith('child-team-1', { deleteChildTeams: true }); | ^ 268 | expect(deleteSpy).toHaveBeenCalledWith('child-team-2', { deleteChildTeams: true }); 269 | }); 270 | at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts:267:25) ● TeamManager › edge cases and error handling › should handle team with no child teams in deleteTeam expect(jest.fn()).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(expected) Expected number of calls: 1 Received number of calls: 0 579 | const deleteSpy = jest.spyOn(teamManager, 'deleteTeam'); 580 | // Should only be called once (for the main team, not recursively) > 581 | expect(deleteSpy).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(1); | ^ 582 | }); 583 | }); 584 | at Object.<anonymous> (src/tools/__tests__/team-manager.test.ts:581:25) Test Suites: 1 failed, 1 total Tests: 2 failed, 28 passed, 30 total Snapshots: 0 total Time: 0.361 s, estimated 1 s Ran all test suites matching /team-manager/i. ╭─    ~/dev/projects/tally-mcp    develop !3 ?1 ·································· 1 ✘  14:40:17   ╰─ ``` --- --- Perfect! I can see the TeamManager issues clearly. The problem is that the recursive deletion logic is calling `deleteTeam` with the main team ID instead of iterating through child team IDs. Let me check the TeamManager implementation: --- Read file: src/tools/team-manager.ts --- ---