e2e-failure-analysis.test.ts•13.7 kB
/**
* E2E Failure Analysis Test Suite
*
* Comprehensive analysis of E2E test failures to identify root causes
* and validate fixes for Issue #480 Phase 3.
*
* This test suite replicates the exact E2E test patterns that are failing
* to isolate and fix the issues systematically.
*/
import { describe, it, expect, beforeAll } from 'vitest';
import { TaskMockFactory } from './mock-factories/TaskMockFactory.js';
import { CompanyMockFactory } from './mock-factories/CompanyMockFactory.js';
import { PersonMockFactory } from './mock-factories/PersonMockFactory.js';
import { ListMockFactory } from './mock-factories/ListMockFactory.js';
import { TestEnvironment } from './mock-factories/test-environment.js';
import {
StandardErrorMessages,
ErrorPatternValidator,
ERROR_PATTERNS,
} from './mock-error-responses.js';
// Import E2E test data factories to replicate exact test scenarios
import { E2ETaskFactory } from '../e2e/utils/test-data.js';
describe('E2E Failure Analysis - Issue #480 Root Cause Investigation', () => {
beforeAll(() => {
// Ensure we're in test environment
expect(TestEnvironment.isTest()).toBe(true);
console.log('🔬 Starting E2E failure analysis in test environment');
});
describe('Task Creation Failure Analysis', () => {
it('should analyze high priority task creation pattern', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing high priority task creation...');
// Replicate the exact E2E test pattern
const taskData = E2ETaskFactory.createHighPriority();
console.log('E2E Task Data:', taskData);
// Create mock task using the same pattern as E2E tests
const mockTask = TaskMockFactory.createHighPriority({
content: taskData.title,
due_date: taskData.due_date,
});
console.log('Mock Task Created:', {
id: mockTask.id,
content: mockTask.content,
title: mockTask.title || 'NOT_PROVIDED',
hasContent: !!mockTask.content,
hasTitle: !!mockTask.title,
contentOrTitle: mockTask.content || mockTask.title,
});
// Issue #480 compatibility checks
expect(mockTask.content || mockTask.title).toBeDefined();
expect(mockTask.content || mockTask.title).toContain('Test Task');
expect(mockTask.id.task_id).toBeDefined();
expect(mockTask.id.record_id).toBeDefined();
console.log('✅ High priority task creation pattern validated');
});
it('should analyze task assignee creation pattern', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing task assignee creation...');
// Create a person first (as E2E tests do)
const person = PersonMockFactory.create();
const taskData = E2ETaskFactory.create();
// Create task with assignee
const mockTask = TaskMockFactory.createWithAssignee(person.id.record_id, {
content: taskData.title,
due_date: taskData.due_date,
});
console.log('Task with Assignee:', {
taskId: mockTask.id.task_id,
assigneeId: mockTask.assignee?.id,
hasAssignee: !!mockTask.assignee,
});
expect(mockTask.assignee).toBeDefined();
expect(mockTask.assignee!.id).toBe(person.id.record_id);
console.log('✅ Task assignee creation pattern validated');
});
it('should analyze task lifecycle workflow patterns', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing task lifecycle workflow...');
const taskData = E2ETaskFactory.create();
// Step 1: Create task
let workflowTask = TaskMockFactory.create({
content: 'E2E Workflow Task - Initial Creation',
due_date: taskData.due_date,
});
expect(workflowTask.status).toBeDefined();
console.log('Step 1 - Created:', workflowTask.status);
// Step 2: Update to in progress
workflowTask = TaskMockFactory.create({
content: 'E2E Workflow Task - Now In Progress',
status: 'in_progress',
});
expect(workflowTask.status).toBe('in_progress');
console.log('Step 2 - In Progress:', workflowTask.status);
// Step 3: Complete task
workflowTask = TaskMockFactory.createCompleted({
content: 'E2E Workflow Task - Completed Successfully',
});
expect(workflowTask.status).toBe('completed');
