Skip to main content
Glama

Senaro Personal Finance

Payoff Strategy Comparison

compare_payoff_strategies
Read-onlyIdempotent

Calculation, not advice. Verify with a professional before acting. Compare avalanche and snowball payoff strategies side-by-side. Pick this to compare avalanche against snowball ordering on the same set of cards; pick calculate_cc_payoff once a strategy is chosen and the need is a single payoff timeline with windfalls or fixed payments.

Returns months, total interest, payoff order, savings, total_balance, weighted_average_apr_pct, monthly_interest_now, and cost_breakdown array. When an arm is not projected to reach a zero balance, the savings.* fields for that arm carry status: "none" with value: null and an explanation, not a number.

savings.strategies_convergence separately discloses the avalanche/snowball arms' own convergence:

  • "both_converge" (ordinary case),

  • "worst_never_amortizes" (the losing strategy arm does not reach a zero balance in this projection but the winning arm does, so savings.best_vs_worst_months/interest carry status: "none"), or

  • "neither_converges" (the WINNING strategy arm does not reach a zero balance either, so no dollar or month figure derived from either strategy arm is reportable).

lower_total_interest_strategy names whichever of avalanche or snowball has the lower total interest, or "tie" when the two arms' total interest and months are exactly equal. A "tie" can co-occur with savings.strategies_convergence="neither_converges". It reports only that comparison, never that either arm pays off.

chart_hints.title and chart_hints.annotations[0].label report a dollar figure only when the comparison they describe is Defined, and otherwise state plainly that no figure is reportable, matching the "none" status on the corresponding savings.* field. Unlike chart_hints, summary and savings.savings_summary hedge rather than decline a figure, and the two always carry the same sentence as each other: when the compared arm does not converge (savings.baseline_never_amortizes=true, or savings.strategies_convergence=worst_never_amortizes) but the winning side still does, both report a figure hedged as a floor, "saves at least $X and N months ..., so the true saving could be higher than reported". Only when strategies_convergence=neither_converges do summary and savings.savings_summary also state that no figure is reportable. No savings.* sentinel object carries a hedged floor in its value key; the only place a floor ever appears is the savings.savings_summary sentence.

This tool carries no domain-shaped warnings[].type entries (unlike calculate_cc_payoff); warnings[] here is exclusively validation disclosures emitted as warnings[].code, e.g. MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING_IN_BASELINE plus the general portfolio findings (MANY_CARDS, HIGH_CARD_BALANCE, etc.) shared with every card-based tool.

The response includes chart_hints with rendering directives any client can use.

This tool takes no strategy, fixed_payments, full_schedule or per_segment parameter: it always compares avalanche against snowball over the full schedule, so all four are rejected as unknown_parameter.

Tool call template

Replace each placeholder with a value matching the input schema. Only required parameters are included; add optional parameters as needed.

{
  "id": 1,
  "jsonrpc": "2.0",
  "method": "tools/call",
  "params": {
    "arguments": {
      "cards": "<cards>"
    },
    "name": "compare_payoff_strategies"
  }
}

Input Schema

NameRequiredDescriptionDefault
cardsYesCredit cards to compare, 1 to 20, the same shape calculate_cc_payoff takes. Required: omitting the field answers contract_error MISSING_REQUIRED_FIELD, while an explicit JSON null answers parse_error ("cards is required and must be an array."); the two are not the same rejection. Every card may carry segments[]. Max 100 segments total across all cards in the request. Per-card, per-type caps: 1 purchase, 1 cash_advance, 5 balance_transfer, 1 promotional, 10 installment_plan.
outputNoValid values: 'summary' (default), 'inline'. summary returns the headline comparison with a data_preview block; inline returns the full payload.
chart_titleNoOverride for the chart title. Optional; must not contain an em dash or en dash. Max 120 characters.
apply_rate_capNoWhether to cap each card's APR at the regulatory ceiling before simulating. Optional; defaults to false when omitted.
extra_monthly_paymentNoExtra monthly payment in dollars, $0 to $1,000,000,000, available each month on top of the required minimums to the balances that take extra payment; a balance with extra_payment_order 0 receives none of it. Optional; defaults to 0 when omitted.

Schema Changelog

Changes observed during successful MCP inspections.

