final-compatibility-report.js•10.8 kB
#!/usr/bin/env node
/**
* Final Compatibility Assessment Report
* Comprehensive analysis of MCP Console Automation vs Backup Features
*/
import fs from 'fs';
import path from 'path';
console.log('🎯 MCP Console Automation - Final Compatibility Assessment');
console.log('========================================================\n');
const report = {
metadata: {
timestamp: new Date().toISOString(),
backupFileSize: '379KB',
currentImplementation: 'Protocol Orchestrator Pattern',
assessmentVersion: '1.0.0'
},
categories: {
coreInfrastructure: {
name: 'Core Infrastructure',
priority: 'CRITICAL',
features: [],
score: 0,
maxScore: 0
},
protocolSupport: {
name: 'Protocol Support',
priority: 'HIGH',
features: [],
score: 0,
maxScore: 0
},
mcpCompatibility: {
name: 'MCP Server Compatibility',
priority: 'CRITICAL',
features: [],
score: 0,
maxScore: 0
},
configuration: {
name: 'Configuration Management',
priority: 'MEDIUM',
features: [],
score: 0,
maxScore: 0
},
advancedFeatures: {
name: 'Advanced Features',
priority: 'LOW',
features: [],
score: 0,
maxScore: 0
}
},
overallAssessment: {
totalScore: 0,
maxScore: 0,
compatibilityPercentage: 0,
status: 'UNKNOWN',
riskLevel: 'UNKNOWN'
},
recommendations: [],
criticalGaps: [],
regressionRisk: 'UNKNOWN'
};
function addFeature(category, name, status, weight = 1, details = '') {
const feature = {
name,
status, // 'PRESENT', 'PARTIAL', 'MISSING'
weight,
details,
score: status === 'PRESENT' ? weight : (status === 'PARTIAL' ? weight * 0.5 : 0)
};
report.categories[category].features.push(feature);
report.categories[category].score += feature.score;
report.categories[category].maxScore += weight;
}
function checkFileExists(filePath) {
return fs.existsSync(filePath);
}
function checkFileContains(filePath, searchString) {
if (!fs.existsSync(filePath)) return false;
try {
const content = fs.readFileSync(filePath, 'utf8');
return content.includes(searchString);
} catch {
return false;
}
}
console.log('📋 Analyzing Core Infrastructure...');
// Core Infrastructure Assessment
addFeature('coreInfrastructure', 'ConsoleManager Core',
checkFileExists('src/core/ConsoleManager.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 3,
'Main orchestrator class for console management');
addFeature('coreInfrastructure', 'Session Management',
checkFileExists('src/core/SessionManager.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 3,
'Session lifecycle and state management');
addFeature('coreInfrastructure', 'Connection Pooling',
checkFileExists('src/core/ConnectionPool.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'Advanced connection pooling with circuit breakers');
addFeature('coreInfrastructure', 'Health Monitoring',
checkFileExists('src/core/HealthMonitor.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'System health monitoring and alerts');
addFeature('coreInfrastructure', 'Error Detection',
checkFileExists('src/core/ErrorDetector.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'Intelligent error detection and recovery');
addFeature('coreInfrastructure', 'Stream Management',
checkFileExists('src/core/StreamManager.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'Real-time output streaming');
console.log('🔌 Analyzing Protocol Support...');
// Protocol Support Assessment
addFeature('protocolSupport', 'Local Shell Support',
checkFileExists('src/protocols/LocalProtocol.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 3,
'cmd, bash, powershell, pwsh, zsh, sh support');
addFeature('protocolSupport', 'SSH Protocol',
checkFileExists('src/protocols/SSHProtocol.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 3,
'SSH connection with advanced features');
addFeature('protocolSupport', 'Docker Protocol',
checkFileExists('src/protocols/DockerProtocol.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'Docker container management');
addFeature('protocolSupport', 'Kubernetes Protocol',
checkFileExists('src/protocols/KubernetesProtocol.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'Kubernetes exec, logs, port forwarding');
addFeature('protocolSupport', 'Protocol Factory',
checkFileExists('src/core/ProtocolFactory.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'Dynamic protocol instantiation');
addFeature('protocolSupport', 'Auto-detection',
checkFileContains('src/core/ProtocolFactory.ts', 'auto') ? 'PARTIAL' : 'MISSING', 1,
'Automatic protocol detection');
console.log('🛠️ Analyzing MCP Server Compatibility...');
// MCP Server Compatibility Assessment
const mcpServerExists = checkFileExists('src/mcp/server.ts');
addFeature('mcpCompatibility', 'MCP Server Implementation',
mcpServerExists ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 5,
'24 MCP tools for console automation');
addFeature('mcpCompatibility', 'Session Creation Tool',
checkFileContains('src/mcp/server.ts', 'console_create_session') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'console_create_session MCP tool');
addFeature('mcpCompatibility', 'Input/Output Tools',
checkFileContains('src/mcp/server.ts', 'console_send_input') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'console_send_input and console_get_output tools');
addFeature('mcpCompatibility', 'Profile Management Tools',
checkFileContains('src/mcp/server.ts', 'console_save_profile') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 1,