console.log('Step 3 - Completed:', workflowTask.status);
console.log('✅ Task lifecycle workflow patterns validated');
});
it('should analyze concurrent task operations pattern', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing concurrent task operations...');
// Simulate concurrent task creation (as E2E tests do)
const taskPromises = Array.from({ length: 3 }, (_, i) => {
const taskData = E2ETaskFactory.create();
return Promise.resolve(
TaskMockFactory.create({
content: `Concurrent Task ${i + 1}: ${taskData.title}`,
due_date: taskData.due_date,
})
);
});
return Promise.all(taskPromises).then((concurrentTasks) => {
expect(concurrentTasks).toHaveLength(3);
concurrentTasks.forEach((task, index) => {
expect(task.content).toContain(`Concurrent Task ${index + 1}`);
expect(task.id.task_id).toBeDefined();
});
console.log('✅ Concurrent task operations pattern validated');
});
});
});
describe('Error Message Pattern Analysis', () => {
it('should validate "not found" error patterns match E2E expectations', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing error message patterns...');
const errorScenarios = [
{
message: StandardErrorMessages.notFound('Task', 'invalid-task-id'),
pattern: ERROR_PATTERNS.NOT_FOUND,
},
{
message: StandardErrorMessages.notFound(
'Company',
'invalid-company-id'
),
pattern: ERROR_PATTERNS.NOT_FOUND,
},
{
message: StandardErrorMessages.notFound(
'Person',
'invalid-person-id'
),
pattern: ERROR_PATTERNS.NOT_FOUND,
},
{
message: StandardErrorMessages.doesNotExist('List'),
pattern: ERROR_PATTERNS.NOT_FOUND,
},
{
message: StandardErrorMessages.invalidId('Record', 'malformed-id'),
pattern: ERROR_PATTERNS.NOT_FOUND,
},
];
errorScenarios.forEach(({ message, pattern }) => {
const isValid = ErrorPatternValidator.validate(message, pattern);
expect(isValid).toBe(true);
console.log(`✅ Error pattern valid: "${message}"`);
});
console.log('✅ All error message patterns validated');
});
it('should validate E2E test tool error format', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing E2E tool error format...');
// E2E tests expect errors in the format: "Error executing tool 'tool-name': <error-message>"
const toolErrorFormats = [
ErrorPatternValidator.formatForE2ETest(
'update-record',
'task_not_found',
'invalid-task-123'
),
ErrorPatternValidator.formatForE2ETest(
'delete-record',
'list_not_found',
'invalid-list-456'
),
ErrorPatternValidator.formatForE2ETest(
'get-record-details',
'company_not_found',
'invalid-company-789'
),
];
toolErrorFormats.forEach((errorMessage) => {
const isValid = ErrorPatternValidator.validate(errorMessage);
expect(isValid).toBe(true);
console.log(`✅ Tool error format valid: "${errorMessage}"`);
});
console.log('✅ E2E tool error formats validated');
});
});
describe('Data Structure Compatibility Analysis', () => {
it('should validate company ID structure for notes management tests', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing company ID structure for notes...');
const company = CompanyMockFactory.create();
// Notes management tests expect company.id to be defined
expect(company.id).toBeDefined();
expect(company.id.record_id).toBeDefined();
expect(company.id.workspace_id).toBeDefined();
console.log('Company ID Structure:', {
hasId: !!company.id,
hasRecordId: !!company.id?.record_id,
hasWorkspaceId: !!company.id?.workspace_id,
});
console.log('✅ Company ID structure validated');
});
it('should validate person ID structure for notes management tests', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing person ID structure for notes...');
const person = PersonMockFactory.create();
// Notes management tests expect person.id to be defined
expect(person.id).toBeDefined();
expect(person.id.record_id).toBeDefined();
expect(person.id.workspace_id).toBeDefined();
console.log('Person ID Structure:', {
hasId: !!person.id,
hasRecordId: !!person.id?.record_id,
hasWorkspaceId: !!person.id?.workspace_id,
