# Test Execution Summary - UNLOCK MLS MCP Server
**Execution Date**: July 27, 2025
**Test Environment**: Development environment with mocked dependencies
**Total Tests Identified**: 195+ tests across 9 test modules
## Test Module Results
### ✅ PASSING Test Modules
#### 1. Core MCP Tools (`test_tools.py`)
- **Status**: ✅ ALL PASSING
- **Tests**: 21/21 passed (100%)
- **Execution Time**: 0.25 seconds
- **Coverage**: MCP tool functionality, resources
**Test Categories**:
- Property search tools (5 tests)
- Property details tools (2 tests)
- Market analysis tools (3 tests)
- Agent finder tools (3 tests)
- MCP resources (8 tests)
**Key Success**: All core MCP functionality works correctly when properly mocked.
#### 2. OAuth2 Handler (`test_oauth2.py`)
- **Status**: ✅ ALL PASSING
- **Tests**: 19/19 passed (100%)
- **Execution Time**: 0.12 seconds
- **Coverage**: Authentication, token management, retry logic
**Test Categories**:
- Token validation (4 tests)
- Authentication flow (7 tests)
- Request handling (4 tests)
- Concurrency (4 tests)
**Key Success**: OAuth2Handler implementation is correct and robust.
#### 3. Data Mapper (`test_data_mapper.py`)
- **Status**: ✅ ALL PASSING
- **Tests**: 29/29 passed (100%)
- **Execution Time**: <0.1 seconds
- **Coverage**: Data transformation, formatting, validation
**Key Success**: Data mapping and transformation logic is solid.
### ❌ FAILING Test Modules
#### 1. Error Scenarios (`test_error_scenarios.py`)
- **Status**: ❌ MULTIPLE FAILURES
- **Tests**: 24 tests (majority failing)
- **Primary Issue**: Method name mismatch in mocks
**Sample Failure**:
```python
# Test expects:
server.oauth_handler.get_access_token.side_effect = Exception("OAuth authentication failed")
# But OAuth2Handler only has:
async def get_valid_token(self) -> str:
```
**Root Cause**: All error scenario tests use incorrect method name in mocks.
#### 2. Integration Tests (`test_integration.py`)
- **Status**: ❌ PARTIAL FAILURES
- **Tests**: 10 tests (4 failing, 6 passing)
- **Execution**: Timeout after 2 minutes
**Failing Tests**:
- `test_complete_property_search_workflow` - OAuth method mismatch
- `test_comprehensive_real_estate_research_workflow` - Authentication failure
**Passing Tests**:
- `test_property_details_to_analysis_workflow` - ✅
- `test_agent_search_to_contact_workflow` - ✅
- Resource integration tests - ✅
- Data consistency tests - ✅
#### 3. Load Tests (`test_load.py`)
- **Status**: ❌ MULTIPLE FAILURES
- **Tests**: 5+ tests (3+ failing)
- **Primary Issue**: Server startup failure prevents load testing
**Sample Error**:
```python
# Load test setup fails because:
oauth_handler.get_access_token.return_value = "load_test_token"
# Method doesn't exist on real OAuth2Handler
```
#### 4. Performance Tests (`test_performance.py`)
- **Status**: ❌ FAILING (not executed due to timeout)
- **Tests**: 15+ tests
- **Issue**: Same OAuth method naming problem
## Specific Error Examples
### Error 1: Method Naming Mismatch
```python
# tests/test_error_scenarios.py:58
async def test_oauth_token_failure(self, error_test_server):
server = error_test_server
# ❌ This fails - method doesn't exist
server.oauth_handler.get_access_token.side_effect = Exception("OAuth authentication failed")
# Should be:
# server.oauth_handler.get_valid_token.side_effect = Exception("OAuth authentication failed")
```
### Error 2: Server Startup Failure
```bash
$ python -m main
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "/Users/davidgumpper/Documents/projects/unlock-reso-mcp/src/server.py", line 1757, in run
await self.oauth_handler.get_access_token() # ❌ Method doesn't exist
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
AttributeError: 'OAuth2Handler' object has no attribute 'get_access_token'
```
### Error 3: Mock Return Type Issues
```python
# src/server.py:315
result_text = f"Found {len(mapped_properties)} properties:\n\n"
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
TypeError: object of type 'Mock' has no len()
# Mock returns Mock object instead of list
# mapped_properties should be List[Dict] but is Mock
```
## Test Infrastructure Analysis
### Mocking Strategy Issues
#### Current Mock Pattern (Broken):
```python
# Used in 40+ test locations
server.oauth_handler.get_access_token.return_value = "test_token"
```
#### Correct Mock Pattern (Required):
```python
# Should use actual OAuth2Handler API
server.oauth_handler.get_valid_token.return_value = "test_token"
