# Quality Checklist: Playwright UX Tests
**Feature**: 002-playwright-ux-tests
**Spec Version**: Draft (Clarified)
**Checklist Created**: 2025-12-10
**Last Updated**: 2025-12-10 (post-clarification)
## Specification Completeness
### User Stories
- [x] At least 3 user stories defined with clear value proposition
- [x] Stories prioritized (P1, P2, P3)
- [x] Each story has acceptance scenarios in Given/When/Then format
- [x] Independence criterion explained for each story
- [x] Edge cases identified
### Requirements
- [x] Functional requirements listed with unique IDs (FR-001 to FR-010)
- [x] Key entities identified
- [x] Non-functional requirements addressed (timeouts, performance)
- [x] Flakiness handling strategy defined (FR-009: fail-fast)
- [x] Execution model defined (FR-010: single conversation)
### Success Criteria
- [x] Measurable outcomes defined (SC-001 to SC-005)
- [x] Criteria are testable and quantifiable
- [x] Clear pass/fail thresholds established
### Assumptions
- [x] Technical assumptions documented
- [x] Infrastructure dependencies noted
- [x] External service dependencies identified
## Technical Validation
### Playwright MCP Compatibility
- [x] Tests designed for Playwright MCP tool execution
- [x] Test scenarios use standard browser interactions (navigate, click, type)
- [x] Screenshot capture included for debugging
- [x] Appropriate timeout values specified (10s page load, 30s AI response)
### Application Coverage
- [x] Page load/accessibility test (P1)
- [x] Button functionality tests (P1)
- [x] Text input tests (P2)
- [x] Element verification tests (P2)
- [x] State reset tests (P3)
### Test Design Quality
- [x] Tests are independent and can run in isolation
- [x] Tests target stable UI elements (titles, roles, data-testid where applicable)
- [x] Flakiness considerations addressed (fail-fast, CI retry)
- [x] Error handling scenarios covered
## Clarifications Applied (Session 2025-12-10)
| Question | Answer | Requirement Added |
|----------|--------|-------------------|
| Flaky failure handling strategy | Fail fast, CI handles retry | FR-009 |
| Test execution model | Single conversation, sequential | FR-010 |
## Validation Results
| Criterion | Status | Notes |
|-----------|--------|-------|
| User Stories Complete | PASS | 5 stories with clear acceptance criteria |
| Requirements Traceable | PASS | FR-001 through FR-010 defined |
| Success Criteria Measurable | PASS | SC-001 through SC-005 with numeric thresholds |
| Playwright Compatible | PASS | Standard browser automation patterns |
| Edge Cases Covered | PASS | Timeout, network, and error scenarios |
| Clarifications Integrated | PASS | 2 questions answered, requirements updated |
## Recommendation
**Status**: READY FOR PLANNING
The specification is complete and clarified. Ready for:
- `/speckit.plan` - To create implementation plan for the test suite