});
console.log('✅ Person ID structure validated');
});
it('should validate list ID structure differences', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing list ID structure...');
const list = ListMockFactory.create();
// Lists use list_id instead of record_id
expect(list.id).toBeDefined();
expect(list.id.list_id).toBeDefined();
expect(list.title || list.name).toBeDefined();
console.log('List ID Structure:', {
hasId: !!list.id,
hasListId: !!list.id?.list_id,
hasTitle: !!list.title,
hasName: !!list.name,
});
console.log('✅ List ID structure validated');
});
});
describe('Universal Tools Integration Analysis', () => {
it('should validate universal tool response format', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing universal tool response format...');
// Universal tools should return data in content field
const mockResponses = {
task: TaskMockFactory.create(),
company: CompanyMockFactory.create(),
person: PersonMockFactory.create(),
list: ListMockFactory.create(),
};
Object.entries(mockResponses).forEach(([type, data]) => {
expect(data).toBeDefined();
expect(typeof data).toBe('object');
console.log(`✅ ${type} response structure valid`);
});
console.log('✅ Universal tool response formats validated');
});
});
describe('Mock Factory Performance Analysis', () => {
it('should validate mock factory creation speed', () => {
console.log('🔍 Analyzing mock factory performance...');
const startTime = Date.now();
// Create multiple instances as E2E tests do
const tasks = TaskMockFactory.createMultiple(5);
const companies = Array.from({ length: 5 }, () =>
CompanyMockFactory.create()
);
const people = Array.from({ length: 5 }, () =>
PersonMockFactory.create()
);
const lists = Array.from({ length: 5 }, () => ListMockFactory.create());
const endTime = Date.now();
const duration = endTime - startTime;
expect(tasks).toHaveLength(5);
expect(companies).toHaveLength(5);
expect(people).toHaveLength(5);
expect(lists).toHaveLength(5);
console.log('Mock Factory Performance:', {
totalCreated: 20,
durationMs: duration,
averageMs: duration / 20,
});
// Should be fast (under 100ms for 20 items)
expect(duration).toBeLessThan(100);
console.log('✅ Mock factory performance validated');
});
});
describe('Comprehensive E2E Scenario Simulation', () => {
it('should simulate complete E2E test data setup workflow', () => {
console.log('🔍 Simulating complete E2E workflow...');
// Step 1: Create test companies (as E2E tests do)
const testCompanies = Array.from({ length: 2 }, () => {
const companyData = {
name: `E2E Test Company ${Date.now()}`,
domain: `e2e-test-${Date.now()}.com`,
};
return CompanyMockFactory.create(companyData);
});
// Step 2: Create test people
const testPeople = Array.from({ length: 2 }, () => {
const personData = {
name: `E2E Test Person ${Date.now()}`,
email_addresses: [`e2e-${Date.now()}@test.com`],
};
return PersonMockFactory.create(personData);
});
// Step 3: Create tasks with various scenarios
const basicTask = TaskMockFactory.create({
content: 'E2E Basic Task',
});
const assignedTask = TaskMockFactory.createWithAssignee(
testPeople[0].id.record_id,
{
content: 'E2E Assigned Task',
}
);
const linkedTask = TaskMockFactory.createWithLinkedRecords(
[testCompanies[0].id.record_id],
{
content: 'E2E Linked Task',
}
);
const highPriorityTask = TaskMockFactory.createHighPriority({
content: 'E2E High Priority Task',
});
// Validate all components
expect(testCompanies).toHaveLength(2);
expect(testPeople).toHaveLength(2);
expect(basicTask.content).toContain('Basic Task');
expect(assignedTask.assignee).toBeDefined();
expect(linkedTask.linked_records).toBeDefined();
expect(highPriorityTask.content).toContain('High Priority');
console.log('E2E Workflow Simulation Results:', {
companies: testCompanies.length,
people: testPeople.length,
tasks: 4,
allValid: true,
});
console.log('✅ Complete E2E workflow simulation validated');
});
});
});