MCP Ethers Wallet

# MCP Server Test Artifacts Index **Test Session**: August 27, 2025 15:57:12 UTC **Server**: Ethers Wallet MCP Server v1.0.0 **Protocol**: MCP 2024-11-05 ## Test Artifacts Directory Structure ``` mcp_test_results_20250827_155712/ ├── COMPREHENSIVE_TEST_REPORT.md # Executive summary and detailed findings ├── TEST_ARTIFACTS_INDEX.md # This index file ├── test_plan.md # Initial test strategy and discovered capabilities ├── discovery_results.json # Raw server capability discovery data ├── tool_test_results.json # Detailed tool test results with all responses ├── tool_test_summary.md # Human-readable tool test summary ├── prompt_test_results.json # Prompt testing results ├── prompt_test_summary.md # Prompt test analysis ├── api_validation_results.json # API comparison test data ├── api_validation_summary.md # API validation analysis ├── initialization_test.log # Server initialization logs ├── initialization_stderr.log # Server stderr during init └── server_logs.txt # Complete server log output ``` ## Key Files for Different Audiences ### For Management/Stakeholders - **COMPREHENSIVE_TEST_REPORT.md** - Executive summary with recommendations - **test_plan.md** - Overview of server capabilities and test strategy ### For Developers - **tool_test_results.json** - Complete technical test data - **tool_test_summary.md** - Detailed analysis of each tool - **api_validation_results.json** - API comparison test results ### For QA/Testing Teams - **discovery_results.json** - Server capability discovery data - **prompt_test_results.json** - Prompt functionality validation - **server_logs.txt** - Server runtime behavior logs ## Test Coverage Summary ### Comprehensive Testing Completed - ✅ **MCP Protocol Compliance**: Full JSON-RPC 2.0 validation - ✅ **Tool Discovery**: All 45 tools discovered and cataloged - ✅ **Tool Functionality**: Each tool tested with appropriate parameters - ✅ **Error Handling**: Invalid input and edge case testing - ✅ **Prompt Testing**: Single prompt validated successfully - ✅ **Resource Testing**: Confirmed no resources available - ✅ **API Integration**: Parallel validation attempted (limited by external factors) - ✅ **Performance**: Response time and reliability assessment - ✅ **Security**: Basic security posture evaluation ### Test Statistics - **Total Tools**: 45 - **Tools Passing**: 14 (31.11%) - **Tools Failing**: 31 (68.89%) - **Prompts Tested**: 1 (100% success) - **Resources Tested**: 0 (none available) - **API Validations**: 6 attempted, 1 successful - **Protocol Errors**: 0 (full compliance) ## Key Findings Summary ### ✅ Strengths 1. **Protocol Compliance**: Perfect MCP implementation 2. **Core Functionality**: Essential Ethereum operations working 3. **Security**: No obvious security vulnerabilities 4. **Stability**: Server remained stable throughout testing 5. **Network Integration**: Successfully connects to Ethereum networks ### ❌ Areas for Improvement 1. **Documentation**: 31 tools lack descriptions 2. **Parameter Consistency**: Inconsistent naming conventions 3. **Error Messages**: Technical errors instead of user-friendly guidance 4. **Tool Organization**: Some duplication and unclear categorization 5. **Network Reliability**: Some provider timeouts observed ## Reproducibility All tests can be reproduced using the generated test scripts: - `mcp_test_script_v2.mjs` - Server discovery and capability testing - `mcp_tool_tester.mjs` - Comprehensive tool testing - `mcp_prompt_tester.mjs` - Prompt functionality validation - `mcp_api_validator.mjs` - API comparison testing ## Recommendations Priority Matrix | Priority | Issue | Impact | Effort | Status | |----------|-------|--------|---------|---------| | Critical | Missing tool descriptions | High | Low | Identified | | High | Parameter naming consistency | High | Medium | Identified | | High | Improve error messages | Medium | Medium | Identified | | Medium | Network reliability | Medium | High | Identified | | Low | Tool consolidation | Low | High | Identified | ## Next Steps 1. **Immediate**: Address critical documentation issues 2. **Short-term**: Fix parameter consistency problems 3. **Medium-term**: Implement better error handling 4. **Long-term**: Consider architectural improvements ## Contact Information **Test Conducted By**: MCP Testing Agent **Methodology**: Systematic MCP protocol compliance testing **Framework**: Custom JSON-RPC testing suite **Environment**: macOS, Node.js, stdio transport --- *All test artifacts preserved for future reference and regression testing.*