workflow-progress-improvements.mdβ’7.91 kB
# π§ Workflow Progress System Improvements
## π Summary of Changes Made
### 1. **Enhanced Step Completion Reporting**
**BEFORE (Fragile Approach):**
```typescript
// Old approach - fragile data extraction
const executionData = {
someField: "value",
anotherField: "data"
}; // Unknown structure
// Service tried to guess what data existed
private extractValidationResults(executionData?: unknown) {
// Try to find validation-related fields by guessing
const validationFields = ['validationResults', 'qualityChecksComplete'];
// ...fragile extraction logic
}
```
**AFTER (Structured Approach):**
```typescript
// New approach - explicit Zod schema validation
const reportData = {
executionId: "exec-123",
stepId: "step-456",
result: "success",
// Structured execution data with clear schema
executionData: {
outputSummary: "Clear description of what was accomplished",
filesModified: ["file1.ts", "file2.ts"],
commandsExecuted: ["npm test", "git commit"],
// ... other structured fields
},
// Explicit validation results
validationResults: {
allChecksPassed: true,
qualityScore: 9.5,
checklist: [
{
item: "Code quality check",
passed: true,
evidence: "All linting rules passed"
}
]
},
// Structured report data
reportData: {
stepType: "implementation",
keyAchievements: ["Feature implemented successfully"],
nextStepRecommendations: ["Add integration tests"]
}
};
```
### 2. **Fixed Step Progress Tracking**
**BEFORE (Incorrect Approach):**
```typescript
// Old - used taskId for progress tracking
const GetStepProgressInputSchema = z.object({
id: z.number().describe('Task ID for progress query'),
roleId: z.string().optional()
});
// Queried by taskId instead of executionId
const executionResult = await this.workflowExecutionOperationsService.getExecution({
taskId: input.id,
});
```
**AFTER (Correct Approach):**
```typescript
// New - uses executionId for progress tracking
const GetStepProgressInputSchema = z.object({
executionId: z.string().describe('Execution ID for progress query'),
roleId: z.string().optional()
});
// Queries by executionId as intended
const executionResult = await this.workflowExecutionOperationsService.getExecution({
executionId: input.executionId,
});
```
### 3. **Comprehensive Progress Information**
**BEFORE (Limited Data):**
```typescript
// Old - minimal progress info
return {
taskId: input.id,
status: execution.completedAt ? 'completed' : 'in_progress',
currentStep: {
name: currentStep?.name || 'No current step',
status: execution.completedAt ? 'completed' : 'active',
stepId: currentStep?.id,
},
progress: {
stepsCompleted: execution.stepsCompleted || 0,
progressPercentage: execution.progressPercentage || 0,
}
};
```
**AFTER (Rich Context Data):**
```typescript
// New - comprehensive progress with detailed context
return {
executionId: input.executionId,
taskId: execution.taskId,
status: execution.completedAt ? 'completed' : 'in_progress',
// Current execution state
currentStep: {
id: currentStep?.id,
name: currentStep?.name || 'No current step',
status: execution.completedAt ? 'completed' : 'active',
roleId: execution.currentRoleId,
roleName: currentRole?.name || 'Unknown',
},
// Progress metrics
progress: {
stepsCompleted: execution.stepsCompleted || 0,
progressPercentage: execution.progressPercentage || 0,
totalSteps: execution.totalSteps || 0,
},
// π§ NEW: Detailed step execution history
completedSteps: [
{
stepId: "step-123",
stepName: "Implementation",
roleId: "role-456",
roleName: "Senior Developer",
completedAt: "2025-07-14T10:00:00Z",
executionData: { /* structured data */ },
validationResults: { /* structured validation */ },
reportData: { /* structured report */ }
}
],
// Execution context for workflow continuation
executionContext: {
phase: "in-progress",
startedAt: "2025-07-14T09:00:00Z",
executionMode: "GUIDED",
lastProgressUpdate: "2025-07-14T10:00:00Z"
},
// Summary for AI agent understanding
contextSummary: {
totalStepsCompleted: 3,
lastCompletedStep: { /* last step info */ },
hasValidationData: true,
hasReportData: true,
keyFindings: [
"Setup: Project initialized",
"Implementation: Core features implemented",
"Testing: All tests passing"
]
}
};
```
## π― Key Benefits
### 1. **Type Safety & Validation**
- β
**Zod Schema Validation**: Ensures data structure correctness
- β
**Clear Error Messages**: Helpful validation errors when data is incorrect
- β
**TypeScript Integration**: Full type safety throughout the workflow
### 2. **Better Agent Context**
- β
**Rich Progress Data**: Agents can understand what work has been completed
- β
**Structured History**: Complete execution history with detailed context
- β
**Key Findings**: Summarized insights from completed steps
- β
**Workflow Continuation**: All context needed to continue work seamlessly
### 3. **Improved Maintainability**
- β
**No Data Guessing**: Explicit schema instead of fragile extraction
- β
**Extensible Schema**: Easy to add new fields without breaking changes
- β
**Documentation**: Schema serves as documentation for expected data
- β
**Backward Compatibility**: Old methods deprecated but not removed
### 4. **Enhanced Reliability**
- β
**Consistent Data Structure**: All completion reports follow same schema
- β
**Validation at Input**: Catches issues before they reach the database
- β
**Proper Error Handling**: Clear error messages for debugging
- β
**Database Integrity**: Structured data ensures consistent storage
## π Usage for AI Agents
### **Simple Step Completion**
```typescript
await report_step_completion({
executionId: "exec-123",
stepId: "step-456",
result: "success"
});
```
### **Detailed Step Completion**
```typescript
await report_step_completion({
executionId: "exec-123",
stepId: "step-456",
result: "success",
executionTime: 5000,
executionData: {
outputSummary: "Successfully implemented authentication system",
filesModified: ["auth.service.ts", "auth.controller.ts"],
commandsExecuted: ["npm test", "git commit"]
},
validationResults: {
allChecksPassed: true,
qualityScore: 9.5,
checklist: [
{
item: "All tests passing",
passed: true,
evidence: "12/12 tests pass"
}
]
},
reportData: {
stepType: "implementation",
keyAchievements: ["Authentication system implemented"],
nextStepRecommendations: ["Add authorization system"]
}
});
```
### **Get Comprehensive Progress**
```typescript
const progress = await get_step_progress({
executionId: "exec-123"
});
// Returns rich context including:
// - Current step details
// - All completed steps with their data
// - Validation results from each step
// - Report data from each step
// - Key findings summary
// - Context for continuation
```
## π Migration Path
1. **Existing Workflows**: Continue to work with backward compatibility
2. **New Workflows**: Use structured schema for better experience
3. **Gradual Adoption**: Agents can start using structured data incrementally
4. **No Breaking Changes**: Old API still supported during transition
This improvement transforms the workflow system from fragile data extraction to robust, type-safe, structured data handling that provides AI agents with the context they need to continue work seamlessly.