'Profile save/load/use tools');
addFeature('mcpCompatibility', 'Monitoring Tools',
checkFileContains('src/mcp/server.ts', 'console_get_system_metrics') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 1,
'System and session monitoring tools');
console.log('⚙️ Analyzing Configuration Management...');
// Configuration Management Assessment
addFeature('configuration', 'Config Manager',
checkFileExists('src/core/ConfigManager.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'Configuration management system');
addFeature('configuration', 'Profile System',
checkFileContains('src/mcp/server.ts', 'profile') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 2,
'Connection and application profiles');
addFeature('configuration', 'Diagnostics Manager',
checkFileExists('src/core/DiagnosticsManager.ts') ? 'PRESENT' : 'MISSING', 1,
'Diagnostics and monitoring configuration');
console.log('🚀 Analyzing Advanced Features...');
// Advanced Features Assessment (from backup)
addFeature('advancedFeatures', 'Self-Healing', 'MISSING', 2,
'Automatic failure recovery system');
addFeature('advancedFeatures', 'Predictive Healing', 'MISSING', 1,
'Proactive issue prevention');
addFeature('advancedFeatures', 'Session Persistence', 'MISSING', 2,
'State restoration across restarts');
addFeature('advancedFeatures', 'Network Adaptation', 'MISSING', 1,
'Quality-based timeout adjustment');
addFeature('advancedFeatures', 'Hardware Integration', 'MISSING', 1,
'Serial devices, IPMI/BMC support');
addFeature('advancedFeatures', 'File Transfer', 'MISSING', 1,
'SFTP upload/download capabilities');
// Calculate overall scores
report.overallAssessment.totalScore = Object.values(report.categories)
.reduce((sum, cat) => sum + cat.score, 0);
report.overallAssessment.maxScore = Object.values(report.categories)
.reduce((sum, cat) => sum + cat.maxScore, 0);
report.overallAssessment.compatibilityPercentage = Math.round(
(report.overallAssessment.totalScore / report.overallAssessment.maxScore) * 100
);
// Determine status and risk level
const compatibility = report.overallAssessment.compatibilityPercentage;
if (compatibility >= 90) {
report.overallAssessment.status = 'EXCELLENT';
report.overallAssessment.riskLevel = 'LOW';
} else if (compatibility >= 75) {
report.overallAssessment.status = 'GOOD';
report.overallAssessment.riskLevel = 'MEDIUM';
} else if (compatibility >= 50) {
report.overallAssessment.status = 'MODERATE';
report.overallAssessment.riskLevel = 'HIGH';
} else {
report.overallAssessment.status = 'POOR';
report.overallAssessment.riskLevel = 'CRITICAL';
}
// Identify critical gaps
Object.values(report.categories).forEach(category => {
if (category.priority === 'CRITICAL') {
category.features.forEach(feature => {
if (feature.status === 'MISSING' && feature.weight >= 2) {
report.criticalGaps.push(`${category.name}: ${feature.name}`);
}
});
}
});
// Generate recommendations
if (compatibility < 60) {
report.recommendations.push('IMMEDIATE: Restore critical missing features before production use');
}
if (report.criticalGaps.length > 0) {
report.recommendations.push('HIGH: Address critical gaps in core infrastructure');
}
if (compatibility < 80) {
report.recommendations.push('MEDIUM: Plan comprehensive feature restoration roadmap');
}
// Assess regression risk
if (compatibility < 50) {
report.regressionRisk = 'SEVERE';
} else if (compatibility < 70) {
report.regressionRisk = 'HIGH';
} else if (compatibility < 85) {
report.regressionRisk = 'MODERATE';
} else {
report.regressionRisk = 'LOW';
}
// Display results
console.log('\n📊 COMPATIBILITY ASSESSMENT RESULTS');
console.log('===================================');
Object.values(report.categories).forEach(category => {
const score = Math.round((category.score / category.maxScore) * 100);
const icon = score >= 80 ? '✅' : score >= 60 ? '⚠️' : '❌';
console.log(`${icon} ${category.name}: ${score}% (${category.score}/${category.maxScore} points)`);
});
console.log(`\n🎯 Overall Compatibility: ${compatibility}%`);
console.log(`🚦 Status: ${report.overallAssessment.status}`);
console.log(`⚠️ Risk Level: ${report.overallAssessment.riskLevel}`);
console.log(`📉 Regression Risk: ${report.regressionRisk}`);
if (report.criticalGaps.length > 0) {
console.log('\n❌ CRITICAL GAPS IDENTIFIED:');
report.criticalGaps.forEach(gap => console.log(` - ${gap}`));
}
if (report.recommendations.length > 0) {
console.log('\n💡 RECOMMENDATIONS:');
report.recommendations.forEach(rec => console.log(` - ${rec}`));
}
console.log('\n📋 DETAILED ANALYSIS:');
console.log('====================');
Object.values(report.categories).forEach(category => {
console.log(`\n${category.name} (${category.priority} Priority):`);
category.features.forEach(feature => {
const icon = feature.status === 'PRESENT' ? '✅' :
feature.status === 'PARTIAL' ? '⚠️' : '❌';
console.log(` ${icon} ${feature.name}: ${feature.status} ${feature.details ? `- ${feature.details}` : ''}`);
});
});
// Save comprehensive report
const reportPath = `final-compatibility-assessment-${Date.now()}.json`;
fs.writeFileSync(reportPath, JSON.stringify(report, null, 2));
console.log(`\n📁 Full report saved to: ${reportPath}`);
console.log(`✨ Assessment complete - ${compatibility}% compatibility achieved`);
process.exit(0);