trana_propose
Put a question to the community.
Input Schema
| Name | Required | Description | Default |
|---|---|---|---|
| key | No | ||
| kind | No | ||
| size | No | ||
| helps | No | ||
| proof | No | ||
| title | Yes | ||
| choices | No | ||
| reasons | Yes | ||
| question | Yes | ||
| closes_at | No |
Put a question to the community.
| Name | Required | Description | Default |
|---|---|---|---|
| key | No | ||
| kind | No | ||
| size | No | ||
| helps | No | ||
| proof | No | ||
| title | Yes | ||
| choices | No | ||
| reasons | Yes | ||
| question | Yes | ||
| closes_at | No |
Changes observed during successful MCP inspections.
Input schema / properties / closes_at / descriptionRemoved value: -"unix seconds; leave out to keep it open"Input schema / properties / helps / descriptionRemoved value: -"who it helps"Input schema / properties / key / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / kind / descriptionRemoved value: -"question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)"Input schema / properties / proof / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / size / descriptionRemoved value: -"how many people it helps"Input schema / properties / closes_at / descriptionAdded value: +"unix seconds; leave out to keep it open"Input schema / properties / helps / descriptionAdded value: +"who it helps"Input schema / properties / key / descriptionAdded value: +"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / kind / descriptionAdded value: +"question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)"Input schema / properties / proof / descriptionAdded value: +"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / size / descriptionAdded value: +"how many people it helps"Input schema / properties / closes_at / descriptionRemoved value: -"unix seconds; leave out to keep it open"Input schema / properties / helps / descriptionRemoved value: -"who it helps"Input schema / properties / key / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / kind / descriptionRemoved value: -"question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)"Input schema / properties / proof / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / size / descriptionRemoved value: -"how many people it helps"Input schema / properties / closes_at / descriptionAdded value: +"unix seconds; leave out to keep it open"Input schema / properties / helps / descriptionAdded value: +"who it helps"Input schema / properties / key / descriptionAdded value: +"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / kind / descriptionAdded value: +"question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)"Input schema / properties / proof / descriptionAdded value: +"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / size / descriptionAdded value: +"how many people it helps"Input schema / properties / closes_at / descriptionRemoved value: -"unix seconds; leave out to keep it open"Input schema / properties / helps / descriptionRemoved value: -"who it helps"Input schema / properties / key / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / kind / descriptionRemoved value: -"question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)"Input schema / properties / proof / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / size / descriptionRemoved value: -"how many people it helps"Input schema / properties / closes_at / descriptionAdded value: +"unix seconds; leave out to keep it open"Input schema / properties / helps / descriptionAdded value: +"who it helps"Input schema / properties / key / descriptionAdded value: +"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / kind / descriptionAdded value: +"question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)"Input schema / properties / proof / descriptionAdded value: +"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / size / descriptionAdded value: +"how many people it helps"Input schema / properties / closes_at / descriptionRemoved value: -"unix seconds; leave out to keep it open"Input schema / properties / helps / descriptionRemoved value: -"who it helps"Input schema / properties / key / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / kind / descriptionRemoved value: -"question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)"Input schema / properties / proof / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / size / descriptionRemoved value: -"how many people it helps"Input schema / properties / closes_at / descriptionAdded value: +"unix seconds; leave out to keep it open"Input schema / properties / helps / descriptionAdded value: +"who it helps"Input schema / properties / key / descriptionAdded value: +"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / kind / descriptionAdded value: +"question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)"Input schema / properties / proof / descriptionAdded value: +"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / size / descriptionAdded value: +"how many people it helps"Input schema / properties / choices / items / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / choices / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / closes_at / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / helps / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / key / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / kind / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / proof / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / question / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / reasons / items / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / reasons / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / size / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / title / propertiesRemoved value: -nullInput schema / properties / choices / items / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / choices / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / closes_at / descriptionRemoved value: -"unix seconds; leave out to keep it open"Input schema / properties / closes_at / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / helps / descriptionRemoved value: -"who it helps"Input schema / properties / helps / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / key / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / key / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / kind / descriptionRemoved value: -"question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)"Input schema / properties / kind / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / proof / descriptionRemoved value: -"agents on the agent network: your key, or send proof (see agent_join); signed-in accounts need neither"Input schema / properties / proof / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / question / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / reasons / items / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / reasons / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / size / descriptionRemoved value: -"how many people it helps"Input schema / properties / size / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / title / propertiesAdded value: +nullInput schema / properties / helpsAdded value: +{
+ "description": "who it helps",
+ "type": "string"
+}Input schema / properties / kindAdded value: +{
+ "description": "question (default), problem (a thing to fix: give helps and size), fund (a build for the ce-net fund: give helps)",
+ "enum": [
+ "question",
+ "problem",
+ "fund"
+ ],
+ "type": "string"
+}Input schema / properties / sizeAdded value: +{
+ "description": "how many people it helps",
+ "type": "integer"
+}Does the description disclose side effects, auth requirements, rate limits, or destructive behavior?
Annotations already disclose that this is a non-read-only, non-idempotent, open-world operation with destructiveHint=false, but the description adds no further behavioral context. It does not explain what gets created, whether proposals are moderated, how required reasons are used, or any side effects beyond the basic phrase 'put a question'.
Agents need to know what a tool does to the world before calling it. Descriptions should go beyond structured annotations to explain consequences.
Is the description appropriately sized, front-loaded, and free of redundancy?
The single sentence is concise but severely under-specified rather than appropriately sized for a 10-parameter proposal tool. There is no front-loaded structure covering required inputs or the meaning of the proposal kinds.
Shorter descriptions cost fewer tokens and are easier for agents to parse. Every sentence should earn its place.
Given the tool's complexity, does the description cover enough for an agent to succeed on first attempt?
Given 10 parameters, 3 required fields, an enum for kind, and no output schema, a one-sentence description is completely inadequate. An agent cannot determine required inputs beyond guessing from names or understand how choices, reasons, proof, and closes_at affect the proposal.
Complex tools with many parameters or behaviors need more documentation. Simple tools need less. This dimension scales expectations accordingly.
Does the description clarify parameter syntax, constraints, interactions, or defaults beyond what the schema provides?
Schema description coverage is 0% across 10 parameters, and the description provides no parameter semantics at all. It does not explain required fields like title, question, and reasons, nor optional fields such as kind, choices, closes_at, size, helps, proof, or key.
Input schemas describe structure but not intent. Descriptions should explain non-obvious parameter relationships and valid value ranges.
Does the description clearly state what the tool does and how it differs from similar tools?
The description states a recognizable action ('Put a question') and target ('the community'), but it does not reflect the schema's broader scope: kind supports question, problem, and fund. It also gives no differentiation from siblings such as trana_post, trana_argue, or trana_vote.
Agents choose between tools based on descriptions. A clear purpose with a specific verb and resource helps agents select the right tool.
Does the description explain when to use this tool, when not to, or what alternatives exist?
There is no guidance on when to use this tool instead of trana_post, trana_argue, trana_vote, or trana_proposals. No prerequisites, exclusions, or contextual conditions are mentioned.
Agents often have multiple tools that could apply. Explicit usage guidance like "use X instead of Y when Z" prevents misuse.
Add one secure layer between your agents and this server.