  1. Changed3 schema fields changed
    • changedInput schema / properties / cards / items / properties / minimum_payment / description
      Previous value: -"Minimum payment in dollars, $0 to $1,000,000,000 (optional, omit or set 0 to auto-calculate). Where it binds, the card is locked at max(minimum_payment, that card's issuer minimum computed at month 1), and that locked amount is paid every month. On calculate_cc_payoff it binds ONLY when fixed_payments = true; on the DEFAULT path (fixed_payments = false) it is NOT used, because the plan recomputes each card's issuer minimum from its current balance every month, and the response discloses that as MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING. On compare_payoff_strategies there is no fixed_payments parameter and supplying one is rejected: the avalanche and snowball arms ALWAYS run locked, so the value binds in both arms wherever it is higher than that card's month-1 issuer minimum, while the minimum-payments-only baseline always recomputes and ignores it, disclosed as MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING_IN_BASELINE."New value: +"Minimum payment in dollars, $0 to $1,000,000,000 (optional, omit or set 0 to auto-calculate). Where it binds, the card's monthly budget is locked at max(minimum_payment, that card's issuer minimum computed at month 1); the card pays no more of it than its balances take. On calculate_cc_payoff it binds ONLY when fixed_payments = true; on the DEFAULT path (fixed_payments = false) it is NOT used, because the plan recomputes each card's issuer minimum from its current balance every month, and the response discloses that as MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING. On compare_payoff_strategies there is no fixed_payments parameter and supplying one is rejected: the avalanche and snowball arms ALWAYS run locked, so the value binds in both arms wherever it is higher than that card's month-1 issuer minimum, while the minimum-payments-only baseline always recomputes and ignores it, disclosed as MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING_IN_BASELINE."
    • changedInput schema / properties / cards / items / properties / segments / items / properties / min_payment_order / description
      Previous value: -"Minimum-payment tie-break priority, 1 or more. Optional on every type. The minimum first pays any installment_plan's locked plan_payment_due in full, then the lowest-current-APR segment; this value only breaks a tie between segments sharing both the same current APR and the same installment-plan status."New value: +"Minimum-payment tie-break priority, 1 or more. Optional on every type. The minimum first pays each installment_plan its locked plan_payment_due, or its balance if smaller, then the lowest-current-APR segment; this value only breaks a tie between segments sharing both the same current APR and the same installment-plan status."
    • changedInput schema / properties / extra_monthly_payment / description
      Previous value: -"Extra monthly payment in dollars, $0 to $1,000,000,000, applied on top of the required minimums. Optional; defaults to 0 when omitted."New value: +"Extra monthly payment in dollars, $0 to $1,000,000,000, available each month on top of the required minimums to the balances that take extra payment; a balance with extra_payment_order 0 receives none of it. Optional; defaults to 0 when omitted."
  2. Changed1 schema field changed
    • changedInput schema / properties / cards / items / properties / minimum_payment / description
      Previous value: -"Minimum payment in dollars, $0 to $1,000,000,000 (optional, omit or set 0 to auto-calculate). Where it binds, the card is locked at max(minimum_payment, that card's issuer minimum computed at month 1), and that locked amount is paid every month. On calculate_cc_payoff it binds ONLY when fixed_payments = true; on the DEFAULT path (fixed_payments = false) it is NOT used, because the plan recomputes each card's issuer minimum from its current balance every month, and the response discloses that as MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING. On compare_payoff_strategies there is no fixed_payments parameter and supplying one is rejected: the avalanche and snowball arms ALWAYS run locked, so the value DOES bind and moves both arms, while the minimum-payments-only baseline always recomputes and ignores it, disclosed as MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING_IN_BASELINE."New value: +"Minimum payment in dollars, $0 to $1,000,000,000 (optional, omit or set 0 to auto-calculate). Where it binds, the card is locked at max(minimum_payment, that card's issuer minimum computed at month 1), and that locked amount is paid every month. On calculate_cc_payoff it binds ONLY when fixed_payments = true; on the DEFAULT path (fixed_payments = false) it is NOT used, because the plan recomputes each card's issuer minimum from its current balance every month, and the response discloses that as MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING. On compare_payoff_strategies there is no fixed_payments parameter and supplying one is rejected: the avalanche and snowball arms ALWAYS run locked, so the value binds in both arms wherever it is higher than that card's month-1 issuer minimum, while the minimum-payments-only baseline always recomputes and ignores it, disclosed as MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING_IN_BASELINE."
  3. Changed5 schema fields changed
    • changedInput schema / properties / cards / items / properties / cash_advance_apr_pct / description
      Previous value: -"Cash advance APR as a percentage, greater than 0 and up to 100. Required when cash_advance_balance is greater than 0: cash advances have no promotional 0% product, so a 0% rate on a real advance balance is a data-entry error."New value: +"Cash advance APR as a percentage, greater than 0 and up to 100. Required when cash_advance_balance is greater than 0. These flat fields have no promo input, so 0 is rejected: nothing would say when a 0% rate ends. For a promotional cash advance, such as a 0% direct-deposit or check offer, use segments[] with a cash_advance segment carrying promo_expires_month and revert_apr_pct."
