Smart MCP

{ "locDiscipline": 3, "locDisciplineRationale": "All files ≤300 LOC. Largest file is README.md at 225 LOC, main code file smart_mcp.py is 145 LOC. Excellent discipline.", "validation": 0, "validationRationale": "No schema validation beyond basic JSON schema type checking. MCP tool has 0% validation coverage - only checks for required 'shortcut' key but no content validation.", "secrets": 3, "secretsRationale": "No secrets found in code. No environment variables used. Static configuration only. Perfect hygiene for this use case.", "statePersistence": 3, "statePersistenceRationale": "Completely stateless. No cross-request memory. Reads shortcuts.json on each call. Fully idempotent. No databases or caching.", "errorsRetriesIdempotency": 1, "errorsRetriesIdempotencyRationale": "Basic error handling with try/catch blocks and ValueError exceptions. No structured errors (Problem+JSON). No retries/backoff (not needed for this use case). Inconsistent error handling (file errors silent, validation errors raise).", "testingCi": 0, "testingCiRationale": "No tests, no test framework, no CI/CD. Zero coverage. Critical paths untested (shortcuts loading, validation, error handling)." }