# OR implement get_access_token() method
```
### Test Fixture Problems
#### Data Mapper Mock Configuration:
```python
# tests/fixtures/test_utilities.py
# Issue: Mock not returning correct data type
server.data_mapper.map_properties.return_value = mapped_properties
# mapped_properties should be List[Dict] but becomes Mock
```
## Performance Impact
### Test Execution Performance:
- **Working Tests**: Fast execution (0.1-0.25 seconds per module)
- **Broken Tests**: Timeout after 120 seconds
- **Full Suite**: Cannot complete due to timeouts
### Development Impact:
- **Feedback Loop**: Broken (cannot run tests to validate changes)
- **CI/CD Pipeline**: Would fail completely
- **Quality Assurance**: Cannot validate functionality
## Coverage Analysis
### Actual Coverage (Working Tests Only):
```
Module Tests Status Coverage
test_tools.py 21 ✅ PASS Core MCP tools
test_oauth2.py 19 ✅ PASS Authentication
test_data_mapper.py 29 ✅ PASS Data transformation
test_validators.py ~15 ❓ UNKNOWN Input validation
test_reso_client.py ~25 ❓ UNKNOWN API client
```
### Claimed vs Actual Coverage:
- **Claimed**: 89% coverage with 195+ tests
- **Actual Working**: ~35% coverage with 69 passing tests
- **Gap**: 126+ tests not working due to authentication issues
## Root Cause Analysis
### Primary Root Cause:
**API Design Inconsistency** - OAuth2Handler implements `get_valid_token()` but all consumers expect `get_access_token()`
### Secondary Root Causes:
1. **Mock Configuration Errors** - Mocks not returning correct data types
2. **Test Infrastructure Dependencies** - Authentication failure cascades to all dependent tests
3. **Integration Test Complexity** - Complex workflows fail when any component is broken
### Tertiary Issues:
1. **Test Timeout Configuration** - Long timeouts mask rapid failure detection
2. **Error Message Quality** - Mocking errors don't clearly indicate root cause
3. **Test Isolation** - Tests not properly isolated from authentication dependencies
## Recommendations
### Immediate Actions (Critical Priority):
1. **Fix OAuth2Handler API** - Add `get_access_token()` method
```python
# Add to OAuth2Handler:
async def get_access_token(self) -> str:
"""Get access token (alias for get_valid_token)."""
return await self.get_valid_token()
```
2. **Validate Core Functionality** - Test server startup after fix
```bash
python -m main # Should start without errors
```
3. **Fix Critical Mock Configurations** - Update data mapper mocks to return lists instead of Mock objects
### Short-term Actions (High Priority):
4. **Update All Test Mocks** - Either update mocks to use `get_valid_token()` or implement `get_access_token()`
5. **Run Full Test Suite** - Validate that authentication fix resolves majority of failures
6. **Fix Remaining Mock Issues** - Address data type and return value problems
### Medium-term Actions (Medium Priority):
7. **Improve Test Isolation** - Reduce dependencies between test modules
8. **Add Real Integration Tests** - Test with actual Bridge Interactive API (if credentials available)
9. **Performance Test Validation** - Ensure performance tests provide meaningful metrics
## Success Criteria
### Phase 1 Success (Critical):
- ✅ Server starts without errors
- ✅ OAuth2Handler method consistency achieved
- ✅ 80%+ of tests passing
### Phase 2 Success (Important):
- ✅ All integration tests passing
- ✅ Error scenarios properly tested
- ✅ Load tests functional
### Phase 3 Success (Optimal):
- ✅ 95%+ test success rate
- ✅ Real API integration validated
- ✅ Performance benchmarks established
## Conclusion
The test execution reveals a classic case where strong architectural design and comprehensive test coverage plans are undermined by a single, critical API inconsistency. The OAuth2Handler implementation is robust and well-tested, but the method naming mismatch creates a cascading failure across the entire test suite.
The good news is that the core MCP functionality (21 tests), OAuth2 implementation (19 tests), and data mapping (29 tests) all work correctly. This suggests that once the API consistency issue is resolved, the remaining 126+ tests should largely pass with minimal additional fixes.
**Bottom Line**: Fix the OAuth2Handler API naming, and the majority of the test infrastructure should become functional, validating the claimed 89% coverage and 195+ test count.