    • changedInput schema / properties / cards / items / properties / segments / items / properties / apr_pct / description
      Previous value: -"Annual percentage rate for this segment, 0 to 100, e.g. 24.99 not 0.2499. Required when balance is greater than 0 on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer and promotional. On cash_advance it must be greater than 0 whenever a balance is carried. Must be 0 on installment_plan, which uses monthly_fee instead, so omitting it there is the correct shape."New value: +"Annual percentage rate for this segment, 0 to 100, e.g. 24.99 not 0.2499. Required when balance is greater than 0 on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer and promotional. On cash_advance with a balance it must be supplied and greater than 0, unless the segment also carries a usable promo_expires_month and revert_apr_pct: then it is the promotional rate and may be 0. Must be 0 on installment_plan, which uses monthly_fee instead, so omitting it there is the correct shape."
    • changedInput schema / properties / cards / items / properties / segments / items / properties / promo_expires_month / description
      Previous value: -"Month at which apr_pct flips to revert_apr_pct, 1 to 480. Required on balance_transfer and promotional. Ignored on purchase, cash_advance and installment_plan."New value: +"Last month charged at apr_pct, 1 to 480; revert_apr_pct applies from the next month. Month 1 is the first statement cycle after the statement the balance comes from. From a statement, count the closing dates after it, up to and including the last one on or before the promo end date; a cycle the end date splits counts at revert_apr_pct. If no closing date qualifies, the promo ends inside month 1: enter the post-promo rate as both apr_pct and revert_apr_pct, with promo_expires_month 1. Required on balance_transfer and promotional. On cash_advance, supply it with revert_apr_pct, under the rule stated on revert_apr_pct. Ignored on purchase and installment_plan."
    • changedInput schema / properties / cards / items / properties / segments / items / properties / revert_apr_pct / description
      Previous value: -"Rate this segment reverts to once its promo expires, 0 to 100, and at least apr_pct. Required on balance_transfer and promotional. Ignored on purchase and cash_advance. Rejected on installment_plan with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE: an expired plan's residual keeps its existing rate rather than repricing."New value: +"Rate this segment reverts to once its promo expires, 0 to 100, and at least apr_pct: the post-promo APR the offer disclosed, wherever the offer or the statement prints it. Only when neither prints one for this balance, take the regular rate of this balance's category, not the promo rate. A direct-deposit or check cash advance reverts to the cash-advance APR for those advances, which can differ from the bank cash-advance APR and is not the balance-transfer APR. Required on balance_transfer and promotional. On cash_advance, supply it with promo_expires_month: alone or invalid, the pair is not used and an INPUT_NOT_USED warning says why, except at an apr_pct of 0 with a balance, where the request is rejected. Ignored on purchase. Rejected on installment_plan with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE: an expired plan's residual keeps its existing rate rather than repricing."
    • changedInput schema / properties / cards / items / properties / segments / items / properties / type / description
      Previous value: -"Segment type. REQUIRED on every segment: omitting it is rejected. Per-type field matrix. Every field below is classified for every segment type: REQUIRED (omitting it is rejected), OPTIONAL (accepted either way and read), IGNORED (accepted and never read for this type, though a value can still fail the field's own range check), or REJECTED (supplying a disallowed value is an error; the field's own rule below says exactly which values are disallowed). Value rules are stated separately from applicability, because a field can be accepted on a type and still be restricted there. The validators are the authority; this matrix describes them.\n- type: REQUIRED on every type. Values: one of purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional, installment_plan.\n- balance: REQUIRED on every type. Values: $0 to $1,000,000,000; above $50,000 returns a HIGH_CARD_BALANCE warning, not an error.\n- apr_pct: REQUIRED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional; OPTIONAL on installment_plan. Values: 0 to 100 as a percentage, e.g. 24.99 not 0.2499. The REQUIRED classification above applies when balance is greater than 0; a zero-balance segment may omit it. Must be greater than 0 on cash_advance carrying a balance. Must equal 0 on installment_plan, where omitting it is the correct shape.\n- revert_apr_pct: REQUIRED on balance_transfer, promotional; IGNORED on purchase, cash_advance; REJECTED on installment_plan. Values: 0 to 100, and at least apr_pct. Rejected on installment_plan with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE: an expired plan's residual keeps its existing rate.\n- promo_expires_month: REQUIRED on balance_transfer, promotional; IGNORED on purchase, cash_advance, installment_plan. Values: 1 to 480.\n- monthly_fee: OPTIONAL on installment_plan; REJECTED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional. Values: $0 or more, and no greater than plan_payment_due, on installment_plan. On every other type a POSITIVE value is rejected with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE; 0 and a negative value are accepted and dropped there.\n- plan_payment_due: REQUIRED on installment_plan; REJECTED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional. Values: greater than $0, at least monthly_fee, and no more than $1,000,000,000, on installment_plan. On every other type a POSITIVE value is rejected with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE; 0 and a negative value are accepted and dropped there.\n- remaining_payments: OPTIONAL on installment_plan; IGNORED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional. Values: 0 or more. 0 means the stated term has ALREADY ended and is valid with any balance. From 1 up, balance must be clearable within the stated term.\n- min_payment_order: OPTIONAL on every type. Values: 1 or more; breaks a tie only between segments sharing both the same current APR and the same installment-plan status.\n- extra_payment_order: OPTIONAL on every type. Values: 0 or more; 0 means skip. Breaks a tie only between segments sharing the exact same current APR.\n- merchant_name: OPTIONAL on installment_plan; IGNORED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional. Values: 120 characters or fewer.\n- monthly_spend: OPTIONAL on purchase; REJECTED on cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional, installment_plan. Values: $0 to $50,000 per month. A negative value is rejected as NEGATIVE_BALANCE on every type, purchase included. On every type other than purchase a POSITIVE value is rejected with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE; an explicit 0 is accepted.\n- stop_spend_month: OPTIONAL on purchase; IGNORED on cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional, installment_plan. Values: 0 or more; range checked on every type, read only on purchase."New value: +"Segment type. REQUIRED on every segment: omitting it is rejected. Per-type field matrix. Every field below is classified for every segment type: REQUIRED (omitting it is rejected), OPTIONAL (accepted either way and read), PAIRED (read when supplied together with its partner as a usable pair: promo_expires_month and revert_apr_pct both supplied beside a supplied apr_pct, each within its value rule; a pair that is not usable is rejected when the segment carries a balance and its apr_pct is omitted, 0 or below, and otherwise is not used, with an INPUT_NOT_USED warning; omitting both, or sending both as null, is accepted), IGNORED (accepted and never read for this type, though a value can still fail the field's own range check), or REJECTED (supplying a disallowed value is an error; the field's own rule below says exactly which values are disallowed). Value rules are stated separately from applicability, because a field can be accepted on a type and still be restricted there. The validators are the authority; this matrix describes them.\n- type: REQUIRED on every type. Values: one of purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional, installment_plan.\n- balance: REQUIRED on every type. Values: $0 to $1,000,000,000; above $50,000 returns a HIGH_CARD_BALANCE warning, not an error.\n- apr_pct: REQUIRED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional; OPTIONAL on installment_plan. Values: 0 to 100 as a percentage, e.g. 24.99 not 0.2499. The REQUIRED classification above applies when balance is greater than 0; a zero-balance segment may omit it. Must be greater than 0 on cash_advance carrying a balance, unless that segment carries a usable promo pair (promo_expires_month and revert_apr_pct). Must equal 0 on installment_plan, where omitting it is the correct shape.\n- revert_apr_pct: REQUIRED on balance_transfer, promotional; PAIRED on cash_advance; IGNORED on purchase; REJECTED on installment_plan. Values: 0 to 100, and at least apr_pct. Rejected on installment_plan with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE: an expired plan's residual keeps its existing rate.\n- promo_expires_month: REQUIRED on balance_transfer, promotional; PAIRED on cash_advance; IGNORED on purchase, installment_plan. Values: 1 to 480.\n- monthly_fee: OPTIONAL on installment_plan; REJECTED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional. Values: $0 or more, and no greater than plan_payment_due, on installment_plan. On every other type a POSITIVE value is rejected with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE; 0 and a negative value are accepted and dropped there.\n- plan_payment_due: REQUIRED on installment_plan; REJECTED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional. Values: greater than $0, at least monthly_fee, and no more than $1,000,000,000, on installment_plan. On every other type a POSITIVE value is rejected with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE; 0 and a negative value are accepted and dropped there.\n- remaining_payments: OPTIONAL on installment_plan; IGNORED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional. Values: 0 or more. 0 means the stated term has ALREADY ended and is valid with any balance. From 1 up, balance must be clearable within the stated term.\n- min_payment_order: OPTIONAL on every type. Values: 1 or more; breaks a tie only between segments sharing both the same current APR and the same installment-plan status.\n- extra_payment_order: OPTIONAL on every type. Values: 0 or more; 0 means skip. Breaks a tie only between segments sharing the exact same current APR.\n- merchant_name: OPTIONAL on installment_plan; IGNORED on purchase, cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional. Values: 120 characters or fewer.\n- monthly_spend: OPTIONAL on purchase; REJECTED on cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional, installment_plan. Values: $0 to $50,000 per month. A negative value is rejected as NEGATIVE_BALANCE on every type, purchase included. On every type other than purchase a POSITIVE value is rejected with FIELD_NOT_ALLOWED_HERE; an explicit 0 is accepted.\n- stop_spend_month: OPTIONAL on purchase; IGNORED on cash_advance, balance_transfer, promotional, installment_plan. Values: 0 or more; range checked on every type, read only on purchase."
  4. Added

TDQS

A4.5/5.0
Behavior4/5

Does the description disclose side effects, auth requirements, rate limits, or destructive behavior?

Annotations already declare readOnly/idempotent/non-destructive, and the description adds substantial behavior beyond them: convergence sentinel semantics, tie handling, the hedging rule for summary vs chart_hints, and that minimum_payment always binds in both arms while the baseline ignores it (MINIMUM_PAYMENT_NOT_BINDING_IN_BASELINE). It also discloses that warnings[] here carries only validation codes, not domain warnings. The only gap is that no rate-limit/compute-cost or performance context is offered for a full-schedule simulation.

Agents need to know what a tool does to the world before calling it. Descriptions should go beyond structured annotations to explain consequences.

Conciseness3/5

Is the description appropriately sized, front-loaded, and free of redundancy?

The purpose and sibling routing are correctly front-loaded, and the bulleted convergence-status list is well structured. However, the middle section is dense and repetitive about savings.* sentinels and chart_hints versus summary hedging, reading like an output-contract memo compressed into prose; with no output schema some of this is necessary, but it could be tighter.

Shorter descriptions cost fewer tokens and are easier for agents to parse. Every sentence should earn its place.

Completeness5/5

Given the tool's complexity, does the description cover enough for an agent to succeed on first attempt?

With no output schema, the description carries the full burden of return-value documentation and does so: it enumerates the returned fields, the status:'none' sentinel shape, the three strategies_convergence values, tie semantics, and the exact places a hedged floor may appear. For a comparison tool with 5 params and nested card/segment input, nothing an agent needs to interpret results correctly is missing.

Complex tools with many parameters or behaviors need more documentation. Simple tools need less. This dimension scales expectations accordingly.

Parameters4/5

Does the description clarify parameter syntax, constraints, interactions, or defaults beyond what the schema provides?

Schema coverage is 100%, so the baseline is 3; the description still adds meaning by noting that cards[] is 'the same shape calculate_cc_payoff takes' (1-20 cards) and that strategy, fixed_payments, full_schedule and per_segment are absent and rejected as unknown_parameter — information the schema cannot express. The minimum_payment binding behavior for this tool is also clarified here.

Input schemas describe structure but not intent. Descriptions should explain non-obvious parameter relationships and valid value ranges.

Purpose5/5

Does the description clearly state what the tool does and how it differs from similar tools?

Opens with a specific verb+resource: 'Compare avalanche and snowball payoff strategies side-by-side.' It explicitly distinguishes itself from the sibling calculate_cc_payoff by naming the condition that selects each, so an agent can route without opening either schema.

Agents choose between tools based on descriptions. A clear purpose with a specific verb and resource helps agents select the right tool.

Usage Guidelines5/5

Does the description explain when to use this tool, when not to, or what alternatives exist?

Gives explicit when-to-use guidance ('Pick this to compare avalanche against snowball ordering on the same set of cards') and names the alternative plus its selecting condition ('pick calculate_cc_payoff once a strategy is chosen and the need is a single payoff timeline with windfalls or fixed payments'). It also states which parameters this tool rejects, closing an obvious mis-call path.

Agents often have multiple tools that could apply. Explicit usage guidance like "use X instead of Y when Z" prevents misuse.

Try in Browser

Glama MCP Gateway

Add one secure layer between your agents and this server.

Resources